hi so you know how like, flowers take up space and have hitboxes, can you not do that? i can't place blocks on them and i can't do chests and stuff, or at least make it weapon breakable, its your mod and i am here to give some badly written, probably not good criticism

Thanks! didnt know the crops could be plant on Planter Boxes, sure it will be better, i can even create a Green-house then, hope you create the Drain Rate config, im actually playing with only the Constant Seed for starvation, i couldn't handle the rate of the mod :((.
Waiting for it <3

@Karenpresci Crops planted on dirt use the same logic as alchemy seeds, you can plant them on Planter Boxes to avoid this premature destruction. I'll consider getting bottles and dishes back when consuming food, it's a good idea. I will also add rebalancing the food/thirst drain rate to my to do list. Thanks for the feedback.

I think the drain rate of Food/Trhist is too fast, the Constant secret seed uses the Food bonus as the timer, and even when you "hungry" you still have 5 minutes to eat.
But in the mod the Drain rate of Food and Water is TOO much fast, i feel overwhelmed by the need of eating/drink everytime, please consider lower its rate, or add a config to change the drain rate.

Just to ADD to my comment, everything that use something like Bowl / Bottle / Plate as a recipient/placeable are things that we use to eat/drink in, and it should come back after eating/drinking.
I also think the Vanilla potions should give us back the bottle but, that's another mod for it.

I'm playing with it for the first time, i love cooking in games so loved the mod, so i want to say 2 things that bother me:

First - planted seed Crops should have the Tree Saplings protection, when you plant it and its growing, you cannot hit/destroy by mistake, like when monsters are roaming and i'm using a Boomerang (my case right now) if the boomerang hit the seeds, he destroy it and so i lost the seeds. Crops should have the sapling protection, so you only break it when Fully Grow.

Second - Water Bottle, when using the Bottle and fill it up with water to create the water bottle, i thought i would receive a bottle back after drinking, but not.
We should receive a bottle back as we are only drinking water, creating endless bottle to fill it up with water will be bothersome, specially when we are Drinking water only, the bottle shouldn't disappear.

[Translate] There is a bug with Lettice and Trellise for plant cultivation that causes the items to be copied when attacked from a distance.

Are there any patches for this that makes it so when you use the Water Bottles to drink it gives back an empty bottle? Tried pairing it with Reusable Bottles but didn't work

@Talecgosa I'll look into it, thanks for the bug report!

Hi, in multiplayer, when you place one of the items that has an interface, it causes a lot of data to be transferred nonstop, even if you take down the items. The only way to stop that is by reloading the server. I've been hosting a game for my friend and I, so when my friend started getting lots of desync, he checked the multiplayer debug menu (F8 ingame) and noticed that this mod was sending massive amounts of data that never stopped. So he did his best Sherlock impression, testing each mod on a new world, and narrowed it down to this mod. We're both sad because we were really enjoying your mod! This is exactly what we're looking for, so we're hoping this is a bug that can be fixed so we can continue enjoying it ^_^ I'm happy to send screenshots/more info if that would help, thanks!

Hi. I wanna to make a modpack with ur mod. Is it possible to make custom food? Or example: RoA mod adds 4 new food and i wanna to make it compatible with ur mod, help plzz

@nobisyu no stress take your time plz just wanted to let you know about it, if it cant be fix no stress as well i am sure its a pain in the ass and the mod its self if a blessing so thanks for your hard work

@MageTrash Thank you. I'll consider the config option.

@DEADLEAD I will look into it. Multiplayer bugs are particularly hard for me to crack, so it may be a while.

Yoo this mod is great! I'm enjoying having a cute lil' basement for my cooking setup, and it's nice to make a bunch of food for my character to nom on.

I was wondering if you could set the base respawn hunger and thirst to something non-100%, like 50% or even 25% (maybe make it configurable)? I feel it defeats the purpose of worrying about starvation or thirst if I could just die during starving/dehydration and respawn with full stats.

@nobisyu thank you so much for getting back to me lmfao i appreciate it deeply. that being said its the trees that were there on world gen regrow after me and my friend load in i forgot to mention previously that i am playing with buddy so i don't know if this is a multiplayer bug specifically i just want to make sure i can give as much detail as possible

@DEADLEAD When you say the trees reload upon world entry, do you mean the trees that were there on world gen regrow? Or are you finding new trees around the world that weren't there before as you explore?

@nobisyu i have encountered a bug where the trees keep reloading now an again or when i rejoin my world. it dose it over/in things i have built or just grass now i don't mind the free fruit but i feel it make it to easy and has lead to concerning amount of grapefruit and peaches, and as i was just sitting here cleaning up ad enjoying my peaches i was wondering if this is fixable on my end?

My review to this mod. This mod is very awesome. Thanks for creating a mod that makes terraria more realistic and immersive. I have had lots of fun with this mod and when i told my friends about this mod, they were excited to hear that there was a mod that made cooking useful.

still i think this mod lacks a few things. Of course i will list them:

configurability (pls let us configure how fast or slow we get hungry and thirsty)
compability (please make that with mods like more critters that they can drop some ingredients)
Cookbook (add a cookbook that tells how every ingredient is cooked made and obtained)

Thats actually all, i really like this mod and please think abt adding my suggestions.

@Vatheryl I know the issue you are speaking of, but unfortunately last I checked, there was an issue with tModLoader not being able to get it to work properly. I've asked the tmod team and they said that Staff of Regrowth compatibility is unavailable at this time. It is on my list of things I plan to fix however.

@taironernesto I am unaware what the Terra Companions mod is, I'll look into it and see if I can try to add compatibility.

@Delecta Vole There is a known multiplayer bug with trellises not working. Are you in multiplayer perhaps? Sorry for the late reply.

Thank you so much for such a fantastic mod! I have played tens of hours in multiple play-through styles. A suggestion:
Weapons both harvest and destroy plants. I build a nice big farm and then my crops are destroyed by an errant swing or arrow while killing mobs or just an accidental button press. This makes me sad. So, with that in mind, can you add a harvesting tool of some kind? Like a Hori-hori knife or just an upgrade for the sickle? It could harvest the full-grown plants, but leave the ones still growing. It could be auto-swing and function similar to a short sword. I can't remember if the Staff of Regrowth works in this manner, but even if it does, it's not super easy to find, and you don't start off with one on day one. If a new tool were simply sold by the Merchant, just like the sickle, that would be great. Or just make things only harvest-able by an empty hand? Maybe this is just a "me" problem, but I thought I'd voice my opinion. Thanks for listening!

very nice and lovely mod. It just has a problem with Terra Companions: the companions don't consume the food, so they end dying of thirst.

@nobisyu and thank you very much for this mod, it's really nice to be able to have an interactive "kitchen", I'm looking forward to seeing this update involving temperature and livestock

I'm having trouble planting tomatoes on the trellises because they simply don't grow and disappear out of nowhere. Is there anything I need to do?

you have blessed me with such exellence

Ok cool!

@NoctisTheBogWitch That is fair, but at the same time, I've already fixed the update as I've said to many different people on many different occasions, it just hasn't been released yet.

I know that. and my personal decisions in the comfort of my own home, however bad they are, shouldn't stop me from playing 2 mods I personally enjoy.

@NoctisTheBogWitch Luiafk is one of the most busted mods out there. It isn't quality of life, it is a cheat mod.

But it isn't broken without this mod installed???

@NoctisTheBogWitch can't break something that's already broken.

This mod breaks luiafk.

THIS IS SO COOL THANK YOU

I think a cool feature could be making the mana bar more like the sanity bar in don't starve together.

Thank you, @nobisyu, I think that my modlist changed description for this item, so I didn't tried it out (right now bottled water is ammo in my game)

@leva.zakharov Bottled Water.

What are the early sources of water in this mod?

Tough As Nails but terraria

@Yumiko_Ishida Are you in multiplayer and using any other mods? The critters are mostly cooked on stove tops, not cooking pots.

Additionally, I'm trying to include a few more bug fixes in the update before I release the fix to luiafk compatibility.

Also you didn't seem to do anything to fix the conflict with miningcracks_take_on_luiafk.

I can't cook critters. And it won't cook them even in magic storage. You can't fit any birds in the changed cooking pot? Is there a setting to fix this?

@summerstorm I'll add it to the to-do list for the next major update.

Man, I've been loving this mod, it would be nice if the farmer could give us tips about how to take care of our crops

man, thats exacly the thing i wanted

Manaberry is OP, I love it.

update soon?

Please fix your conflict with Luiafk and other mods as shown in the discussions tab.

Hey, there is a bug where the fruit trees will grow through my base, even without dirt. I am not sure if it's a multiplayer issue or what, but it's slightly inconvenient.

If you decide to look into it, thank you :D