Darkest Dungeon®

Darkest Dungeon®

Gyll's Vanilla: Musketeer
31 件のコメント
coffee 2024年6月23日 5時15分 
what is pure shard dust!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! i dont think its Shard Dust
ravenz 2024年5月31日 9時55分 
is this compatible with Musketeer Fixes?
wjingyao2008 2024年4月18日 23時43分 
just comment for my play experience
the dmg of musketeer was 7-14 at lv5 , this mod changes to 10-19

compare to the hellion is 10-19. i would say the aimed_shot skill was not weak at first looking,

but dealy indead.
wjingyao2008 2024年4月17日 19時11分 
reloads means skip one turn, and skill slot -1, the penalty is too strong compare to the one-use skill.
Hadouken Your Face 2022年7月6日 17時09分 
Agreed with the others saying that the reload gimmick isn't really justified given that her one-use skills aren't particularly strong. This is my favorite concept of the class, but all her damage skills ought to be buffed significantly due to this drawback.
Seagullathoth 2022年3月2日 1時54分 
I agree with @Reddragoon100. I love the idea of having to reload but the other skills need to be worth the one turn we have to skip. Especially since everything is once per battle. Have our basic do penetration, for instance.

Sidearm should move us back and not reload.
Shadowlurker4897 2022年2月9日 12時27分 
Finally a rework that doesnt just make the affected class overpowered!
Reddragoon100 2021年11月16日 13時53分 
What a wonderful idea for a class! I think the whole kit is absolutely brilliant! I think overall though it's a bit undertuned overall though; I think especially aimed shot just needs a straight damage buff (maybe to marked?). Since Rearm skips your turn it is just 100% of the time worse than sidearm. The buff to speed is very little and the buff to acc was the wrong choice because the base acc for all her other abilities is amazing. That being said the unique reload mechanic and the camps skills are all amazing.
Frigid 2021年1月26日 8時40分 
Hi! I made a SChinese translation for some of yours' class rework mod , hope you could include in next update :steamhappy:
Musketeer
https://paste.ubuntu.com/p/ySyHkRmw3N/
https://paste.ubuntu.com/p/sPrdwD49D3/

flagellant
https://paste.ubuntu.com/p/jfYtKQ63rC/

shieldbreaker
https://paste.ubuntu.com/p/BgPgfCSXbG/
Ze Ubermensch 2021年1月24日 20時09分 
@Dawnpromise

- I'll look into using misdirection with ripose but I forgot to mention in my first post that it would be a lot more valuable if it could be used from row 2.
- Sidearm HAS to be used in conjunction with Misdirection or another hero that can guard as it suffers from an accuracy penalty if you don't. As stated in the changelog, you don't get the reload if it misses but it has really good crit that it lets you do more single target dps than aimed shot.
- I suppose it's ok if she trades marking with the double stun.
Dawnpromise 2021年1月22日 22時34分 
@Ze Ubermench
I feel like many of your issue stem from the fact you're taking her skillset in isolation rather then looking at her synergy with other heroes:
-Misdirection is similar to the Antiquarian's "Guard Me" it's a good move to put on a riposte fighter such as the Man-at-Arms or Highwayman
-Sidearm is primarily a way to refresh skill uses but can also pair well with the Man-at-Arms for a damage buff as you noted. I personally don't feel it's meant as a self set up combo.
-She can't apply marks on her own, but in exchange she gains a double stun. A fair trade in my opinion as few heroes have this kind of ability.
- You complaint against Aimed Shot is valid as it isn't very good currently. Needs to at least be par with Arbalest if not better. It's okay if she steps on the Arbalest's toes a little since they've got so much setting them apart now already.
Ze Ubermensch 2021年1月22日 17時28分 
I like the concept of the mod so far but there's a few things I just can't wrap my head around:

- Aimed shot is overall garbage tier after your changes (mark damage doesn't scale to 90-100 like bounty hunter or Arbalest, lower crit, only being able to use it every other round at most)
- you took out her ability to apply mark (this is a big deal for her to have synergy with mark teams)
- Misdirection is another ability that's worthless. It takes two turns to use in conjunction with sidearm but if you don't plan to use it for that, it can only be used from row 3 and 4 where it would be a lot more valuable for use at

That aside though, I really like what you've done with percussive blast and buckshot, sidearm has also been fun to use with man at arms. The reload mechanic has potential but it needs some extra tuning.
M.P.K. 2020年6月5日 10時20分 
Turns out I am an idiot as I didn't have the musketeer dlc installed for some reason... my bad
M.P.K. 2020年6月3日 14時57分 
Hi I have a bug, when using the mod. I can't upgrade the musketeer's skills in the guild. When I drop her in, it will just display her flavor-text, but it shows no skills (not even the ones you own), it's just empty...
I love your reworks and hope you can help me solve this issue^^
Gyll  [作成者] 2020年5月16日 7時25分 
@Dawnpromise
Thank you! <3
Dawnpromise 2020年5月13日 12時12分 
Glad to hear it, also after trying this class out I really enjoy it. The powerful but limited use abilities with the reload mechanic give her a very unique flavor. Very strong in normal battle but falls of a lot in extended engagements. Also like how she can function closer to the front means you can team her up with other backline heroes. Great work!
Gyll  [作成者] 2020年5月11日 7時37分 
@Dawnpromise
Will do when I have time!
Dawnpromise 2020年5月5日 22時13分 
Well I don't see her trinket changes listed anywhere, could you list them somewhere? Since trinket changes are the biggest conflict I'm looking at I'd be nice if I could compare the changes.
Gyll  [作成者] 2020年5月5日 17時35分 
@Dawnpromise
Well this one's a bit different because Musk is basically just a skin in vanilla so I had to change more to make her different from Arb. If I don't change the trinkets then she has all the same trinkets as Arb and that really limits what I can do with her skills while still fitting the trinkets.

If you have a conflicting mod and you'd rather play with those town events/camp skills/trinkets you should be able to just put this mod on bottom and have the other mod overwrite and pretty much achieve that.

I think I still got about the maximum compatibility I could, that's just not as high because of the original role of the musk and the way the files are combined in the base game, I think most if not all musk reworks have this same issue.
Dawnpromise 2020年5月5日 0時13分 
Question: This mod seems to overwrite Trinket data which does put into conflict with other mods much more so then your other reworks. I'm curious as to those changes regarding those trinkets and the thought behind reworking them as it does seem to against your usual design pattern of maximum compatibility.
Gyll  [作成者] 2020年2月24日 17時26分 
@MerlinCross
Yes this works as a standalone mod, you don't need "Gyll's Vanilla: Heroes", I should maybe clarify that in the description.
MerlinCross 2020年2月24日 13時05分 
Could I use just this instead of the Collection? Cause I don't mind base game but having Musketeer be a reskin is just meh at the end of the day.
Nive 2020年2月7日 4時26分 
Hey Gyll, I'm thinking of getting into the mod scene myself. I asked you in the past how you felt about giving mod heroes the "Gyll's Vanilla" treatment and you weren't that interested, so I thought "Maybe I'll just do it myself". I'd love to have a chat and bounce some ideas around/share some notes/etc. It'd really help!
Earzentail 2020年1月11日 14時16分 
Looks pretty cool!
AceEquinox 2020年1月4日 7時36分 
I was looking through the files and noticed a seemingly identical copy of the base games event file(unless I missed something). You should remove it to maintain compatibility with mods that alter this file.
76561198129806621 2019年11月22日 8時19分 
Wow, I'm loving this mod!
Gyll  [作成者] 2019年11月11日 19時26分 
Thanks for the nice comments guys :) I hope everyone enjoys the mod.

@Nive
Thanks for convincing me to do this one in the first place! It's been so long that I almost forgot, I'll add you to the credits :)
ttk22 2019年11月11日 6時04分 
Finally! Thanks Gyll :)
Kope 2019年11月11日 5時01分 
It looks really good, mate.
Nive 2019年11月11日 3時38分 
Nicely done Gyll, she sounds amazing and incredibly unique!
Blustrum 2019年11月10日 23時52分 
Great.