Cities: Skylines II

Cities: Skylines II

View Stats:
Reviews Suck
Can anyone here convince me this is better than the original? Are the railroads in this version better. Honest opinions only, no fan boys please.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 23 comments
MC858 Jan 4 @ 1:42pm 
paradox games always end up broken and trash on release before the wave of DLC. this one is just taking longer to fix and the first game is good enough so people just went back to playing it and waiting on this to get better
Originally posted by MC858:
paradox games always end up broken and trash on release before the wave of DLC. this one is just taking longer to fix and the first game is good enough so people just went back to playing it and waiting on this to get better

Thanks, I still play the original and I'll continue to wait. I was hoping the rail network gets improved
Originally posted by Sgt.Johnson:
Can anyone here convince me this is better than the original? Are the railroads in this version better. Honest opinions only, no fan boys please.
no
Cats and Jamaica Steel Drum Music could make this game so much better.
The game has potential, especially with a bunch of mods, but there's still no asset editor and even if the game works okay on your rig, it's still a bore due to the lack of content/unique assets.
Can we convince you right now… nope the reviews are warranted

Are trains better as it stands no, they are different and if the paradox mods ever get the variety that the steam workshop gets then maybe yes.

Will this be better in the long run, yes I believe so there is enough foundational upgrades in there to be sculpted in to a better game. It has a LOT of fixing and polishing still to be done, they really did drop the ball
Originally posted by Sgt.Johnson:
Can anyone here convince me this is better than the original? Are the railroads in this version better. Honest opinions only, no fan boys please.
When all bugs got fixed, the whole "crash all the time" problems get resolved, the performance issues get solved, the missing animations get added, and we finally get custom assets, roads and companies - and similar mods to the popular CS1 mods (some are already there, others are still missing) - then it might be better than the original.

It has already new and some interesting different features than CS1, but with all those above problems it's not really fun to play.
I guess it will take another 1-2 years until it's really comparable to CS1.
Reviews are high IMO. Give it a few years. If it hasn't been abandoned by then, ask again.
Pick a post, I agree with it.
And now that I posted on it, it will die. Ask me how I know.
Last edited by zaltocleotl[Banned@Paradox]; Jan 4 @ 5:41pm
Originally posted by Sgt.Johnson:
Can anyone here convince me this is better than the original? Are the railroads in this version better. Honest opinions only, no fan boys please.

Well, Some things are better, but I can count them "better" things on a well a single hand....

Building a road network, railroad is definitely an improvement but I can't say the AI is an improvement at all, In fact thats what is keeping me from playing so much is the stupid AI like they are in my opinion worse than CS1.

Performance, yeah if you like 15 20 or 30 fps when your city gets to any reasonable size, this is your game!!
Originally posted by MC858:
paradox games always end up broken and trash on release before the wave of DLC. this one is just taking longer to fix and the first game is good enough so people just went back to playing it and waiting on this to get better

its been over a year and the game is still broken
Originally posted by Sgt.Johnson:
Originally posted by MC858:
paradox games always end up broken and trash on release before the wave of DLC. this one is just taking longer to fix and the first game is good enough so people just went back to playing it and waiting on this to get better

Thanks, I still play the original and I'll continue to wait. I was hoping the rail network gets improved

Like the tram depot you now need subway and train deports and the tracks/connections are a bit smoother but those are the only positives. There are way less stations and no elevated, sunken or island ones, and only 2 train models each for cargo and passenger (north american and european), which even if you only have diesel (north america) requires catenary which would make sense if you were able to change the train types, which you can't (If you choose North American you can't use European trains which could be used in america irl, same for all the other service buildings) These could be fixed with mods, but modding is still in beta and there are only code mods, no asset mods.

I'd say original is better especially for rails and transportation.
Originally posted by Denim Chicken:
Reviews are high IMO. Give it a few years. If it hasn't been abandoned by then, ask again.

Overall Steam review rating is mixed. That's not good. Majority of recent reviews are negative
Originally posted by Sgt.Johnson:
Can anyone here convince me this is better than the original? Are the railroads in this version better. Honest opinions only, no fan boys please.

Base game to base game, yes, this is better. Against fully loaded C:S1 with all DLC and mods, no.

Railways are much better as you can now make proper lines and have trains reversing along the way etc. You got much more advanced AI (single train track AI is built in) to make more complex networks that actually do work. You can for example make train to turn around in a triangle track (Y for muricans) if you so want to. Or pull out from one station and then reverse to another station.
Originally posted by Sgt.Johnson:
Can anyone here convince me this is better than the original? Are the railroads in this version better. Honest opinions only, no fan boys please.

I think I played like 300 hours in CS1 and I've probably got double that in CS2 by now. I'm not here to convince you, but for a player of my play-style (which you don't know how I prefer to play) CS2 is far better, even with all the buggy crappy crashing feature starved game we have now.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 23 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Jan 4 @ 1:32pm
Posts: 23