Store Page
Half-Life
All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews

Half-Life

Store Page
Half-Life > General Discussions > Topic Details
Groovy Reject Oct 23, 2018 @ 4:25pm
I need help with half-life sdk
So I've been making maps for half-life (goldsource) for a while, but all of the sudden, the maps aren't compiling right, here's what the compilation looks like for the thing I'm working on.



** Executing...
** Command: D:\PROGRA~1\Steam\STEAMA~1\common\HALF-L~2\HAMMER~1\tools\ZHLT\hlvis.exe
** Parameters: "D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1"

hlvis v3.4 Final (Feb 25 2006)
Zoner's Half-Life Compilation Tools -- Custom Build
Based on code modifications by Sean 'Zoner' Cavanaugh
Based on Valve's version, modified with permission.
Submit detailed bug reports to (amckern@yahoo.com)
----- BEGIN hlvis -----
Command line: D:\PROGRA~1\Steam\STEAMA~1\common\HALF-L~2\HAMMER~1\tools\ZHLT\hlvis.exe "D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1"
>> There was a problem compiling the map.
>> Check the file D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1.log for the cause.

----- END hlvis -----




** Executing...
** Command: D:\PROGRA~1\Steam\STEAMA~1\common\HALF-L~2\HAMMER~1\tools\ZHLT\hlrad.exe
** Parameters: "D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1"

hlrad v3.4 Final (Feb 25 2006)
Zoner's Half-Life Compilation Tools -- Custom Build
Based on code modifications by Sean 'Zoner' Cavanaugh
Based on Valve's version, modified with permission.
Submit detailed bug reports to (amckern@yahoo.com)
----- BEGIN hlrad -----
Command line: D:\PROGRA~1\Steam\STEAMA~1\common\HALF-L~2\HAMMER~1\tools\ZHLT\hlrad.exe "D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1"
>> There was a problem compiling the map.
>> Check the file D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1.log for the cause.

----- END hlrad -----


I also have an external hard drive (a small black brick that provides 2 terabytes of space) hooked up to the side of my laptop and I use half-life sdk version 3.4 if that's important.
The author of this topic has marked a post as the answer to their question.
Click here to jump to that post.
Originally posted by Peter Brev:
Assumptions. It's not complicated if you do things correctly.

13 brushes (totalling 82 sides) discarded from clipping hulls CreateBrush: Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 0: plane with no normal Error: plane with no normal Description: The map has a problem which must be fixed Howto Fix: Check the file http://www.zhlt.info/common-mapping-problems.html for a detailed explanation of this problem Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 1: plane with no normal Error: Entity 16, Brush 1, Side 2: plane with no normal Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 1: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 69), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 2: plane with no normal Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 2: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 1: outside world(+/-4096): (-2749,-9616,-10000)-(9591,2830,10000) Error: Entity 16, Brush 1: outside world(+/-4096): (-2749,-9616,-10000)-(9591,2830,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 2: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 1: outside world(+/-4096): (-2749,-9616,-10000)-(9591,2830,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: plane with no normal Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 1: plane with no normal Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (161, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 2: plane with no normal Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (161, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 2: has a coplanar plane at (156, -17, 55), texture BLACK Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (161, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 3: plane with no normal Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 5: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 3: has a coplanar plane at (154, -10, 56), texture BLACK Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 3: has a coplanar plane at (154, -10, 56), texture BLACK Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 16, Brush 3: outside world(+/-4096): (-2607,-9575,-10000)-(2887,9655,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 16, Brush 3: outside world(+/-4096): (-2607,-9575,-10000)-(2887,9655,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9, Side 0: plane with no normal Error: Entity 25, Brush 9, Side 4: plane with no normal Error: Entity 25, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (142, -27, 57), texture TABLE Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) (1.00 seconds)

There are your issue.

If you're using Half-Life SDK/VHE, just stop using that and use something more up to date like Jackhammer or Sledge. Both will make your life easier in building your world, fixing issues, etc.
< >
Showing 1-11 of 11 comments
SURVIVOR-DUP Oct 23, 2018 @ 4:27pm 
>> There was a problem compiling the map. >> Check the file D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1.log for the cause.
Check that directory.
#1
Groovy Reject Oct 23, 2018 @ 5:31pm 
It's the messed up compilation for the map, but there is a URL that says to go to

http://www.zhlt.info/common-mapping-problems.html

but besides that it,s the compilation
#2
SURVIVOR-DUP Oct 23, 2018 @ 5:46pm 
Originally posted by TheManOfButtons:
It's the messed up compilation for the map, but there is a URL that says to go to

http://www.zhlt.info/common-mapping-problems.html

but besides that it,s the compilation
Send me the .log file.
#3
LiveWire Oct 24, 2018 @ 12:04pm 
Have you got the full log as I cant see that hlcsg.exe hlbsp.exe have run.
Could it be that you unchecked them?



#4
Groovy Reject Oct 24, 2018 @ 6:36pm 
this is what the .log file looks like


hlcsg v3.4 Final (Feb 25 2006)
Zoner's Half-Life Compilation Tools -- Custom Build
Based on code modifications by Sean 'Zoner' Cavanaugh
Based on Valve's version, modified with permission.
Submit detailed bug reports to (amckern@yahoo.com)
----- BEGIN hlcsg -----
Command line: D:\PROGRA~1\Steam\STEAMA~1\common\HALF-L~2\HAMMER~1\tools\ZHLT\hlcsg.exe "D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1"
Entering D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1.map

Current hlcsg Settings
Name | Setting | Default
---------------------|-----------|-------------------------
threads [ 2 ] [ Varies ]
verbose [ off ] [ off ]
log [ on ] [ on ]
developer [ 0 ] [ 0 ]
chart [ off ] [ off ]
estimate [ off ] [ off ]
max texture memory [ 4194304 ] [ 4194304 ]
max lighting memory [ 6291456 ] [ 6291456 ]
priority [ Normal ] [ Normal ]

noclip [ off ] [ off ]
null texture stripping[ on ] [ on ]
clipnode economy mode [ on ] [ on ]
clip hull type [ legacy ] [ legacy ]
onlyents [ off ] [ off ]
wadtextures [ on ] [ on ]
skyclip [ on ] [ on ]
hullfile [ None ] [ None ]
nullfile [ None ] [ None ]
min surface area [ 0.500 ] [ 0.500 ]
brush union threshold [ 0.000 ] [ 0.000 ]

Using mapfile wad configuration
Wadinclude list :
[zhlt.wad]

13 brushes (totalling 82 sides) discarded from clipping hulls
CreateBrush:
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 0: plane with no normal
Error: plane with no normal
Description: The map has a problem which must be fixed
Howto Fix: Check the file http://www.zhlt.info/common-mapping-problems.html for a detailed explanation of this problem

Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 1: plane with no normal
Error: Entity 16, Brush 1, Side 2: plane with no normal
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 1: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 69), texture LAB1_COMP3F
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 2: plane with no normal
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 2: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F
Error: Entity 16, Brush 1: outside world(+/-4096): (-2749,-9616,-10000)-(9591,2830,10000)
Error: Entity 16, Brush 1: outside world(+/-4096): (-2749,-9616,-10000)-(9591,2830,10000)
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 2: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F
Error: Entity 16, Brush 1: outside world(+/-4096): (-2749,-9616,-10000)-(9591,2830,10000)
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: plane with no normal
Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 1: plane with no normal
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (161, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F
Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 2: plane with no normal
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (161, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F
Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 2: has a coplanar plane at (156, -17, 55), texture BLACK
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (161, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F
Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 3: plane with no normal
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 5: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F
Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 3: has a coplanar plane at (154, -10, 56), texture BLACK
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 3: has a coplanar plane at (154, -10, 56), texture BLACK
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 16, Brush 3: outside world(+/-4096): (-2607,-9575,-10000)-(2887,9655,10000)
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 16, Brush 3: outside world(+/-4096): (-2607,-9575,-10000)-(2887,9655,10000)
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9, Side 0: plane with no normal
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9, Side 4: plane with no normal
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (142, -27, 57), texture TABLE
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000)
(1.00 seconds)

----- END hlcsg -----



hlbsp v3.4 Final (Feb 25 2006)
Zoner's Half-Life Compilation Tools -- Custom Build
Based on code modifications by Sean 'Zoner' Cavanaugh
Based on Valve's version, modified with permission.
Submit detailed bug reports to (amckern@yahoo.com)
----- BEGIN hlbsp -----
Command line: D:\PROGRA~1\Steam\STEAMA~1\common\HALF-L~2\HAMMER~1\tools\ZHLT\hlbsp.exe "D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1"
>> There was a problem compiling the map.
>> Check the file D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1.log for the cause.

----- END hlbsp -----



hlvis v3.4 Final (Feb 25 2006)
Zoner's Half-Life Compilation Tools -- Custom Build
Based on code modifications by Sean 'Zoner' Cavanaugh
Based on Valve's version, modified with permission.
Submit detailed bug reports to (amckern@yahoo.com)
----- BEGIN hlvis -----
Command line: D:\PROGRA~1\Steam\STEAMA~1\common\HALF-L~2\HAMMER~1\tools\ZHLT\hlvis.exe "D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1"
>> There was a problem compiling the map.
>> Check the file D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1.log for the cause.

----- END hlvis -----



hlrad v3.4 Final (Feb 25 2006)
Zoner's Half-Life Compilation Tools -- Custom Build
Based on code modifications by Sean 'Zoner' Cavanaugh
Based on Valve's version, modified with permission.
Submit detailed bug reports to (amckern@yahoo.com)
----- BEGIN hlrad -----
Command line: D:\PROGRA~1\Steam\STEAMA~1\common\HALF-L~2\HAMMER~1\tools\ZHLT\hlrad.exe "D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1"
>> There was a problem compiling the map.
>> Check the file D:\Program Files EXT\Steam\steamapps\common\Half-Life SDK\maps\esc1.log for the cause.

----- END hlrad -----
#5
Groovy Reject Oct 24, 2018 @ 6:41pm 
Originally posted by LiveWire:
Have you got the full log as I cant see that hlcsg.exe hlbsp.exe have run.
Could it be that you unchecked them?

nah I just checked, there all checked, I've tried different compilation tools in the configuration setting but nothing works :(.
#6
Groovy Reject Oct 24, 2018 @ 6:43pm 
why does old early 2000's technology half to be so complicated. I just want to make half-life maps.
Last edited by Groovy Reject; Oct 24, 2018 @ 6:44pm
#7
The author of this thread has indicated that this post answers the original topic.
Peter Brev Oct 24, 2018 @ 9:26pm 
Assumptions. It's not complicated if you do things correctly.

13 brushes (totalling 82 sides) discarded from clipping hulls CreateBrush: Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 0: plane with no normal Error: plane with no normal Description: The map has a problem which must be fixed Howto Fix: Check the file http://www.zhlt.info/common-mapping-problems.html for a detailed explanation of this problem Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 1: plane with no normal Error: Entity 16, Brush 1, Side 2: plane with no normal Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 1: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 69), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 2: plane with no normal Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 2: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 1: outside world(+/-4096): (-2749,-9616,-10000)-(9591,2830,10000) Error: Entity 16, Brush 1: outside world(+/-4096): (-2749,-9616,-10000)-(9591,2830,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 2: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 1: outside world(+/-4096): (-2749,-9616,-10000)-(9591,2830,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: plane with no normal Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 1: plane with no normal Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (161, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 2: plane with no normal Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (161, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 2: has a coplanar plane at (156, -17, 55), texture BLACK Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (161, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 3: plane with no normal Error: Entity 0, Brush 9, Side 5: has a coplanar plane at (156, 65, 67), texture LAB1_COMP3F Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 3: has a coplanar plane at (154, -10, 56), texture BLACK Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 16, Brush 3, Side 3: has a coplanar plane at (154, -10, 56), texture BLACK Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 16, Brush 3: outside world(+/-4096): (-2607,-9575,-10000)-(2887,9655,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 16, Brush 3: outside world(+/-4096): (-2607,-9575,-10000)-(2887,9655,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 0, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9, Side 0: plane with no normal Error: Entity 25, Brush 9, Side 4: plane with no normal Error: Entity 25, Brush 9, Side 4: has a coplanar plane at (142, -27, 57), texture TABLE Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999968,-10000,-10000)-(999999968,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) Error: Entity 25, Brush 9: outside world(+/-4096): (999999984,-10000,-10000)-(999999984,10000,10000) (1.00 seconds)

There are your issue.

If you're using Half-Life SDK/VHE, just stop using that and use something more up to date like Jackhammer or Sledge. Both will make your life easier in building your world, fixing issues, etc.
#8
LiveWire Oct 25, 2018 @ 11:42am 
Hammer works just fine if you know what your doing :steammocking:, but as Peter said your would be better off with jackhammer as it has a tool to help prevent invalid brushes, as well as an auto save function.

Get it here, then run check for problems on your map ALT + P or in Map menu, my guess is the map has been corrupted or is decompiled.
http://jack.hlfx.ru/en/download.html


#9
Groovy Reject Oct 26, 2018 @ 3:09pm 
Thank you guys so much for the help, everything works great, and perhaps even better then what I used to use (is it sad that when I inserted an info_player_start and seeing its 3D Gordan Freeman player model in the 3D view window absolutely blew the brains out of my mind).
#10
LiveWire Oct 27, 2018 @ 5:27am 
Oh hammer 3.5 has been able to show models for years, it just that valve have old versions in the SDK.

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=830153981
#11
< >
Showing 1-11 of 11 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Half-Life > General Discussions > Topic Details
Date Posted: Oct 23, 2018 @ 4:25pm
Posts: 11

Discussions Rules and Guidelines