24
Products
reviewed
706
Products
in account

Recent reviews by marbledCalico

Showing 1-10 of 24 entries
<123>
12 people found this review helpful
32.3 hrs on record (29.5 hrs at review time)
{TL;DR}
I wouldn't recommend it. It's repetitive in a bad way and the sim portion is shallow. The smithing portion and store management is missing a lot. I feel like it is a lesser supermarket together combined with a MMORPG's shallow gathering/crafting mechanic..

{Graphics}
I didn't play this for graphics, ultra isn't really that different from very low. Nothing crazy, In outside in the morning generally have lighting problems causing the light to overlap objects. I would highly recommend it being lowered because the Forest location causes me to lag like crazy.

{Gameplay}
The loop involves; gathering materials, crafting, active commissions/passive sales, and minor adventurer management.

Repetitive, which is normal for sim games, but the game doesn't introduce new gameplay mechanics for crafting as you level up. Crafting an iron sword is no different than crafting an endgame MOON SWORD. Usually in other sims as the game reaches a certain point new mechanics are introduced to become more difficult or provide a semblance of intricacy, but nothing new is introduced as you progress.

EVERY item takes 5 hits after heating it up, regardless of the size of the object. Also the conversion of an important object "Iron Parts" uses up a whole iron ingot, but I can also make a whole hammer head/blade/axe blade using 1 iron ingot as well. It doesn't feel right and the iron parts are in most recipes and vital for repairs. You can buy 20 per day and craft as many as there are iron in the mines. I wish there was a perk or as your level increases, you'd increase how many iron parts you can create and make the stack # higher for that to accommodate. Wood becomes almost useless as well as cloth later in the game.

They did add an update for one QoL that I noticed when it comes to construction of an object that speeds up gameplay. However I wish they did that with enchantment too since that can't be failed and just a statistical probability.

The Arena is pointless. The opponents SCALE with your adventurers REGARDLESS of tier of combat. You can still lose in the beginner league with endgame items.

For the Quest assignment. Only SOME traits affect the missions. I have adventurers with "Fire Soul", "Beast Tamer", and other ones that never show up being a trait for quests. Making them a little less viable, but it sucks that they never show up, even if it's a 90% success rate. The 10% still feels like a lot when the character is gone for 18 in-game hours.

The only "fun" part is the smithing minigame because the sweet spots are random and you have to use the hammer as a guide and guesstimate where it's going to hit. That's fun, but everything else it whatever.

{Audio}
I didn't really have this on, it's mostly just SFX and minimal background noise.

{Audience}
Fantasy Sim, If you wanted a blacksmithing experience in a fantasy setting.

{Game Size}
6.33 GB Nothing too crazy.

{Difficulty}
Casual

{Grind}
It's a sim, they're all grindy, but this one's grind isn't horrible.

{Story}
There's an introduction, but that's it. You meet the king and another dwarf as he gives you smithing orientation, but after that they are just there. Any possible story after you become established in your shop, becomes nonexistent. If you want a story, you won't find it here.

{Game Time}
It took me about 30 hrs to 100% the achievements. I would've stopped around 10 if I didn't think the achievements were easy to get.

{Price}
$11.99 USD, but if you really want to play it. I would only get it if it was on sale.

{Bugs}
During the smithing minigame, in order to enhance the rarity of the item, you hit a specific spot on the item. However, you need to be able to see the hammer to guesstimate where you'll hit, sometimes the hammer disappears. If you're not experienced you have to blindly hit and possibly miss. On a lot of thin objects the sweet spot is UNDER the item and barely visible.

There are problems with the 3rd & 4th levels of the mine that have visible holes to see through that breaks immersivity and you can see all the other places. You can't fall under them so it's not game breaking.

{Overall Score}
3 / 10
Posted September 8.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
 
A developer has responded on Oct 13 @ 4:03am (view response)
No one has rated this review as helpful yet
307.1 hrs on record (143.4 hrs at review time)
ROCK AND STONE. Incredible replayability, simple mechanics, adjustable difficulty, and the community doesn't make me feel anxious to play and communicate.
My first and favorite extraction based shooter.
Posted July 4, 2024.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
6 people found this review helpful
37.4 hrs on record
A charming, silly game. However, I can't get myself to complete it due to it's incredibly grindy, stale gameplay of clicking the screen until the HP sponges are dead. None of the enemies are unique and changing classes mid campaign is a hassle to get them up to the proper level, especially in the late game.
Posted June 24, 2024.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
No one has rated this review as helpful yet
162.8 hrs on record (137.4 hrs at review time)
Cute cultists that need to learn to poop in an outhouse that I made for them
Posted August 8, 2023.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
No one has rated this review as helpful yet
173.8 hrs on record (66.2 hrs at review time)
Grindier than I thought it was going to be, but it's pretty fun for now
Posted July 30, 2023.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
No one has rated this review as helpful yet
233.5 hrs on record (12.2 hrs at review time)
fun
Posted November 25, 2021.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
No one has rated this review as helpful yet
90.0 hrs on record (3.7 hrs at review time)
Monster waifus and husbandos
Posted November 5, 2021.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
No one has rated this review as helpful yet
417.2 hrs on record (15.7 hrs at review time)
I am so bad at this game :P
Posted November 26, 2020.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
No one has rated this review as helpful yet
9.5 hrs on record
There's very few people left to play with in the US area.
Posted May 25, 2020.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
No one has rated this review as helpful yet
4.2 hrs on record
Rusty Lake games are great for people who like puzzles that you would find in escape the room type games. I love puzzles like these.
Posted May 25, 2020.
Was this review helpful? Yes No Funny Award
Showing 1-10 of 24 entries
<123>