Recent reviews by ARFB0Y

I am having fun playing this game.
The gameplay is fun.
Everything else is not enjoyable.

The dialogue makes me cringe, the cosmetics are some of the worst I have seen, the performance is awful, the map is just sort of okay, the U.I. gets in the way constantly, the animation playing after every loot box opening is annoying.

Speaking of the loot boxes... I feel like that whole experience could be way more rewarding for the player if props, clothes, stickers, and skateboard items weren't all thrown together in the same boxes.

Ultimately, this just feels like EA trying to make a quick buck on an unfinished game.
However, I am having fun and I keep coming back.

As a first time RDR1 player I can say this game is clearly dated but it holds up nicely. I love RDR2 a lot and wanted to see these character's stories play out. If I hadn't played RDR2 I don't think I would have bought this game. I know a lot of people played this game in their formative years and it holds a special place for them. As someone coming to this game for the first time present day I would say: I had fun, it was nice to see the character's stories play out, it was fun exploring a world I've experienced in a different context, it does hold up nicely, but it does show it's age as well. It definitely is not worth the full price but if it's on sale I guess I would recommend it.

This is probably one of the best games of all time.

The last time I cried this hard while playing a game was at the end of Red Dead Redemption 2.

Play as a cat!

I don't know, it's just not good.

I love this game but I would like to do stuff in the yards of the houses like mow the grass, plant flowers, trees or put stuff on the decks like patio furniture and grills. I think this would add a lot more enjoyment in renovating houses. Keep up the good work, love this game.

I didn't enjoy it.

Better, cheaper, and has more content than EA's.

10/10 would buy all DLC again.