The thumbnail look like Doritos unusual

Man this does not have to be so saturated. It doesn't have to be neon spew, especially the orange. If you washed-out all of these, it would look better. Even then, it doesn't look like ash. There's no smog, smoke, and an underwhelming lack of embers. I think this needs to go back into the oven. I would love to see what becomes of this effect.

The green and purple are unecessary

This probably takes the cake for the most unnecessary recolors for any effect on the workshop.

I also have to agree that this doesn't really look like burning ash. Hell, the thumbnail art doesn't even look ANYTHING like the effect in-game.

The more you can make it look like the thumbnail art, the better. And get rid of the recolors.

The particle effect doesn't feel true to its name. I feel like there should be more Black smoke and White glow in the mix similar as how you would burn a stack of paper and watch the ember fly up in the air. As it is now, the effect is very underwhelming to me.

the fire one's good enough, the effect isnt really too much in your face
i like it

not really a big fan of green/purple
but the ash/amber looks cool

looks great but the green and purple colors r totally unnecessary