bad

sloppy asf,go make something that's good

Make a variant with the Red Army Robin's colors.

good idea actually

Trash.

THE BURNING WON'T STOP AUGHHHHHHHH

The robin walkers worked due to the name and item being based on one of the creators of the game. However the modeling work along with this being just another beanie really bring this down for me. From what I’ve seen on your workshop page you’re new to making items and that’s fine just gotta keep trying and improving don’t let mean comments discourage you from making items. Maybe try making a hat for just one class something that the character would wear and see what you come up with from there. Again good start keep improving!

We have enough beanies, and certainly enough beanies with some sort of cutesy mascot. This is trade up fodder.

no. nobody is going to wear this except the ocasional hoovy

no

At least the robin walkers were made to respect(maybeeeeee? It at least had him in mind I think) robin walker

dust

I know it's goofy and all but I still think this is kinda cute.

Awww I need to see this with the chicken kiev

Hat doesn't have any sort of deformities, it is just kind of a perfect circle which doesn't look too great lol, but the concept is cute! Also your texture is flat overall, you can make a simple tiling noise pattern that is incredibly small to give it that woven texture look, and on top of that, here's a good guide you can read for a good idea on how to make textures for Tf2 :

https://polycount.com/discussion/73559/texturing-for-team-fortress-2-a-short-guide/p1
(unembeded link in case its deleted)
https polycount com/discussion/73559/texturing-for-team-fortress-2-a-short-guide/p1

Thank you all for your feedback!

I agree, it's not the best hat I've ever made (if I've ever made good hats at all, lol). Even negative comments help and motivate me to work out ideas better.
I hope that my next items will be better and you will like them!

I'm sorry mate we just don't want more silly Christmas/winter goofy friend cosmetics we need cool war themed stuff with a pinch of some light lore or theme fitting goofy stuff, you clearly have skills in modelling game items just do less of this please :)

slop

your items are lovely

not really a fan, I can't see many people wanting to use any of these novelty beanies that people keep adding into the workshop

The Robin walkers are a reference to a developer of tf2 Robin Walker. With this item the joke is lost and the reference half dead so you're left with this odd looking beanie. It looks great but it's just not for tf2.

Just gonna comment here so I don't spam but the heavy boots look great and the engi hat could use more time in the oven but overall it's good