Which MH game wins over all?: Wilds, World or Rise.

[Rain]

What is your opinion on which of these games is the best overall?

[Muradin]

When wilds will get more content, it will probably be the best
Otherwise i love both rise and world differently

[lailaamell]

wilds seem to be closer to rise than worlds its less about tracking and hunting and more about fighting but gonna be honest world is better over all for it made me feel more like a hunter than a monster fighter

[Terron]

World for me so far out of those 3 but probably Generations Ultimate overall. Wonderful game. That said it is a bit unfair as wilds is only just out and we will have to see what balance changes they do as well as see how good (and hopefully challenging) the G rank stuff is for wilds. Enjoying wilds a ton so far though all the same. Love the wound system. The one thing world has over all other monster hunters is combat feel. Its the meatiest of all the games with its hitstop. My switchaxe though amazing in wilds with its awesome new offset attack and counter simply does not feel as good as in world with the extra hitstop and camera shake and sound effects and awesome zero sum discharge BOOM!!.

[sidray749]

None of them. MH4U is the peak of MH and it’s only going downhill ever since.

[Xlax]

Monster Hunter 4U is still my favourite out of all the games. Cross and double cross are the worst imho. I liked Rises movement and gameplay. It felt good, but I didn't find it as fun.

MH4U>MH3U>Rise>World>Wilds>>>>>Cross>>>>Double Cross
I've played a few others but they were psp and ps2 games

[Senki]

Rise is the best for me easily

[FarRisk]

I had more fun with RiseBreak.

[アンジェル]

Originally posted by Rain:

Which MH game wins over all?: Wilds, World or Rise.
What is your opinion on which of these games is the best overall?

Rise was best so far - but we have not seen the full Wilds yet. Only with the addon we can be sure, like back then when Icebourne blew my mind.

[ChisaiiNeko]

Originally posted by Rain:

What is your opinion on which of these games is the best overall?

I like Portable 3rd the most (bite me) but out of those 3, i like both World and Rise at the same level for different reasons. WIlds on the other hand is shaping up to become the best MH ever made. It's not there yet but with some work and some polish, it should overtake World & Rise after an expansion and a TU or 2.

It has all the foundations for such a rise (pun intended) to the top of the ranking (except to those with chronic nostalgia/rose-tinted glasses). And i say this as someone who has been playing since MH Freedom (Unite is where i spent the most hours with World being second place) which is the portable version of the first game in which LS was not a weapon type yet.

QoLs, streamlining of various mechanics while still keeping some complexity, letting you eat wherever, proper move forwards from the yucky claw tenderising mechanics, better skill mechanics, better deco grind, layered armour version crafted upon any HR armour crafted, an actual reason to go hunt tempered monsters beyond difficulty (and fun), a moving quest board (which sometimes needs to be chased down), very lively world (pun not intended this time) and fun distractions like fishing the big fishes.

[Misfit]

world is the best modern monster hunter so far, even with the horrible clutch claw.

rise was a fun power fantasy, but lacked any challenge

wilds is promising, but too easy. if they step it up with title updates and the expansion it could take the crown.

best monster hunter overall is generations ultimate imo

[Treyen]

Kinda unfair to compare them until the inevitable wilds expansion+title updates, but right now? world/iceborne

wilds has potential and I really like some of the new monsters, but it's held back by some weird design choices, like how focus mode completely breaks every melee weapon and makes the game a joke. Monsters just weren't designed to fight a hunter that can circle strafe them the entire fight and still be outputting full damage combos. Performance is also a serious issue for a lot of people that can't just brute force the game with money.

[Lunacy]

Some people are finishing Wilds seemingly fast, like just a couple dozen hours
while Worlds I had hundreds of hours before finishing or getting bored.

[GamingWithSilvertail]

Originally posted by lailaamell:

wilds seem to be closer to rise than worlds its less about tracking and hunting and more about fighting but gonna be honest world is better over all for it made me feel more like a hunter than a monster fighter

Once you had maxed out research on monsters which didnt take long it would insta pop on map too.

[Grishark]

I'd love to say Wilds, but the overall technical state of the game is so poor it's hard to do so.

[MrMeh]

Monster hunter 4 Ultimate.