This topic has been locked
tiglo Jul 25, 2020 @ 5:08am
BUG in steam purchasing system - Double charge
Steam sent a mail after purchase that the "purchase failed" and that I should "try again". After the repurchase it turned out that they charged TWICE.

How do I get a refund?

Tried 3x through their support site. They don't READ the tickets - denied 3x ">2Hrs playing time"

Any way to get help, or should I bring in the big guns and sue them?

Anyone else with similar problems?

https://twitter.com/fixsteam1
< >
Showing 46-60 of 104 comments
tiglo Jul 25, 2020 @ 2:09pm 
Thanks, Vandread,

Top-answering because your reply is so long.

Indeed, many people seem to have opinions about how iDEAL works.

It is different. Much more direct than credit cards

If Steam support (that has now awoken) still does not refund I will definitely speak to the bank.


Originally posted by Vandread:
@Tiglo:
You can contact the company to ask them if they have received a double payment and request them to reverse the payment.
That is what I did 3 times


Originally posted by Vandread:
@Tiglo:
In this particular case, I would start with informing Steam of the situation and explaining what had happened. In as clear language as possible. From what I've gathered, you've done that.
And now, finally after 3 requests and a lot of noise here they have responded.

Originally posted by Vandread:
@Tiglo:
Ask them to check the records on the status of the iDEAL payment in question. You would've wanted to do this first, as their answer is necessary for later on.

Call your bank as well and ask them to check the status on the iDEAL payments (all of the ones involved here). Most notably the one that you believe has not been handled properly. Your bank will likely (help you) reach out to the CPSP (GlobalCollect BV / Ingenico ePayments) to verify what has happened.
Steampowered by globalcollect


Originally posted by Vandread:
@Tiglo:
To help you out some more, here's a list of the CPSPs for iDEAL:
https://www.ideal.nl/en/partners/acquirers-and-cpsps/
https://www.ideal.nl/partners/acquirers-en-cpsps/
Look up Ingenico there if you happen to need to contact them yourself. If you happen to pull a nice member of Steam Support, as well as a nice Customer Service employee at your bank, they may be willing to contact the CPSP for you instead. But chances are you won't be so lucky and might have to do it yourself (especially given the possible implications of (sensitive) personal data involved).

At that point, if the CPSP has received the money, but claims it has not transferred it to Steam, you will likely still need to have Steam's answer on whether or not the iDEAL payment had actually been completed. If Steam also says it has not, you can request the CPSP to reverse the payment. If it has been, request the reverse payment from Steam instead.

Critical here is that you keep Steam in the loop. Outright reversing a payment is likely going to get your account in trouble - Valve really does not like you messing around with reversing payments.

So basically this is a problem outside my sphere of influence, with a third company that Steam uses, and you are telling me that *I* should sort it out with this third party and keep Steam informed?

To me this sounds like the world turned upside-down.


Originally posted by Vandread:
@Tiglo:
Take this one step at a time, don't try to rush through. And above all: try to stay calm. =)

Thanks. Until a few hours ago I couldn't even get Steam to acknowledge there is a problem, so there is some progress.


Originally posted by Vandread:
@Tiglo:
For what it's worth - iDEAL is a pretty great system in general. 60% of the online payments done in the Netherlands run by it. I'm not saying its infallible, but in all the times I've used it, this has never even occurred once, which... kind of makes me believe iDEAL as a system isn't at fault here.


ALL: sorry that the discussion deteriorated, but it is my honest opinion that whatever happened is NOT my fault. Either Steam OR a company tasked by Steam to deliver a service borked up. And that is essentially also Steams' responsibility to solve. They can not simply point at a subcontractor and say "gfy"

tiglo Jul 25, 2020 @ 2:14pm 
Originally posted by cinedine:
More importantly:

Have you talked to support yet to reverse the charge? Or do you keep trying with refunds.

Because that's what you should focus on instead of putting blame on anyone.

I have now finally received a response from "Marco", and have sent him the screenshot he requested
cinedine Jul 25, 2020 @ 2:16pm 
Originally posted by tiglo:
And now, finally after 3 requests and a lot of noise here they have responded.
[...]
Thanks. Until a few hours ago I couldn't even get Steam to acknowledge there is a problem, so there is some progress.

Well, you tried with an *automated* refund system instead of going through the proper channels. What do you expect?
This one is on you. :P
tiglo Jul 25, 2020 @ 2:27pm 
Originally posted by cinedine:
Originally posted by tiglo:
And now, finally after 3 requests and a lot of noise here they have responded.
[...]
Thanks. Until a few hours ago I couldn't even get Steam to acknowledge there is a problem, so there is some progress.

Well, you tried with an *automated* refund system instead of going through the proper channels. What do you expect?
This one is on you. :P

Not really

Well, if it is automated, why does it ask me to leave a note? That gives me the impression that it is actually a human looking at it. The first response took TWO DAYS, which is also not typical for an automated system.

IS it an automated system, and is Steam only TRYING to make it look human, or is it a human? It does not SAY it is automated, it just sends the same response after some time..

As noted earlier, I tried 3 different routes, explaining why I wanted a refund every time. And now someone is actually looking at it. It seems....
Gambit-3k Jul 25, 2020 @ 2:47pm 
So I'm having trouble understanding why you didn't select "I was double-charged for this purchase" which is the option directly below "I would like to request a refund" if that's what the problem was and your goal is simply having that charge corrected. Why would you not choose the option that precisely matches what your issue is?
Last edited by Gambit-3k; Jul 25, 2020 @ 9:17pm
Vandread Jul 25, 2020 @ 2:57pm 
Originally posted by tiglo:
So basically this is a problem outside my sphere of influence, with a third company that Steam uses, and you are telling me that *I* should sort it out with this third party and keep Steam informed?

To me this sounds like the world turned upside-down.
It does sound like the world turned upside-down. I know. However, if the payment never made it to Steam, they can't do a whole lot to even confirm the payment was made in the first place.

Basically what I'm suggesting is that you approach it from both angles. You can approach your bank rather easily, ask them to check what has happened. Your bank can verify the payment having been made up until the CPSP. Beyond that, your bank cannot help you... well, maybe they can, but I don't think you want them to. A forceful reverse payment could lead to a ban on your Steam account.

If the payment never made it to Steam, Valve has no records of it. From what I gather, you have given them proof of the double payment, so now they are able to trace back up until the CPSP. Somewhere in the chain something went sideways and borked up.

I understand your frustration, and I also admit that it's definitely "not right" that you'd have to start chasing things down by yourself - but that does give you the result you're after. As you've experienced, Steam is slow. So, the more information you can feed them on your support ticket that shows where the problem is somewhere in the chain, the faster it gets resolved. You do need to give this some time sadly.

They may still be able to request the CPSP to reverse the payment regardless of it making it to Steam or not. I'm not entirely certain how this works precisely actually. Either way, from your point of view, it's both "better" and "easier" if Steam initiates the procedure from their end - because that also leaves a paper trail on their end that you can refer to if the need arises.

Originally posted by tiglo:
ALL: sorry that the discussion deteriorated, but it is my honest opinion that whatever happened is NOT my fault. Either Steam OR a company tasked by Steam to deliver a service borked up. And that is essentially also Steams' responsibility to solve. They can not simply point at a subcontractor and say "gfy"
Yup. That's pretty much how I think about this as well. Steam is still the "store" in this, and that is where you turn to first and foremost. Anyone behind the store is practically irrelevant. You're basically only doing some legwork here to show you've fulfilled your part of the contract, after that it should be up to them.

Just try to stay calm. Wait out what Steam Support says.

I hope it gets resolved swiftly and in a fashion you can approve of. =)
tiglo Jul 25, 2020 @ 5:57pm 
Originally posted by Gambit-3:
So i'm having trouble understanding why you didn't select "I was double-charged for this purchase" which is the option directly below "I would like to request a refund" if that's what the problem was and your goal is simply having that charge corrected. Why would you not choose the option that precisely matches what your issue is?

Hi, Thanks for taking the time to contribute to this thread. I think I have mentioned it before, but there is NO OPTION "I was double-charged for this purchase". in the location you suggest. Please see the screenshot here: https://i.imgur.com/HPduE93.png

The first refund request was "accidentally purchased twice" - which imho also covers the incident even though the second purchase was made after they sent me a mail.

To be honest, I'm getting fed up with this discussion and me having to prove that *I* did not make a mistake again and again.
Gambit-3k Jul 25, 2020 @ 6:10pm 
Originally posted by tiglo:
Originally posted by Gambit-3:
So i'm having trouble understanding why you didn't select "I was double-charged for this purchase" which is the option directly below "I would like to request a refund" if that's what the problem was and your goal is simply having that charge corrected. Why would you not choose the option that precisely matches what your issue is?

Hi, Thanks for taking the time to contribute to this thread. I think I have mentioned it before, but there is NO OPTION "I was double-charged for this purchase". in the location you suggest. Please see the screenshot here: https://i.imgur.com/HPduE93.png

The first refund request was "accidentally purchased twice" - which imho also covers the incident even though the second purchase was made after they sent me a mail.

To be honest, I'm getting fed up with this discussion and me having to prove that *I* did not make a mistake again and again.
That's interesting, every purchase I've ever made has that option, so of course I thought everyone else's would too. I guess it must be something to do with the payment method, hopefully you can see why I thought it would be the same across the board.

In the future if you ever need help from an actual person when dealing with refunds, make sure to select "I have a question regarding this purchase", of course I understand you couldn't magically know that before hand. Good luck getting the problem resolved.

edit:
You're in contact with Steam support at this point, just be patient and deal with them and I'm sure they'll help you get the issue resolved.
Last edited by Gambit-3k; Jul 26, 2020 @ 3:20pm
crunchyfrog Jul 25, 2020 @ 6:11pm 
Originally posted by tiglo:
- It was charged to a debit card, and I can NOT contest it like with a credit card.

- The charge is NOT on hold

- The first purchase is NOT listed as failed

- After the first purchase I received an email from Steam:

<quote>
Hello xxx
There was an error with a recent Steam purchase.
We've saved your cart (including discounts) for 72 hours so you can attempt your purchase again.
Click here to repurchase. This cart will expire on 24 Jul @ 8:00pm CEST.
</quote>

AFTER this email I had no access to the game so I retried, and that purchase went well
ONLY then it turned out that the first purchase went through

This is clearly a bug in their system

No there's no bug. You're not understanding how ALL online purchases work on the whole internet. Let me try to explain.

All online payments use a variant of the BACS payment system (it's more complicated than that but I'm not going to explain that here). There's certain security features built in, one of which is that the window for the handshake between your card provider or bank and the vendor is VERY short, only a couple of seconds or probably less these days.

It's deliberately kept short to mitigate people trying to hack and piggyback the data flow.

But, because of this short window, if you're using either a third party card provider (that may have more hopps to jump through to do the transaction) or some internet hiccup happens, it will fail with the message something like "there has been some sort of problem...." That too is kept deliberately vague as a security feature too.

But in the rarest of cases, it can fail at the SAME time as one side gets the handshake. This is likely what has happened in your case.

So what happens is that you will see the money go from your account (it doesn't actually, it's just set aside, waiting), and the vendor's end hasn't had anything. But there's backup systems in place, and there's some sort of period update that goes through (it used to be end-of-day routines way back in the day) and it CAN end up receiving the data hours afterwards or the next day, so it will sort itself out.

But not always though - and as such the procedure goes that the money still sits reserved in your account for around 3 working days. If that backup doesn't complete the transaction then the funds are freed up for you then.

If you're using a bank debit card, you can ring them up if this happens and if the staff are well trained they can see the failure there and then and release the funds for you to try again. However, if it's after about 4 days, they can't because the point's going to be moot by then.


So, in summary, you've likely had this with ONE of those payments. It failed so you've only been charged once.

But just in case it has double paid (I've never heard of it happening like that) you absolutely CAN ring your bank up and dispute the charge. I've done this on my debit card a few times.

Hope this helps you understand things a bit clearer.
tiglo Jul 25, 2020 @ 6:11pm 
Originally posted by Vandread:
Originally posted by tiglo:
So basically this is a problem outside my sphere of influence, with a third company that Steam uses, and you are telling me that *I* should sort it out with this third party and keep Steam informed?

To me this sounds like the world turned upside-down.
It does sound like the world turned upside-down. I know. However, if the payment never made it to Steam, they can't do a whole lot to even confirm the payment was made in the first place.

Both purchases are listed in my purchase history, and there are no outstanding charges or "holds". Moreover steam support has now confirmed that the purchases were completed, so afaic Steam knows the payment was made.

Originally posted by Vandread:
Basically what I'm suggesting is that you approach it from both angles. You can approach your bank rather easily, ask them to check what has happened. Your bank can verify the payment having been made up until the CPSP. Beyond that, your bank cannot help you... well, maybe they can, but I don't think you want them to. A forceful reverse payment could lead to a ban on your Steam account.
Actually, right now that outcome wouldn't bother me at all. It is my first purchase on Steam, so no other games to loose. The experience has been extremely bad and gives me no confidence in Steam whatsoever, and I doubt if I will *ever* buy any game on steam again unless they own up to their problem and solve it.


Originally posted by Vandread:
If the payment never made it to Steam, Valve has no records of it. From what I gather, you have given them proof of the double payment, so now they are able to trace back up until the CPSP. Somewhere in the chain something went sideways and borked up.

I understand your frustration, and I also admit that it's definitely "not right" that you'd have to start chasing things down by yourself - but that does give you the result you're after. As you've experienced, Steam is slow. So, the more information you can feed them on your support ticket that shows where the problem is somewhere in the chain, the faster it gets resolved. You do need to give this some time sadly.

They may still be able to request the CPSP to reverse the payment regardless of it making it to Steam or not. I'm not entirely certain how this works precisely actually. Either way, from your point of view, it's both "better" and "easier" if Steam initiates the procedure from their end - because that also leaves a paper trail on their end that you can refer to if the need arises.
I would be surprised if the CPSP would do that. As far as they are concerned they handled two payments correctly. The only reason I re-purchased the game was because Steam sent me an email that the purchase failed and that I should try to purchase again. After that it appeared twice in my purchase history and once in my game library

Originally posted by Vandread:
Just try to stay calm. Wait out what Steam Support says.

I hope it gets resolved swiftly and in a fashion you can approve of. =)

Yes, I'll give them some days to respond to the screenshot I sent them.
crunchyfrog Jul 25, 2020 @ 6:15pm 
Just note, Steam WILL say there's two payments because from their end that's correct info . As I explained, the problem lies somewhere in the middle at the point of handshake.

I'm not sure what you're expecting Valve to do, as they might not be able to do anything here. As I said, you really should be talking to your bank, because in any case, Valve are likelygoing to want such evidence from them before they'll do anything in any case.

I repeat, debit card does NOT mean you can't challenge payments or speak to staff about failures, etc.As I said, I've done it MANY times.

Last edited by crunchyfrog; Jul 25, 2020 @ 6:16pm
tiglo Jul 25, 2020 @ 6:17pm 
Originally posted by crunchyfrog:

So, in summary, you've likely had this with ONE of those payments. It failed so you've only been charged once.

But just in case it has double paid (I've never heard of it happening like that) you absolutely CAN ring your bank up and dispute the charge. I've done this on my debit card a few times.

Hope this helps you understand things a bit clearer.

*sigh* here we go again. You are making assumptions.

I have a bank statement with two separate charges from Steam

I *did* purchase twice - The second time AFTER Steam sent me an email that the first purchase failed

After the second purchase I could play the game.
crunchyfrog Jul 25, 2020 @ 6:20pm 
Originally posted by tiglo:
Originally posted by crunchyfrog:

So, in summary, you've likely had this with ONE of those payments. It failed so you've only been charged once.

But just in case it has double paid (I've never heard of it happening like that) you absolutely CAN ring your bank up and dispute the charge. I've done this on my debit card a few times.

Hope this helps you understand things a bit clearer.

*sigh* here we go again. You are making assumptions.

I have a bank statement with two separate charges from Steam

I *did* purchase twice - The second time AFTER Steam sent me an email that the first purchase failed

After the second purchase I could play the game.

And have you spoken to your bank? That's the point.

I didn't type all that explanation out for fun. Please read it carefully and you'll understand why you need to talk to your card provider first.
tiglo Jul 25, 2020 @ 6:22pm 
Originally posted by crunchyfrog:
Just note, Steam WILL say there's two payments because from their end that's correct info . As I explained, the problem lies somewhere in the middle at the point of handshake.

I'm not sure what you're expecting Valve to do, as they might not be able to do anything here. As I said, you really should be talking to your bank, because in any case, Valve are likelygoing to want such evidence from them before they'll do anything in any case.

I repeat, debit card does NOT mean you can't challenge payments or speak to staff about failures, etc.As I said, I've done it MANY times.

I am expecting Steam to issue a refund. That should not be that difficult, and I have a valid reason to demand one - Steam sent me a mail claiming that my initial purchase failed, asking me to retry, which I did.

steam acknowledges that two purchases were made, I have a deal with Steam and NOT with any middle-man they employ
crunchyfrog Jul 25, 2020 @ 6:25pm 
Originally posted by tiglo:
Originally posted by crunchyfrog:
Just note, Steam WILL say there's two payments because from their end that's correct info . As I explained, the problem lies somewhere in the middle at the point of handshake.

I'm not sure what you're expecting Valve to do, as they might not be able to do anything here. As I said, you really should be talking to your bank, because in any case, Valve are likelygoing to want such evidence from them before they'll do anything in any case.

I repeat, debit card does NOT mean you can't challenge payments or speak to staff about failures, etc.As I said, I've done it MANY times.

I am expecting Steam to issue a refund. That should not be that difficult, and I have a valid reason to demand one - Steam sent me a mail claiming that my initial purchase failed, asking me to retry, which I did.

steam acknowledges that two purchases were made, I have a deal with Steam and NOT with any middle-man they employ

You are dreadfully confused. There IS NO middleman - I don't know where you're getting that idea from.

If you read my posts, which you clearly haven't or haven't understood it, you'd see WHY you need to speak to your bank FIRST.

If you won't take the correct advice I'm giving you, then there's no point in carrying on here.

I can only lead a horse to water.
< >
Showing 46-60 of 104 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Jul 25, 2020 @ 5:08am
Posts: 104