can't plant pumpkins in fall, lol what? :: My Time at Portia General Discussions

Store Page

My Time at Portia

All Discussions Screenshots Artwork Broadcasts Videos News Guides Reviews

My Time at Portia > General Discussions > Topic Details

Hexo Mia

Oct 27, 2020 @ 10:46am

can't plant pumpkins in fall, lol what?

is this for real? can't harvest pumpkins on the season of pumpkins, do this devs don't even bother on searching for this plants season, jesus christ.

can't have pumpkins on halloween then lol.

< >

Showing 1-11 of 11 comments

Ihateeverybody has My Time at Portia

Oct 27, 2020 @ 11:49am

In real life wouldn't you plant the pumpkins in Summer and Harvest them in Fall. I don't know, I didn't bother to google.

I like Pumpkin Pie. Toasted Pumpkin Seeds, Can't think of anything else pumpkin related...Bread?

Hexo Mia

Oct 27, 2020 @ 12:18pm

Originally posted by Ihateeverybody:
In real life wouldn't you plant the pumpkins in Summer and Harvest them in Fall. I don't know, I didn't bother to google.

I like Pumpkin Pie. Toasted Pumpkin Seeds, Can't think of anything else pumpkin
related...Bread?

ofc in REAL LIFE, but pumpkings take 4 days to grow IN THE GAME, it makes no freaking sense.

Ihateeverybody has My Time at Portia

Oct 27, 2020 @ 12:25pm

Cmon...Seriously? Plant them in Summer or check if Sophia has them. What's your actual argument (Not that I really want to argue)?

The devs probley looked and Saw Plant in Summer to harvest in Fall, that's what I saw on the one site I looked at. Plant after the last Frost (Spring) or Mid July to harvest the week before Halloween. Not sure what region (Earth is a big place).

You can argue for Reality or you can Argue for Fantasy (in that case why even have seasons) but please don't do both just because you feel slighted.

Adesanya

Oct 27, 2020 @ 1:20pm

Originally posted by Ihateeverybody:
In real life wouldn't you plant the pumpkins in Summer and Harvest them in Fall. I don't know, I didn't bother to google.

I like Pumpkin Pie. Toasted Pumpkin Seeds, Can't think of anything else pumpkin related...Bread?

IRL you plant pumpkins in SPRIG ..they take a LONG time. Here in Tucson, my neighbors planted their pumpkins in the beginning of February and harvested in September.

House Gnome has My Time at Portia

Oct 27, 2020 @ 4:15pm

We planted our pumpkins in late May and just harvested the last ones yesterday, first were harvested two weeks ago.

Hexo Mia

Oct 27, 2020 @ 6:21pm

Originally posted by Ihateeverybody:
Cmon...Seriously? Plant them in Summer or check if Sophia has them. What's your actual argument (Not that I really want to argue)?

The devs probley looked and Saw Plant in Summer to harvest in Fall, that's what I saw on the one site I looked at. Plant after the last Frost (Spring) or Mid July to harvest the week before Halloween. Not sure what region (Earth is a big place).

You can argue for Reality or you can Argue for Fantasy (in that case why even have seasons) but please don't do both just because you feel slighted.

the thing is, the seeds take 4 days to grow, not 4 MONTHS, even stardew valley got this right.

Ihateeverybody has My Time at Portia

Oct 28, 2020 @ 2:58pm

Yes they take 4 days in Spring and Summer (going off of memory). Whats the problem? You can't grow them in Fall. You have no basis for arguing you should be able to. None. You have two months to grow them. Says right on the Seeds.

You are attempting to use reality (Fall is Pumpkin Season) as an argument for but refusing to acknowledge reailty in the refutation of your argument.

blade_125

Oct 29, 2020 @ 7:14pm

See, you should follow my lead. I've noticed that Pumpkins have been rising in value all through September and October, and I have a feeling they will peak in...January. Then I sell and reap the profits.

PinkOrc

Oct 31, 2020 @ 8:02am

Understandably you associate pumpkins with autumn (pumpkinspice and halloween) and all but think of MTI a bit of a different world where everything got mutated, how about you make the layered carrot the portian equivalent of a pumpkin ^^ the golden radish soup already looks like a pumpkinsoup.
(i dont remember them use pumpkins during the day of memory anyway)

Last edited by PinkOrc; Oct 31, 2020 @ 8:08am

The Yeen Queen has My Time at Portia

Oct 31, 2020 @ 9:50am

Originally posted by Roderick✪Legend:
Originally posted by Ihateeverybody:
In real life wouldn't you plant the pumpkins in Summer and Harvest them in Fall. I don't know, I didn't bother to google.

I like Pumpkin Pie. Toasted Pumpkin Seeds, Can't think of anything else pumpkin
related...Bread?

ofc in REAL LIFE, but pumpkings take 4 days to grow IN THE GAME, it makes no freaking sense.

I mean, you're the one who started arguing about comparing to real life in whining about not being able to harvest pumpkins in "The season of pumpkins". He's right, they don't grow in the fall, they're ripe at the end of Summer/start of Fall.

#10