Should Puck get a NEW voice actor?

[Joey The Lemur]

Okay so Puck is suppose to be a young Faierie Dragon but what is Puck's gender? This Question is what I mean ''Is Puck a boy or a girl?'' So I made an idea change Puck's voice actor to a child actor so we can finally figure out Puck's gender. I swear Puck's voice child actor/actress should be either Joshua Black or Bryson Barretto (filipino child actor). For my female option i would go for Ivy Bishop. Does anybody agree or not agree with me? PS: This is my way of figuring out puck's gender so we can't get confused.

[76561198126166182]

I like puck's voice though... but I want Morgan Freeman Announcer pack !!!

[DonJuaheed]

I dont want some 7 year old ruining my most enjoyed hero.

[Joey The Lemur]

Escrito originalmente por DonJuaheed:

I dont want some 7 year old ruining my most enjoyed hero.

They are not seven years old. They are above the age of seven. Joshua Black is around 11, Bryson Barretto is around 11-12 and Ivy Bishop somewhere around 13-15

[Sol4rSky]

OP, you are a dumb special kind of troll aren;t you?

[Joey The Lemur]

Escrito originalmente por MasacruAlex:

OP, you are a dumb special kind of troll aren;t you?

Me? Also I am not a troll. Also if your talking about the children's ages. Those are my guesses.

[Dakoria]

DOES anyone remeber what the compendium thing was about, the voice rework if you voted for puck then puck would have better voice

[himself78RR]

1. No.
2. Why do you NEED to know Puck's gender? It has no impact on any of their interactions in the game and they are as much a hero as any other is.
3. They are referred to as an it. The voice doesn't matter; Puck is genderless.

[Screenlag]

Man, I'm actually 1/8th black and I find it very offensive what you wrote in the OP. please edit your post so it doesn't reek of racism and bigotry. thanks

Escrito originalmente por Imsogoofy:

Joshua Black (a child actor who was in Amazing Spider man 2 as some random kid on a carousel and yes he is black

This part needs to be changed, don't mention he is black, that's very racist.

[Joey The Lemur]

Escrito originalmente por Screenlag:

Man, I'm actually 1/8th black and I find it very offensive what you wrote in the OP. please edit your post so it doesn't reek of racism and bigotry. thanks

Escrito originalmente por Imsogoofy:

Joshua Black (a child actor who was in Amazing Spider man 2 as some random kid on a carousel and yes he is black

This part needs to be changed, don't mention he is black, that's very racist.

I fixed it. :)

[achus93]

Puck is not supposed to have a gender, just like Io. so what if people refer to ir as he/she/it, it doesn't matter because Puck is Puck...

[Chickenhead]

puck is voiced by jen taylor, aka cortana from halo.

[👌m8]

The mystery is the one of the things that make this hero interesting. Though, Puck's pronoun is it according to the game itself. People who think it's a he or she is just jumping to conclusions simply because they heard its 'voice' and read 'biographies outside the Dota 2 world'. For example:

The name Puck originated from one of William Shakespeare's plays. Shakespeare's Puck has another name, Robin Goodfellow, and it's a he in the play. Another basis is that on PlayDota's Hero Background of Puck, its pronoun is 'he'. Also, the voice actor/actress of Puck is a woman.

So if you want to find out if Puck's a he or she or it on Dota 2, just simply check the Dota 2 lore:

"The Faerie Dragon sows confusion by forcing its enemies to vividly dream about their own mortality."

"With a mischievous grin, Puck spreads its enchanted powder which disrupts magical flow."

"Puck spends countless millennia in its childish form."

Once again, that mystery is what make this hero unique. Just like Pyro on Team Fortress 2... though there are 'theories' that he's actually a homosexual male, no joke.

Sources:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Puck_(A_Midsummer_Night's_Dream)
http://www.playdota.com/heroes/faerie-dragon
http://dota2.gamepedia.com/Puck
http://www.dota2.com/hero/Puck/

edit: Answering your question, I don't think Puck needs a voice change. The voice actress did a good job on it, and hiring a child voice actor would be pointless since the voice actress has already imitated it unless you're talking about a different kind of child voice.

[Tortle™]

Vanilla Puck voice is fine, OP. No need to go changing it. And that's a very unpopular idea anyway, so there's likely no way it would get done.

[Taweret]

no, Puck is based on manga Berserk character Puck which was some sort of comedy character that why he have such voice

[Melencolia I]

Why Valve should waste money to replace Puck's excellent voice lines? Why is everybody so concerned about the gender of fictional characters?