Tabletop Simulator

Tabletop Simulator

Mage Knight Plus (Highly Scripted)
MANIC Feb 1, 2021 @ 4:37pm
The War of Four
Any chance of adding the following scenario?

https://boardgamegeek.com/thread/2120021/new-mage-knight-scenario-uses-all-ultimate-edition

Basically all my friends and I play any more. The scripting here is really cool, but this scenario has so many custom elements it is a bit tough to play in this mod ='(. I've probably implemented over 500 edits from irl playtesters and random BGG community members over the years, so hopefully the rules are very clear at this point. Either way, thanks for the awesome mod!
< >
Showing 1-15 of 18 comments
Tuff-Luck  [developer] Feb 1, 2021 @ 5:18pm 
I’ve seen this one before. I can’t remember why , but at the time it was probably too complex for my skill level. I’ll take another look at it.
MANIC Feb 1, 2021 @ 5:36pm 
Cool, thanks! If it seems possible and there is anything I can do to help just let me know. My friends and I are about to start playing a series of games in this scenario and just realized how much easier our lives would be if it was scripted XD
MANIC Feb 10, 2021 @ 12:24pm 
Loving the mod and trying to play War of Four using custom, but I am having some issues. I have found a work around for setting up tiles (just have to pull out the cities and do some randomization the hard way). I can dot he same for enemy tokens (though this is more of a pain). I can't seem to spawn Volkare's tile and or the Avatars from Life and Death. I'd also love to turn off auto population of tiles with enemy tokens due to the special rules I have for this, but it isn't as big a problem as simply accessing certain components. Any ideas for a temporary work around?

I tried switching from your mod to an unscripted one to play War of Four but it makes doing everything else so painful I went back to trying to find work arounds in your mod XD
Tuff-Luck  [developer] Feb 10, 2021 @ 5:40pm 
I was playing around at integrating your mod, because I felt guilty about adding “The Chaos Rift” who didn’t ask over yours who did ask. But every time I try and parse your scenario rules, I feel like I did back learning Mage Knight for the first time. I think it’s all the exception to rules that get me. Graveyards heal now? Far north and Far south? It doesn’t help that when I read that I’m trying to think where in my code I need to put an exception to achieve the rule. I need to stop looking at the big picture and focus on each part, so I’ve added it to the setup with an Experimental label. It will show up in the next update, but will probably only go as far setting up the map. Let me know the parts that need to be focused on from there.
MANIC Feb 10, 2021 @ 10:08pm 
Haha hey don't feel guilty it is your mod! I don't think anyone can blame you for adding whatever you want to add in whatever order, we just appreciate what you do =). That is already super helpful, thanks! I'll test it Friday when we play (if it is up by then, if not sometime next week) and keep a list of all of the things that don't occur automatically (that seem like they should) and make it very concise to minimize work for you.

Some of the minor changes like the graveyard adjustment was for balance purposes. We found that the plethora of artifacts in the South and the lack of healing from graveyards in the North in standard Life and Death just made the South route feel easier and more lucrative on average. Basically every small change has some rationale like this, but your right that they really do pile up! Still, I think I can get you something very bare bones in terms of what the scenario could use that will be waaaay easier to work with than going straight from the rules. Thanks again for your efforts!
Tuff-Luck  [developer] Feb 15, 2021 @ 6:32pm 
Turns out your setup rules aren’t that complicated once I sat down and focused. I think I’ve got them all working now. Can’t prove it, but the dice is virtually rolled for rampaging units deploying north and south and far and near.

Putting your manual in next. I’ve tweaked it to fit on the page better, but otherwise it’s the same. I can’t help but feel there is a lot of stuff that isn’t needed now the script does it for you. I think it still needs to be there, but worded more past tense. Ie “this is what the script has done”, not “this is how you setup”. Up to you, I’ll put in any PDF you send me.
MANIC Feb 18, 2021 @ 8:49pm 
Originally posted by Tuff-Luck:
Turns out your setup rules aren’t that complicated once I sat down and focused. I think I’ve got them all working now. Can’t prove it, but the dice is virtually rolled for rampaging units deploying north and south and far and near.

Putting your manual in next. I’ve tweaked it to fit on the page better, but otherwise it’s the same. I can’t help but feel there is a lot of stuff that isn’t needed now the script does it for you. I think it still needs to be there, but worded more past tense. Ie “this is what the script has done”, not “this is how you setup”. Up to you, I’ll put in any PDF you send me.

Great, idea! I'll make a separate rulebook for the this mod at some point that focuses on the stuff that isn't scripted and send it your way.

The two most problematic issues we ran into last Friday were:
-There should not be any indecisive units in the unit offer, so when Volkare draws a wound the script can get in the way by stealing units from the offer. I then need to manually add a new copy of that unit to the offer and remove a grey enemy token from Volkare
-The set-up defaults to cooperative in the sense that the co-op player skills are used. As we were playing competitive, we need to just pretend the co-op skills are the competitive skills. Additionally, there should be a copy of the competitive spells in the spell deck as well as in Volkare's deck during competitive play (I just copied these manually)

As we didn't quite finish our game and are wrapping it up tomorrow, I'll send you these and some more minor issues after we have finished one full game. Thanks again for adding the scenario set-up! It has made playing Mage Knight (especially this scenario) infinitely easier =)
Tuff-Luck  [developer] Mar 8, 2021 @ 6:32pm 
Ok, I believe I have gotten most of the issues you sent me sorted, but here's a few points I've jotted down:-
- The deck description summary not including the stored sparing power cards is a valid issue, but not easily fixed. I've recorded it as something I'll look at eventually.
- Leader sites converting to city sites is a bit awkward to handle with my scripts. You are free to flip and move the city info cards where you need them but pulling shields from the Leader will confuse the scoring system. In your next game can you experiment with using the marker tokens instead of shields on the city cards. (also curious how a copy of the shields on the city cards would work?)
- Marking enemy tokens as followers, have you tried using the marker tokens instead of shields? I've added a Volkare token to assist with this.
- You were worried about the monster discards still being separated by faction, but my script should refill empty stacks every time it tries to draw from them, and if the faction stack is still empty goes to the standard stack. I think you might be worried about nothing, but I am happy to hear a more detailed explanation of how keeping them separate is a problem.
I think this makes the scenario very close to removing the "EXPERIMENTAL" label. It just needs an instruction book more stream lined to what is needed to play it in this mod.
Tuff-Luck  [developer] Mar 9, 2021 @ 5:27am 
I just noticed that Volkare should have 12 wounds (and no indecisive units [which I've sorted]). This is a thrilling race level for Volkare, which is the highest race level. Is this intended? Should I force this for your scenario, or allow players to choose easier levels?
MANIC Mar 9, 2021 @ 8:13am 
Originally posted by Tuff-Luck:
I just noticed that Volkare should have 12 wounds (and no indecisive units [which I've sorted]). This is a thrilling race level for Volkare, which is the highest race level. Is this intended? Should I force this for your scenario, or allow players to choose easier levels?

This is correct, I force the choice of 12 wounds. I removed race levels when I removed the round limit. Taking both cities already can make this scenario so ungodly long that the idea of adding more wounds makes even me pale.
MANIC Mar 9, 2021 @ 8:23am 
Thanks, the current version is amazing!

-Fair, I can see how fixing this might be a pain. I'll just tell people not to check their deck composition if they get sparing power.

-Ya I think I'm worried about nothing with the monster discards.

-I forgot about the markers! With a Volkare marker, this should make everything work fine now =D. I'll use that in our game tonight, but unless you hear from me you can assume it worked.

-Manually adding cities should be straightforward. I didn't see where the cards were stored originally but now that I do it should not be an issue.


General Bugs:

-I had a new error with Volkare moving himself. He drew a white and moved the direction typically reserved for green in this scenario. I moved him manually, but then he started moving all sorts of crazy directions in subsequent turns. I took pictures, but they apparently cannot be included here.

-We had a player next to a keep that was not his and his hand size increased by one. He owned a keep on the other side of the board. Is the game considering being next to any keep reason to increase your hand size by the number of keep you control? This should only happen when on or adjacent to a friendly keep.
MANIC Mar 9, 2021 @ 8:25am 
Ya, now that the scripting appears very stable, I'm going to rewrite a mod specific version of my rulebook in the near future. Quarter is ending soon though, so this may be slightly delayed
Tuff-Luck  [developer] Mar 11, 2021 @ 8:29am 
You should like this latest patch. Got the level values all working for city, Volkare and Leaders. Removed the race level and defaulted it to 12 wounds. I got Volkare running the "Volkare's Quest" ruleset, but I still need to figure out his interactions with the cities. he's just going to head for the portal at the moment. Fixed the keep problem and some other minor issues.
MANIC Mar 11, 2021 @ 10:31am 
Originally posted by Tuff-Luck:
You should like this latest patch. Got the level values all working for city, Volkare and Leaders. Removed the race level and defaulted it to 12 wounds. I got Volkare running the "Volkare's Quest" ruleset, but I still need to figure out his interactions with the cities. he's just going to head for the portal at the moment. Fixed the keep problem and some other minor issues.

That's awesome, thanks! The groups I play with can't believe how amazing your mod is, so know your work is appreciated =P. Probably the best TTS mod any of use have played (which is collectivley a lot of mods lol). One thing I noticed this week is that rampaging monsters on tiles with the Necropolis and Hidden Valley are suppossed to be guranteed to be from the appropriate faction. Not a big deal if this is annoying to automate, mostly had this rule cause it felt thematicly appropriate
Tuff-Luck  [developer] Mar 11, 2021 @ 6:20pm 
I thought they were. Are you saying you got an opposite faction or just a generic token? Will keep my eye out and see if I can spot it.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 18 comments
Per page: 1530 50