Fish Fillets for the Bishop

[Ivaer]

Hello! I just tried to complete my fish fillet quest for the Bishop and was wondering if anyone else came across the same thing:

He asks for 4 fish fillets, and when you talk to him it shows bronze star. I got exactly 4 fish fillets ready to go before he left for the day, but it turns out ONE of them was silver quality, leading me to end up having to waste another week waiting to kick this off (though I've read the other issues with church/cathedral/citizen progression issues and am not SUPER bummed by this). It's a small thing, but I would've thought ANY quality fish fillet should count for such a quest; if the guy truly wants something nice to eat you'd think he'd be A-OK with getting a nice fish fillet. But nope, silver doesn't count, because the quest REQUIRES bronze star.

Not a big deal, but it irked me after just managing to get the fishing and prepping in before the guy left.

[Halcyon Eve]

I think the naming for some of the fillets are incorrect. The bronze fish that you can catch from the river above the waterfall (east side of the river) are the right fish to get the fillets you need. Sorry, I can't remember what fish, but they're super easy to catch, no bait needed.

[Ivaer]

Yup, that's where I went after seeing that Bream (the fish caught there) didn't require bait. I caught four Bream, one of which was silver, which- of course- meant the fillet was silver, which did NOT count for the quest. When I talked to the Bishop regarding the quest with all 4 fillets in my inventory it showed a 3/4 result in his dialogue, because it wouldn't accept the silver fillet.

[Halcyon Eve]

Oh, I see. How weird, you'd think he'd be fine with better quality.

[Ivaer]

Yeah, I would have thought so, too, which is why I didn't think to try and catch one more- much to my annoyance later on! xD

[Nneu]

I forget which vendor, but one of them you can buy the bronze fish for like 70 copper each. It might be the fisherman.

[Tehrock]

Fyi there's lots of other things like that as well, so make sure you get the right quality. The marble statues for the bishop come to mind. No way to guarantee silver quality so I had to reload until I got the right ones.

[wallyk426]

I bought 4 fish fillets from the lighthouse keeper gave them to him worked just fine

[Ivaer]

Thanks for the tips! I appreciate it! I wish the developer would be a little less specific in these quests- it doesn't really make any sense, mechanically. My biggest problem currently is money, so I didn't really want to go and buy the fish from the Fisherman- just barely managed to scrape past for the rightful citizen and building permit.

[DeNarr]

Originally posted by Burd Turglar:

Fyi there's lots of other things like that as well, so make sure you get the right quality. The marble statues for the bishop come to mind. No way to guarantee silver quality so I had to reload until I got the right ones.

He wants Gold though. The Silver is used for marble graveyard stuff

[Tehrock]

Originally posted by DeNarr:

Originally posted by Burd Turglar:

Fyi there's lots of other things like that as well, so make sure you get the right quality. The marble statues for the bishop come to mind. No way to guarantee silver quality so I had to reload until I got the right ones.

He wants Gold though. The Silver is used for marble graveyard stuff

Oh yeah, I got the two confused. It'd be better the other way around honestly, since you'll be making a ton of the graveyard statues and just have to save frequently or sell the gold ones and waste marble.