Is this mod compatible with medieval 1212?

it seems you cannot use Loose formation when using this mod pack.. they dont loose formation when you toggle it. and ive tried with only this mod installed

This is a decent mod.
The Attila total war AI is a hit or miss, sometimes it'll put up a good fight, sometimes it'll just do a moshpit, exhaust its troops, and you'll do the encircling very easily.
This mod does things quite well, despite the mention of "fights being more slow", it does not keep it grindy. The biggest improvement is hands down the archery and missile focus, archers have a far greater range and shoot in an arc like in shogun II. This can be inconvenient if you play the base game with a unit number modifier, as archers won't find the right spot to shoot their arrows at you, but with this mod, they can be right behind units at close range and shoot their stuff at the enemy.
I'd recommend it to people who wants to try and see for themselves if they'd find battles to be more enjoyable as i am so far.

Good mod.

think it would work with dawnless days

work with radious ?

Hey just curious, is loose formation turned off with this mod? When I activate it it does nothing. I had heard loose formation in ATW is broken, is this why or?

This mod is quite well put together. I really like its changes and thank you for making it. Good work.

Can you make it compatible with 1212 ?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xg3R9I139CM

i played with these and during a siege (on hard) and single enemy skirmisher unit on the walls killed of almost 2 of infantry units coming at the walls, you should've seen them go down... also the towers killed like one solder per 2 seconds wtf archers are EXTREMELY OP with this mod...

Does this work with Medieval 2 fluent combat system?

does this work with aoc?

crashing with FOTE

Its compatible with battle animations mod ?

I disagree that this mod creates a 'grind fest'. You should try some of the other realism battle mods. Those are slow and tedious. This one gets the balance right.

i like the mod, but battles now are grindfests that take longer than they should. can you release a faster battles version but keep everything else

This is what I would like to see the most battle images, the cavalry should have a powerful impact.

comrade

thanks!

@Malata Societa' Official This mod, Realistic Battle Pack is the one you should run.

@Comrade Maarten

"And no Realistic Charge Impacts is just a part of this mod so no need to run both." so which i must run?

@Malata Societa' Official no my guy it does not work with 1212 as that mod is under active development and I am not following their updates. And no Realistic Charge Impacts is just a part of this mod so no need to run both.

its compatible whit medieval 1212???
and have a sense if i use whit Realistic Charge Impacts???

historically accurate
-military formations
pros
-trajectory
cons/historically inaccurate
-slower paced combat
I like to do cinematic battles and the con is way to big for my liking

and have a sense if i use whit Realistic Charge Impacts???

its compatible whit medieval 1212???

With this mod, loose formation is deactivated.

hoping this works with radious

and have a sense if i use whit Realistic Charge Impacts???

its compatible whit medieval 1212???

and have a sense if i use whit Realistic Charge Impacts???

its compatible whit medieval 1212???

Hello! What is load order for your mod? Playing with Ancient Empires, Medieval 1212 and FOTE. Add to description, please.

Does it work with Ancient empires mod ?

could this work for 1212? or is there one like it for 1212?

its compatible whit medieval 1212???

Hi. Is this mod compatible with 'Battle' category mods like 'return to glory', 'cinematic combat', 'realistic charge impact' and etc...?

is this compatible with 'return to glory'?

Your mod is pretty astonishing - As of now I really have to rethink battles...
But one question: Why does spacing not work anymore?

AND: Could you make it compatible with the Dark Ages AD257 (4.0) Mod?
Would be great - Thank you in advance.

is this compatible in all mods?

Did you just give +5 defense and +10 armor to all units? But this reduced the effectiveness of the missiles, right?

And what does "Better veterans" mean?

Hail :)
If I install this mod, will I need to additionally install "Realistic Cav Charges"?

What has been done for longer battles? Increased armor? If the armor is increased, are they in the same proportions for all units?

aw,, and her ei thought i was talking to Professor Hank Pym ;)
- couldn't resist.
but yeah, again- apart from that pet peeve, ya'll addressed alot of things i think has gotten more-fantasy (mp focused? ) in the game, luckily we have quite the mod community to address such differences in tastes; so I should end with a "bravo"

@Badger BrownCoat not henry haha, but yeah no worries. Have fun!

@antman ( Henry? is that you! ) : i understand- i quit modding myself, only recently playing TW games again-
I'll see what ya'll did, i was just curious; as it doesn't seem a lot of folks noticed they "snuck in" that change ( from trained to troops almost all ) - and few share my conclusion that doing so ( as the original rome2 crew seem to have; before the new-crew change, judging by the name "expert" & the units as had it.) ...that setting vs a charge takes... some grit.
-I was just curious, but sure, why would u remember that offhand?
Sorry to bug you about an old mod; thanks for the response, and I'll check it out ;)

@Badger BrownCoat Haven't worked on this for a year, but I do remember that I changed charge effectiveness of cavalry on unbraced troops. If you want your inf unit to withstand a charge you have to manually put them in a shieldwall or any similar position. And heavy inf is heavier while light inf is lighter.

Cant really answer your question fully but just experiment with the mod and see if you like it or not.

what Dalathor said ( 3 down !)
- i've a question tho'-
since ATW on, it seems ALL spear men get "set spear vs charge" ( expert charge reflection/defense ) - which may go with mp and rock-scissor-paper-
but doesn't very well reflect how much discipline, training, and raw *courage* receiving a charge w/ spears *took* - does this mod address this?

Sounds great, does it make arrows more deadly at all? the vanilla arrows in every TW game are so weak!