Biggest and Smallest Heroes

[Charles Nelson Riley]

I have a discussion question that I find very interesting if somewhat trivial.
What are the five most and least massive dota heroes, and pitted against each other (big team vs. little team) which side would win? I think this is very interesting to think about and I'd love to hear anyone's opinion on it.
P.S.
I don't count tiny or any mounted heroes

[Walf]

Well, I would think atleast Io and Zues would be on the smallest, and centuar and elder titan would be on the most massive. The smaller heros seem to be more spammable heros while the larger ones have tons of health and resistance to things.
(This is now a reason to make a dota hero pokedex ;.;)

[JVteam]

Originally posted by Charles Nelson Riley:

I don't count tiny or any mounted heroes

5 biggest:
Tiny
Axe
Elder Titan
Ogre Magi
Alchemist is a mount, so Treant protector, Pudge
Centaur Warrunner- wait does he count as a mount?

5 Smallest:
Puck
Sniper
Io
Dark Seer
Clinkz

I'm pretty sure the little guys would win. The big team has nothing but tanks.

[achus93]

biggest:
Tiny
Elder Titan
Doom
Centaur Warrunner
dunno who else

Smallest:
Riki
Clinkz
Pugna
Dark Seer
Io

[JVteam]

Originally posted by achus93:

biggest:
Tiny
Elder Titan
Doom
Centaur Warrunner
dunno who else

Smallest:
Riki
Clinkz
Pugna
Dark Seer
Io

Tiny doesn't count sorry achus

[Charles Nelson Riley]

I had considered that the big team would be all tanks, but I don't see anyone suggesting tidehunter who I saw as one of big teams biggest assets

[Charles Nelson Riley]

I asked myself whether I counted him as a mount, but since he's one being I don't. does pudge enter the big guy line-up?

Originally posted by jrocker314:

Originally posted by Charles Nelson Riley:

I don't count tiny or any mounted heroes

5 biggest:
Tiny
Axe
Elder Titan
Ogre Magi
Alchemist is a mount, so Treant protector
Centaur Warrunner- wait does he count as a mount?

5 Smallest:
Puck
Sniper
Io
Dark Seer
Clinkz

I'm pretty sure the little guys would win. The big team has nothing but tanks.

[JVteam]

Okay I guess Pudge is wider than treant( although treant's taller) so ok I'll change it, the prompt said "massive"

[Charles Nelson Riley]

right, I just wonder whether pudge is bigger than axe

[JVteam]

Originally posted by Charles Nelson Riley:

right, I just wonder whether pudge is bigger than axe

Axe is definitely taller, idk about width though...

[Charles Nelson Riley]

yeah it's hard to say. either way the big team probably loses due to theirlack of stealth.
I think they would get ganked to death

[Zapallo]

Tidehunter is really big as well, and for what small heros goes, I'd say those would be Dark Seer, Meepo, Puck, Clockwerk, Riki, Sniper and maybe even Timbersaw, if we ignore the suit of course.

[Charles Nelson Riley]

...yeah I wouldn't count timbersaw, and I think clinks is way smaller than clockwork. otherwise yeah, I hadn't thought of meepo

Originally posted by Nova:

Tidehunter is really big as well, and for what small heros goes, I'd say those would be Dark Seer, Meepo, Puck, Clockwerk, Riki, Sniper and maybe even Timbersaw, if we ignore the suit of course.

[achus93]

Originally posted by jrocker314:

Originally posted by achus93:

biggest:
Tiny
Elder Titan
Doom
Centaur Warrunner
dunno who else

Smallest:
Riki
Clinkz
Pugna
Dark Seer
Io

Tiny doesn't count sorry achus

he's an effing mountain dude, of course he counts,
his whole thing is about mountains getting bigger....

edit: ah, it's from the OP,
should've read it carefully...

[Charles Nelson Riley]

so far it seems like the line-up is:
Centaur warrunner
Ogre Magi
Treant protector
Tidehunter
Elder Titan

vs

Clinks
Sniper
Puck
Pugna
Dark Seer

(I don't feel like including Io because A: he's a strength character and B: he sort of just a light source so he plays by defferent rules.)

P.S. would bounty hunter have any part?

[achus93]

Originally posted by Charles Nelson Riley:

P.S. would bounty hunter have any part?

no, he's taller than Riki...