Gemma makes no sense as a part of the main cast...

[AndyKills457]

I have multiple problems with the story, with it dragging out pointless scenes, palicoes not speaking their own language, and other minor details.

But personally I am really bothered by the fact that Gemma goes everywhere with the hunter, Alma makes sense since she's your handler, the boy whose name I forgot, I guess since he would be able to identify parts of the terrain due to him being native to the region. But Gemma? Why does the smith travel with the hunter? She seems to be one of the main smiths in the expedition, her not being in base camp could massively delay the weapon supply chain for the rest of the expedition. Another thing that is of concern, is that she seems to have no combat ability, I could assume that handlers are trained on how to properly get away from monsters and not get in the way of their hunter when they're fighting, but a smith?

I'm sorry but if every hunter had a smith constantly following them not only would there need to be WAY more smiths in the guild (possibly even more smiths than hunters), not to mention the risk of smiths dying due to a small mistake, or even some unexpected situation. The hunter can't protect everyone if something goes wrong, they're just human after all...

[Riukensei]

Originally posted by AndyKills457:

I have multiple problems with the story, with it dragging out pointless scenes, palicoes not speaking their own language, and other minor details.

But personally I am really bothered by the fact that Gemma goes everywhere with the hunter, Alma makes sense since she's your handler, the boy whose name I forgot, I guess since he would be able to identify parts of the terrain due to him being native to the region. But Gemma? Why does the smith travel with the hunter? She seems to be one of the main smiths in the expedition, her not being in base camp could massively delay the weapon supply chain for the rest of the expedition. Another thing that is of concern, is that she seems to have no combat ability, I could assume that handlers are trained on how to properly get away from monsters and not get in the way of their hunter when they're fighting, but a smith?

I'm sorry but if every hunter had a smith constantly following them not only would there need to be WAY more smiths in the guild (possibly even more smiths than hunters), not to mention the risk of smiths dying due to a small mistake, or even some unexpected situation. The hunter can't protect everyone if something goes wrong, they're just human after all...

Handler from world made no sense, Alma makes no sense, wait hold up....
-Insert NPC from ANY MH Game- makes no sense with this logic.
Damn.

[Scipo0419]

I had the same thought before I realized each team is a team of 4: The Hunter (Player/Olivia), The Handler (Alma/Erik), The Smith (Gemma/Werner), The Palico (Player Palico/Fluffy, Destroyer of Monsters)

Gemma is Avis Units Smith just like Werner is Olivia's units Smith

[Scipo0419]

Originally posted by BlairiesTTV:

Originally posted by Popcorn:

Is it confirmed? And i meant "referencing her to being Miss Little Forge"

You can peice it together as the hunter from U4 jumped for a hat and she references that you remind her of him. Also Ace the lancer is pretty obvious and says he grew up knowing Gemma. Gemma is little miss forge. Fabius is Ace. There is also a scene of her old hammer if it's still not enough to convince you

Little Miss Forge wasn't there when the 4U hunter jumped for the hat as she wasn't part of the caravan at that time. The rest of it I can't refute. I'd love it if she was little miss forge except that means we have a mature older Sophia somewhere and I need her to step on me and call me Doodle.

[.°• Sheep ༄𖦹]

Originally posted by AaaaNinja:

Originally posted by scylla:

this is actually a misconception, gemma isn't following the hunter at all. she's actually following alma because they're girlfriends. they engage in extremely passionate make out sessions while you're off hunting the target monster (gemma can only get in the mood if something is dying within earshot).

Something tells me you must be 12.

tough crowd

[Riukensei]

Originally posted by scylla:

Originally posted by AaaaNinja:

Something tells me you must be 12.

tough crowd

I like it. rule 32 fanart incoming.

[Tebza Ngwana]

Originally posted by Popcorn:

Originally posted by AaaaNinja:

Wait... what did they say about Erik? All they said is he is a Handler.

I mean players finding him annoying and wanting to off him.
The Lala Barina intro proves their point imo

this is the first time i see someone hating Erik.

[KingOfFriedChicken]

She is your Smith, and you are in a foreign land, she even has her mobile Smithy she talks about for this reason. Because you weren't native and no way to know what to expect, she is sent to help forge for the hunter.

That's pretty much what I got from her being there.

[KingOfFriedChicken]

Originally posted by Scipo0419:

I had the same thought before I realized each team is a team of 4: The Hunter (Player/Olivia), The Handler (Alma/Erik), The Smith (Gemma/Werner), The Palico (Player Palico/Fluffy, Destroyer of Monsters)

Gemma is Avis Units Smith just like Werner is Olivia's units Smith

Yes, they had no way to know what would be available in other lands, so they sent mobile smiting stations with us from my understanding.

[Tebza Ngwana]

Originally posted by KingOfFriedChicken:

She is your Smith, and you are in a foreign land, she even has her mobile Smithy she talks about for this reason. Because you weren't native and no way to know what to expect, she is sent to help forge for the hunter.

That's pretty much what I got from her being there.

Not to mention that she was the one handling establishing camps at checkpoints whenever we reached an unknown environment.

[BluntWrap]

Sheeet, keep her as close as possible. With less on.

[Jay🥸]

You think Gemma is following you but she is actually following the Zennies. I don't remember a single time she does things for me for free.

[Riukensei]

Originally posted by BluntWrap:

Sheeet, keep her as close as possible. With less on.

There is a mod for that.

[Nolo Contendere]

Originally posted by Scipo0419:

that means we have a mature older Sophia somewhere and I need her to step on me and call me Doodle.

I do not understand the obsession with 4u's guild (village) sweetheart.

3u's was the superior choice

[Jean]

Please go play Monster Hunter 4 LOL

[Popcorn]

Originally posted by Tebza Ngwana:

Originally posted by Popcorn:

I mean players finding him annoying and wanting to off him.
The Lala Barina intro proves their point imo

this is the first time i see someone hating Erik.

You haven't been around much then.
I'm just stating that I see the person's POV who wanted to off Erik during the Lala Varina scene.

Originally posted by BlairiesTTV:

Originally posted by Popcorn:

Is it confirmed? And i meant "referencing her to being Miss Little Forge"

You can peice it together as the hunter from U4 jumped for a hat and she references that you remind her of him. Also Ace the lancer is pretty obvious and says he grew up knowing Gemma. Gemma is little miss forge. Fabius is Ace. There is also a scene of her old hammer if it's still not enough to convince you

Currently going back through with another character as the first one I just rushed through