How do I settle accounts with Alice McLafferty?

[Melody]

I've gotten the key off her person but it doesn't look like there's anything quest related or unique in the crimson caravan camp. I've killed the Van Graffs and Ranger Jackson. But I still don't actually know what I'm meant to do. Any help?

[Dadpool]

I don't remember much but wasn't this where you had to go with Cass and kill her?

[Melody]

I just went and did that. The marker is still pointing to her body. The quest must be bugged or something

[Melody]

Oh, nevermind. You have to kill Alice then go talk to Cass

[Jawey]

With Alice McLafferty's quest, all you have to do is convince Cass to let the Crimson Caravan buy out her business, passing all speech checks in the process. There's no pickpocketting involved (I have no idea where you got that idea from).

Originally posted by Elys Cusumus:

I don't remember much but wasn't this where you had to go with Cass and kill her?

That's the Van Graff sidequest, where you NEED to bring Cass back to the Silver Rush in order to complete it.

[Riyadhcraft]

blast her with a shotgun because that's what she deserved