earth shaker busted NEEDS NERF/REBALANCE

[Amalekites Uprising]

on top of a billion stuns now he has aoe attacks that reach out a billion meters away AND his W damage but buffed a while ago, no doubt the most broken hero in the game and can play any role insanely good.

[Deepbluediver]

I dunnoh OP, his winrate is only barely above 50%: https://www.dotabuff.com/heroes/earthshaker/trends

He seems pretty decent but far from "broken".

[ナルゴ]

You went midas & mask of madness on void rather than getting bkb against a team that had Earthshaker, Skywrath Mage. Asking to be permanently locked down.

[Amalekites Uprising]

faceless void on the otherhand feels like absolute dogsh1t this patch... needs a better option than choosing his old ult as his "buff" no tools to farm damage wise and gets demolished in lane by 95% of the hero draft.

[Amalekites Uprising]

Originally posted by ナルゴ:

You went midas & mask of madness on void rather than getting bkb against a team that had Earthshaker, Skywrath Mage. Asking to be permanently locked down.

meaningless statement if u dont watch the game you are clueless our wd was afk, it was a free to leave game, that is still not argument to not nerf earth shaker

[Danaie]

jesus, Ive been seeing post from heralds crying about anything

[Amalekites Uprising]

Originally posted by Deepbluediver:

I dunnoh OP, his winrate is only barely above 50%: https://www.dotabuff.com/heroes/earthshaker/trends

He seems pretty decent but far from "broken".

nope ES is the only hero that is beyond broken right now, you still havent discussed anything about earth shaker other than peoples winrates. appeal to authority is not an argument, earth shaker has too many stuns too much damage and way too much aoe.

[ナルゴ]

Originally posted by Zog Slayer:

faceless void on the otherhand feels like absolute dogsh1t this patch... needs a better option than choosing his old ult as his "buff" no tools to farm damage wise and gets demolished in lane by 95% of the hero draft.

Honestly if I saw that enemy line-up, would immediately go bkb after treads. Wouldn't have room to farm with midas because they have such a strong early-mid game.

[Amalekites Uprising]

Originally posted by Danaie:

jesus, Ive been seeing post from heralds crying about anything

earth shaker is beyond S tier, appeal to authority is not an argument, too much damage stun and aoe and takes no skill to play. you are crying about people trying to balance the game weebo.

[ナルゴ]

Originally posted by Deepbluediver:

I dunnoh OP, his winrate is only barely above 50%: https://www.dotabuff.com/heroes/earthshaker/trends

He seems pretty decent but far from "broken".

It's worse because Earthshaker is sub-50% winrate in higher brackets lol

[Amalekites Uprising]

Originally posted by ナルゴ:

Originally posted by Zog Slayer:

faceless void on the otherhand feels like absolute dogsh1t this patch... needs a better option than choosing his old ult as his "buff" no tools to farm damage wise and gets demolished in lane by 95% of the hero draft.

Honestly if I saw that enemy line-up, would immediately go bkb after treads. Wouldn't have room to farm with midas because they have such a strong early-mid game.

with pudge on team? and u didnt watch the full game i already told u WD was level 6 afk since minute 8 u still havent made any points about earth shaker, needs a nerf bad.

[Amalekites Uprising]

Originally posted by ナルゴ:

Originally posted by Deepbluediver:

I dunnoh OP, his winrate is only barely above 50%: https://www.dotabuff.com/heroes/earthshaker/trends

He seems pretty decent but far from "broken".

It's worse because Earthshaker is sub-50% winrate in higher brackets lol

again appeal to authority is not argument can you use brain to discuss earth shaker or you are a hive mind zombie weeb like ur post mates?

[ナルゴ]

Winrate is brought up because it directly refutes the claim that he's OP. Because he is in fact not OP, backed up by hard numbers. It's not appeal to authority too. Which authority are you talking about? Basic math? lol
Also your teammate's performance does not diminish the fact that you built the wrong items.
When you're against magical burst damage, you get bkb, glimmer cape, or aeon disk. Even on core/carry heroes. You instead went for Midas, a farming item that does not help with your chances of survival in fights at all.

[Amalekites Uprising]

Originally posted by ナルゴ:

Winrate is brought up because it directly refutes the claim that he's OP. Because he is in fact not OP, backed up by hard numbers.
Also your teammate's performance does not diminish the fact that you built the wrong items.
When you're against magical burst damage, you get bkb or glimmer cape, or aeon disk. Even on cores. You instead went for Midas, a farming item that does not help with your chances of survival in fights at all.

again you havent said a single meaningful word about earth shaker, just another npc hive mind weeb, earth shaker is busted as i already mentioned he has way too many tools damage and aoe.

[Amalekites Uprising]

earth shaker is busted as i already mentioned he has way too many tools damage and aoe, anyone with 2 functioning braincells can see it, unless you abuse 1 hero yourself then you will end up bringing up flying elephants instead of talking about why or why not earth shaker is broken.

[ナルゴ]

I did though. I said he's not OP. As already proven by deepbluediver's post.
And if you don't want to die from Earthshaker's magical damage, you buy the items I mentioned.
Just because you claim what I said isn't meaningful, doesn't mean it isn't.