The Philosopher
Review Showcase
Short version (too long, didn't read):
1. Is the game good? Yes.
2. Is plot good? Yes.
3. Is it "Planescape: Torment" good? No.
4. Can be played in many ways and more than once? Yes.
5. Is it memorable and makes you stop to think? Yes.
6. Is there something objectively really bad about this game? It's a little short.

Is this game really good? Yes it is. There is some minor bugs here and there, maybe people who focus more on combat can be little disappointed, but it's still ok. Besides "Tides" is a different kind of game, I don't think combat is that important part of the game. Don't get me wrong, it's not bad. Let's say you coudn't make game with this combat as primary feature. Anyway this is great game in a way it should be, in those aspects creators focused on for it to be.

Is plot of the game really good? Yes it is. World is truly amazing, fresh and complex. NPCs you encounter are really alive, there is a lot of them who should leave some marks on your character. Finally your party members backgrounds and quests are exceptional, for the most part.For example I absolutely loved Rhin story. I dislike Tybirs, but even he has something interesting in him. Still, for me in both my runs his ending was meeting "death of Tybir".

Is this plot "Planescape: Torment" good? No, it isn't. But plot-wise Torment is really high bar to jump over, so everybody who dismiss Tides of Numenera as "not as good as Torment": chill out, there was no game that good to this day. Let me remind you: we were waiting over 18 years for such game.

Can I deal with this game in many ways? Yeah, for sure. And I believe that if you liked first run even a little bit you should go again, picking different playstyle.I believe you can complete game slaying everything on your way or do not kill single enemy. And it's only one aspect, there is a lot of decisions out there.

Finally the most important question, at least for me: does this game can make you stop and think about choices you make, world you influence and (sometimes) about life as it is? Yes, if you take the game seriously, read those walls of text and try to experience events like ingame characters: you can have some reflections. Can you feel good about completing the game? Can ending be satisfying? Well you absolutely can feel good and you absolutely can be satisfied with it. Problem is that it depends on a player and her/his playstyle. I can imagine situation when you won't like how it ends, or that you can feel hunger for more. I certainly would like to play longer, maybe explore few extra details, but at the same time ending just felt right, especially the first time I played. And not only for me and for character I tailored, but also for other characters and world itself. The thing is how undone it may feel plot of the game is more than complete! Place you meet Last Castoff is the same place you find Nameless One- in the middle of nowhere, knowing next to nothing and understanding even less. And this stories both end is reasonable place.In "Tides" like in "Planescape: Torment" you meet with your former self and, one way or another, face threat that haunts you since the very beginning. In the past there were shadows, now there is Sorrow. And even if your character lives at the end: beyond that point her/his life is a different story. Tides of Numenera tell us a story of the Last Castoff, her/his purpose and fight against Sorrow. To be honest I wouldn't like game to continue beyond that point, but I do would love to have more content in between.

To sum up: I really think many people treated "Tides" unfair, softly speaking. Personally I never expected this game to be better than Planescape, I didn't expect it to be even similar. I was sure it's gonna be totally different experience. All I wanted was really good game with endless walls of text, many character-defining decisions, interesting characters and quaint quests. And I got it all, sometimes even better than expected. If you want same things I did and you are open-minded: you are gonna have really good time.

There should be one more question here: what does one life matter? Well, there is so many answers, but few of them are surely gonna come up playing Tides of Numenera.
Recent Activity
2,403 hrs on record
last played on Nov 22
107 hrs on record
last played on Nov 19
829 hrs on record
last played on Nov 5
Comments
May 8, 2024 @ 8:47am 
gj