1 min silence for people who don't know this game.
2 min silence for people who know but don't have this game.
5 min silence for people who have but didn't play this game.
10 min silence for people who played but believe its overrated.
.
.
Indefinite silence for people who didn't like this game.

Rating: 10/10

One of the best single-player experiences I ever had. It's stylish, it's cowboi, it's immersive and it's emotional. This is sooo immersive that every place in its huge open world has its own secrets and encounters. There is always something interesting popping up wherever you go. Yeah seriously.

I even had a dream in real life where Dutch was saying "We just need more money"!

It took me 75-80 hours to just complete the main story with all the important side missions I found (87% plus total completion). And in that time, not even a single mission or exploration felt grind. Yeah, let me repeat NOT EVEN A SINGLE MISSION FELT GRIND. How they managed to pack sooo much content with so many minute details remains a mystery! Then it's full of replayability because, during missions and open-world activities, we have plenty of choices that change our honour, mission dialogues, ending, consequent effects, etc etc.

Regarding Red Dead Online, it has its own fun mission content which can be played in coop but I don't know how people are playing it because of its predatory microtransaction practice and hackers and grind. I haven't finished more than 25% of it.. yet already encountered UFO bombing me, hackers burning the ground, with flamed rabbit running and whatnot.. multiple times. Very unplayable at times. Then the distance between each main mission is so huge for that ♥♥♥♥ horse we are provided with that 70% of the time is spent in riding than actually playing missions. And to unlock real RDR2 online content, you either need to grind like hell or buy micro-transaction gold ♥♥♥♥. IMO, if you have low tolerance and patience like me, you will only enjoy Single Player RDR2.

For the single player, this experience makes people emotional and even cry... every video you see for this game is a spoiler. Please don't go through much, just get the game.
For the amount of quality time this game offers, it's really very underpriced.