Skin Economy Gambling/Trading/Selling/Analysis Site URL Suspiciousness
I was wondering why Steam blocks just some of the sites connected to skin gambling/trading/selling and/or price analysis with the "suspicious url" warning or just straight "link removed".

It turns out even a lot of sites that are purely for price analysis like "CSGO Exchange", "CSGO Steamanalyst", "CSGO Zone" and "CSGO Stash" get flagged as well.
To my complete suprise "OPSKINS" which propably used to be the most well-known site to sell skins is even featured with an embedded link and even two major gambling sites like "♥♥♥♥♥♥♥" and ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ are also given an embedded link with information.

I do not know what Valve is trying to do here and I am neither an advocate nor an opponent of gambling of in game items.
Some sites like "♥♥♥♥♥♥♥" and "Bitskins" that are really only for buying skins are flagged while the sites "Playerauctions" and "Gamerall" practically do the same as I am aware and do not get the "suspicious url" label.

It is just all over the place and I would like to know if there is a way for me to use a link e.g. to my page on "Lootbear" to not get removed on my profile as that is neither a scam site nor a gambling site.

NOTE: My latest public artwork on my profile shows the sites I tested in a chat if you are curious.

EDIT1:I just saw that Steam even censored some of the sites I listed in my original post. I believe those were both sites associated with skin gambling. Let me try again:
Ursprünglich geschrieben von TimmiWanted1243:
and even two major gambling sites like "CSGO 500" and "Skin hub" are also given an embedded link with information.
Zuletzt bearbeitet von ΛCY|Ziz1243; 12. März 2019 um 1:17
< >
Beiträge 115 von 20
1. Everyday someone loses their account/items to a phishing scam site, people report the said phishing site which then get filter out.

2. You will always get a warning when clicking on links that wasn't whitelisted.

3. Steam does not, and will not support 3rd party sites, especially gambling sites.

4. Steam will not return lost/stolen items. They already got fed up with the amount of stupidity that happen for years every single day, and give warning, and place roadblocks to help refuse the amount of stupidity, which is did, but there are people willing to go the extra mile to get themselves scammed, or hijacked, support knows you can't fix the pure stupidity some people have.
https://support.steampowered.com/kb_article.php?ref=7623-IOFX-1021

5. Don't try to bypass the filter system, or promote phishing sites.
https://support.steampowered.com/kb_article.php?ref=4045-USHJ-3810
Zuletzt bearbeitet von Dr.Shadowds 🐉; 5. März 2019 um 1:58
м 5. März 2019 um 1:58 
there is one easy rule for csgo gambling or giveaway sites:

they are ALL scam.
Ursprünglich geschrieben von Dr.Shadowds 🐉:
1. Everyday someone loses their account/items to a phishing scam site, people report the said phishing site which then get filter out.

2. You will always get a warning when clicking on links that wasn't whitelisted.

3. Steam does not, and will not support 3rd party sites, especially gambling sites.

4. Steam will not return lost/stolen items. They already got fed up with the amount of stupidity that happen for years every single day, and give warning, and place roadblocks to help refuse the amount of stupidity, which is did, but there are people willing to go the extra mile to get themselves scammed, or hijacked, support knows you can't fix the pure stupidity some people have.
https://support.steampowered.com/kb_article.php?ref=7623-IOFX-1021

5. Don't try to bypass the filter system, or promote phishing sites.
https://support.steampowered.com/kb_article.php?ref=4045-USHJ-3810

Totally agree with all of what you said, especially your fourth point! And that is why it makes sense that only half of these sites and even those that I would assume to be the safest sometimes get hit with a warning label.

Ursprünglich geschrieben von M:
there is one easy rule for csgo gambling or giveaway sites:

they are ALL scam.

I must disagree with you there! Some of these sites I listed give an actual value to me and everyone that I traded with and I would consider my "closest friends on Steam" would probably agree that sites like:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von TimmiWanted1243:
"CSGO Exchange", "CSGO Steamanalyst", "CSGO Zone", "CSGO Stash", "OPSKINS", "Bitskins" and "Lootbear"

and probably also "♥♥♥♥♥♥♥", "Playerauction" and "Gamerall" although I personally have not tried these last three sites.

are definitely not scams, are very helpful and offer a service that Valve/Steam did not think about like betting on competitive CSGO matches and even renting out skins to users which is such a great idea if you do not play CSGO all the time anymore!
Hell, I think you cannot even give any items to "CSGO Stash" the site only lists prices like "CSGO Steamanalyst". Yet, it still has gotten a warning label because people do not even know which sites can scam them or which you can actually give items to...

I really only noticed this issue because "Lootbear" is a site I recently really started to enjoy as you can rent skins out to other people and you can actually earn quite a bit of money from that. The issue with Lootbear was that it is hard to grasp how it works and to the average stupid Steam user they will likely set their item to selling eventhough they only wanted to rent it out and lose a bunch of money because it is sold at a way cheaper price than they would have wanted to set it for. And before you asked yeah that is what happened to me! But eventhough I lost at least 300 Euros because of the sale of an item that I wanted only as a rentable item I would still recommend this site. The support is great, you just got to be half decent at understanding Steam and item trades. I am sure the average stupid Steam user would already get upset and report the site to the Steam support for "scam" or "hijacking" just because when they actually rent the item out and it is returned to their bots after the person gave it back they will not understand why there is this 7-day-delay that got added because people were way too stupid in the first place!

I guess you could conclude that a lot of these "warnings about suspicious links" and the removal of these links on profiles has to do with what was said by:

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Dr.Shadowds 🐉:
4. Steam will not return lost/stolen items. They already got fed up with the amount of stupidity that happen for years every single day, and give warning, and place roadblocks to help refuse the amount of stupidity, which is did, but there are people willing to go the extra mile to get themselves scammed, or hijacked, support knows you can't fix the pure stupidity some people have.
https://support.steampowered.com/kb_article.php?ref=7623-IOFX-1021

Stupid Steam users reporting sites because they are either not careful enough or just flat out do not know what they are doing!
Sadly, the people who do know what they are doing and can tell the good offers from the scams, get the short end of the stick for the sake of the safety of the stupid! :csgogun::rcry:
Zuletzt bearbeitet von ΛCY|Ziz1243; 5. März 2019 um 6:41
Zaskar 5. März 2019 um 7:01 
All trades conducted outsite the Steam's system can be a scam. Curiously, we can see some of those sites you mentioned in a lot of nickname histories of hijacked accounts. Please stop promoting those shady sites, enough stupid people already have their account stolen.
Zuletzt bearbeitet von Zaskar; 5. März 2019 um 7:02
Sites tend to be blocked due to scamming, phishing or being spammed. Sites with referrals often get added to the list due to the amount of spam they produce.

Skin gambling and 3rd party trading on its own is not why such sites get blocked.

OPSKINS API use was revoked by Valve as they bypassed a security measure in place by Valve. Such actions are not allowed as the measure is in place for user protection.

https://blog.counter-strike.net/index.php/expresstrade/

Renting is not possible on Steam, so a site like Lootbear can not work the way they claim. It would be really easy for users to scam them by using fake/stolen credit cards, stolem/purchased account, ect. It is s bubble just waiting to burst and there is nothing they can do to prevent such activity.
Ursprünglich geschrieben von Zaskar:
All trades conducted outsite the Steam's system can be a scam. Curiously, we can see some of those sites you mentioned in a lot of nickname histories of hijacked accounts. Please stop promoting those shady sites, enough stupid people already have their account stolen.
I am definitely not promoting any shady sites here. I am just trying to find out the difference because there certainly is a huge difference between a gambling site and a economy analysis site. Also a lot of the sites I use to rent my skins or sell them are completely save to use! Some of those sites I use on a bi-daily basis and can only recommend them. It all comes down to not being stupid on the internet and watch out what and who you trust.
Teksura 11. März 2019 um 23:26 
Ursprünglich geschrieben von TimmiWanted1243:
Ursprünglich geschrieben von Zaskar:
All trades conducted outsite the Steam's system can be a scam. Curiously, we can see some of those sites you mentioned in a lot of nickname histories of hijacked accounts. Please stop promoting those shady sites, enough stupid people already have their account stolen.
I am definitely not promoting any shady sites here. I am just trying to find out the difference because there certainly is a huge difference between a gambling site and a economy analysis site. Also a lot of the sites I use to rent my skins or sell them are completely save to use! Some of those sites I use on a bi-daily basis and can only recommend them. It all comes down to not being stupid on the internet and watch out what and who you trust.
My favorite part about this post is how you start it by saying you're not promoting any shady sites, and by the end you're going into great detail about what types of shady sites you promote, how often you use them, and insist that all the people who get scammed by them are totally wrong and it's safe to use because you personally haven't been affected. Yet.
Ursprünglich geschrieben von Spawn of Totoro:
Sites tend to be blocked due to scamming, phishing or being spammed. Sites with referrals often get added to the list due to the amount of spam they produce.

Skin gambling and 3rd party trading on its own is not why such sites get blocked.

OPSKINS API use was revoked by Valve as they bypassed a security measure in place by Valve. Such actions are not allowed as the measure is in place for user protection.

https://blog.counter-strike.net/index.php/expresstrade/

Renting is not possible on Steam, so a site like Lootbear can not work the way they claim. It would be really easy for users to scam them by using fake/stolen credit cards, stolem/purchased account, ect. It is s bubble just waiting to burst and there is nothing they can do to prevent such activity.
I agree on all the things you said except the last paragraph.
Lootbear does a lot to make sure if someone scams someone who is renting skins they have to pay for it and not just the price of the skin but a lot more.
For example I myself cannot even rent more than one skin and none that are over 10 USD I think.
You have to add a valid credit card and confirm it with a picture of yourself and of your ID and credit card. If you still scam someone they will take legal action against you.
If you do not have any of those which a huge amount of scammers would not get their hands on you might as well try to scam people somewhere else!
They have a really good system on their hands if you ask me.
They could still if they wanted remove their site of the internet and try to claim all the skins for themselves but I am pretty sure they would lose way more money if they did that.
Their bots or anyone who they try to trade these skins to will all get banned and the items will be frozen in their inventories so that would be the worst a site can ever do.
The longer their services runs, the more people rent everyone elses skins and the more people can try Dragon Lores and expensive skins they would never be able to try because they can be upwards of 500 USD easily so paying 10 USD for such a skin to own them for a week is such a good idea to me. I really do not hope that this is a bubble like you said. I would love for Valve to implement such a system so I can rent skins with Steam backing me up completely. I am barely playing CSGO lately and that site finally gives me a way to earn a little bit of a cash back from the 3k to 4k I spend on all my skins at this point. I have no idea how some traders make 300 USD in skins into 10k USD in skins and up. I have no idea how this trading stuff works in terms of how to make a profit but renting is such a good idea and Lootbear has a great support that reacts quickly too and backing from a ton of big CSGO influencers on YouTube. So I hope that it will stay...
Like I said the site has already been flagged with the warning I was talking about and that one was the straw that broke the camel's back for me.

And I definitely understand that there is not much moderators could do, the system is pretty much automated at this point.
There could be users right now selling an item on Lootbear or any other sites flagged or not and because they did not understand what they where doing and because they somehow feel mistreated they are contacting Steam support at this very moment about that "CSGO Steamanalyst" site and how they somehow go scammed even though it was someone completely different and that is one those sites that is just there for price analysis anyway...
Ursprünglich geschrieben von Teksura:
Ursprünglich geschrieben von TimmiWanted1243:
I am definitely not promoting any shady sites here. I am just trying to find out the difference because there certainly is a huge difference between a gambling site and a economy analysis site. Also a lot of the sites I use to rent my skins or sell them are completely save to use! Some of those sites I use on a bi-daily basis and can only recommend them. It all comes down to not being stupid on the internet and watch out what and who you trust.
My favorite part about this post is how you start it by saying you're not promoting any shady sites, and by the end you're going into great detail about what types of shady sites you promote, how often you use them, and insist that all the people who get scammed by them are totally wrong and it's safe to use because you personally haven't been affected. Yet.
Please tell me how anyone would ever get scammed by any of these sites: "CSGO Exchange", "CSGO Steamanalyst", "CSGO Zone" and "CSGO Stash". These are all pure price checking sites.
Ursprünglich geschrieben von TimmiWanted1243:
Ursprünglich geschrieben von Teksura:
My favorite part about this post is how you start it by saying you're not promoting any shady sites, and by the end you're going into great detail about what types of shady sites you promote, how often you use them, and insist that all the people who get scammed by them are totally wrong and it's safe to use because you personally haven't been affected. Yet.
Please tell me how anyone would ever get scammed by any of these sites: "CSGO Exchange", "CSGO Steamanalyst", "CSGO Zone" and "CSGO Stash". These are all pure price checking sites.
Price manipulation scams are one of the oldest tricks in the book and one of the main reasons scammers move into the trade items from this game for items from that game offers.

Make some piece of worthless trash look like it is worth a lot and then pick a target that won't know better and offer your "super valuable" item for their items that are totally worth less and then sit back and laugh as the person finds out they just gave away $100 dollars worth of items for junk that in reality won't even sell for 3 cents.
Zekiran 12. März 2019 um 0:14 
Every time you post a site name, you are actually and in point of fact "advertising that site" because people are stupid and will look them up - even when they're told they're bad and scams.

Stop doing that.
Teksura 12. März 2019 um 0:22 
Ursprünglich geschrieben von TimmiWanted1243:
You have to add a valid credit card and confirm it with a picture of yourself and of your ID and credit card. If you still scam someone they will take legal action against you.

Okay, well that's already super suspicious and gives them everything they need to steal your identity, while also being really, really easy for a scammer to work around.


Ursprünglich geschrieben von TimmiWanted1243:
If you still scam someone they will take legal action against you.
This is just laughable. If they make these claims to you on the site, that's how you know they're liars. There exists no legal action they can take. Nobody is getting dragged into court over it because trading items in steam is not illegal and they'll never actually be worth any amount of effort to pull anyone into a civil case even if they CAN make a compelling argument that there was some kind of legally binding agreement across international borders which involved breaking the terms of service of the service they were using. "They will take legal action", hah! Ridiculous, Such action would be unstartable.

Meanwhile, if you're violating the SSA by using their site exactly as you just described then the best you can hope for is having your account locked for SSA violations.

For reference, it's a really bad idea for you to go around and encourage or promote breaking the SSA.
Zuletzt bearbeitet von Teksura; 12. März 2019 um 0:26
Ursprünglich geschrieben von Zekiran:
Every time you post a site name, you are actually and in point of fact "advertising that site" because people are stupid and will look them up - even when they're told they're bad and scams.

Stop doing that.
I actually do not believe that any of the sites here I mentioned in all 5 posts are scams so there is that. But also like I said it is not my fault that people are stupid and do not know what they are doing and anyone who is smart enough to click this thread and read any of this should know better and understand what they are doing with their items anyway.
Teksura 12. März 2019 um 0:30 
Ursprünglich geschrieben von TimmiWanted1243:
I actually do not believe that any of the sites here I mentioned in all 5 posts are scams so there is that.
Your determined and willful naivety doesn't make a difference.

Ursprünglich geschrieben von TimmiWanted1243:
But also like I said it is not my fault that people are stupid
It is when you're the one advertising and promoting the sites for them.
Ursprünglich geschrieben von Teksura:
Okay, well that's already super suspicious and gives them everything they need to steal your identity, while also being really, really easy for a scammer to work around.

That is what pretty much every mainstream banking/crypto site does as well. Paypal could steal my identity the same way they could.
How is this even remotely "easy to work around"?
From Lootbear:
We require:

- A photo of the account owner (you) with a government issued ID, (driver’s license or passport) as well as a piece of paper saying “Lootbear” + the current date.

- A link to a social media account. (Facebook, LinkedIn, Instagram, VK, Twitter).

- Should the payment owner be a parent, the person who owns the debit/credit card will need to provide verification, along with the Lootbear account owner.
If the parent provides a valid government issued ID, the Lootbear account owner can provide any type of ID.

- A photo of the payment card used on file next to the ID. We need to see the last 4 digits, as well as the name.

Ursprünglich geschrieben von Teksura:
This is just laughable. If they make these claims to you on the site, that's how you know they're liars. There exists no legal action they can take. Nobody is getting dragged into court over it because trading items in steam is not illegal and they'll never actually be worth any amount of effort to pull anyone into a civil case even if they CAN make a compelling argument that there was some kind of legally binding agreement across international borders which involved breaking the terms of service of the service they were using. "They will take legal action", hah! Ridiculous, Such action would be unstartable.

Meanwhile, if you're violating the SSA by using their site exactly as you just described then the best you can hope for is having your account locked for SSA violations.

For reference, it's a really bad idea for you to go around and encourage or promote breaking the SSA.
I would love to see you get passed this if you are so sure it is "laughable":

- Risk evaluation AI - An adaptive machine learning system that evaluates each rent risk level in real-time. It uses hundreds of signals about each user & payment and taps into data across our network of 100,000+ businesses to predict whether a user or payment is likely to be fraudulent.
- Credit insurance - We authorize your payment with an international card issuer. Meaning, if an item is stolen, your credit company or bank will charge you 110% of stolen items value.
- Scam signal - If fraud has being detected, our system sends out a signal (report) to Valve and to your local law enforcement as a theft felony.

And honestly who cares about whatever the SSA is. I live in Europe anyway.
< >
Beiträge 115 von 20
Pro Seite: 1530 50

Geschrieben am: 4. März 2019 um 23:44
Beiträge: 20