OutDrive
HAKIMODO May 28, 2020 @ 2:24pm
My key was revoked (by developer)
Today I've revealed my key from Fanatical "Born 2 Race 3 Bundle" and when I tried to activate it on other account - I've got info about duplicated code.
I've written to the seller (Fanatical) and I've got a working replacement.

I wanted to check this key. So I created a ticket to the Steam Support.

"Twój klucz został unieważniony na prośbę wydawcy. Taka sytuacja może mieć miejsce, gdy dojdzie do kradzieży partii kluczy lub gdy dany klucz był przeznaczony do wersji beta gry, która została wydana, i wymagana jest płatna wersja gry.
Skontaktuj się ze sprzedawcą, aby uzyskać więcej informacji."

= They told me, that my key was revoked directly by the dev.

I have this game also on another bundle bought (unrevealed yet) on this site. Are they are revoked too? Why my key "Q9EV5-H7K..-...FM" was revoked?
Last edited by HAKIMODO; May 28, 2020 @ 2:25pm
< >
Showing 1-15 of 18 comments
FuriousDevi Jun 8, 2020 @ 10:17am 
That sounds rly wierd. I never had any issue with any key from fanatical...those keys are known to be from a legit source - im pretty sure in all cases directly from the devs/publishers.
So either fanatical fked something up and the dev saw himself forced to revoke the keys OR the dev changed his mind and didnt want to give then away for too cheap and trying to get out of the deal with fanatical by them canceling the contract after this comes out - BUT that could ruin a small dev so why would he do it? .... I personaly see fanatical more and more critical lately (new premium bundle is a flatout scam) so i think maybe fanatical didnt keep their part of the contract with this dev? ...Just some thoughts about that^^
DNVR prod  [developer] Sep 2, 2020 @ 3:30pm 
Hi, sorry for this.
But the keys were banned, because stolen on the "black market". They were purchased using stolen credit cards to sell at third-party stores.
HAKIMODO Sep 2, 2020 @ 5:33pm 
Do you want to tell me that Fanatical are selling stolen keys?
It's not a legit shop? You're not sold your game keys here?
https://www.fanatical.com/
Last edited by HAKIMODO; Sep 2, 2020 @ 5:34pm
dragonfly59 Jan 31, 2022 @ 7:53am 
Same Problem.... with 2 bundles .....

Do you replace the key YOU revoked ???
Thanks
amfest Jun 8, 2022 @ 3:01am 
I've just experinced this with that same bundle bought in 2016. I've been trying to redeem old keys that I already own on my main account when I got this bundle to another account but just ran into this issue so emailed the fanatical team receiving this email response:
(Fanatical Customer Service Area)

Jun 8, 2022, 09:57 GMT+1

Hello,

Thank you for getting in contact with us.

I am sorry you have duplicate keys.

I can see the order in question is very old and as such it appears the keys have been removed from Steam by the developers of the game. Because of this the game is no longer redeemable.

We provide a warranty on our keys of 30 days. A key is valid unless somebody else redeems it, or the developers of the game remove the key from Steam, both will result in a 'duplicate key' message from Steam.

If we had replacement keys available then even after this period of time we would have swapped then for you, but our spare keys have also been removed from Steam.

I am sorry but we are not able to help with getting with this problem. Please ensure you redeem any other older keys you may have. You might find that different developers haven't removed the keys from Steam and the games will still activate.

Fanatical.com

After that I see this developer response and am scratching my head on this . .so someone somehow got these unclaimed keys numbers and sold them on another 3rd party site or something. I'm not certain how this works with these sites but fanatical was formally known as BundleStars and still going strong as Fanatical .. not sure how developers work with these storefronts and bundles but are they purchasing these outright to give away on their sites somehow? I'm sorta scratching my head on this one being called a blackmarket but mkay.
HAKIMODO Jun 8, 2022 @ 5:05am 
This is not a problem of Fanatical.

The reason is simple: the dev sold you a key and after some time he invalidated all sold keys.
So this is close to a scam. You're paid for this and you've been cheated.

This can be a mistake and I had similar problems with other games. But their authors always gave me a replacement key. And I hear a "sorry".
Last edited by HAKIMODO; Jun 8, 2022 @ 5:06am
Tiberia Mar 21, 2023 @ 9:07am 
Originally posted by HAKIMODO:
This is not a problem of Fanatical.

The reason is simple: the dev sold you a key and after some time he invalidated all sold keys.
So this is close to a scam. You're paid for this and you've been cheated.

This can be a mistake and I had similar problems with other games. But their authors always gave me a replacement key. And I hear a "sorry".


Just so this does not stand in the room

THE DEV itself was scammed by the previous publisher and the previous publisher stole a lot of keys before THIS dev the ORIGINAl dev of the game got the game back to himself.

He then revoked all keys the old publisher stole because the original dev never got money from it.

SO YES Fanatical had stolen keys since the dev is russian and can`t speak english well he explained it in the simplest term understandable. which is a shame since it created confusion.
HAKIMODO Mar 21, 2023 @ 10:01am 
@Tiberia.
The developer still has not answered the question of whether the keys sold by Fanatical were stolen (purchase through a stolen credit card).
Tiberia Mar 21, 2023 @ 10:51am 
Originally posted by HAKIMODO:
@Tiberia.
The developer still has not answered the question of whether the keys sold by Fanatical were stolen (purchase through a stolen credit card).

The Developer will probabaly not answer ever again. I would assume.

But my answer answer this the keys from fanatical where stolen by the old publsiher (The original owner never sold keys to key selling websites) so every single key that you did not get from steam is a stolen key, he said stoen / credit card because he is lacking the better word to describe it because of his bad english.
HAKIMODO Mar 22, 2023 @ 3:23am 
It's not a stolen key. DEV was granted access to create a keys or gived them keys directly. This is an agreement between the two of them and not between the developer and me.

The keys were legally transferred and legally sold. That something didn't work out between the two is their internal matter. We still don't know WHO he transferred those keys to and WHY he received any payment. Maybe for the keys from Fanatical he received and from the sales on other sites he didn't get any more?

I gave my key and the developer did not respond in any way.

So this is a scam. Sold a keys and revoke them later.
Last edited by HAKIMODO; Mar 22, 2023 @ 3:25am
Tiberia Mar 22, 2023 @ 5:09am 
Originally posted by HAKIMODO:
It's not a stolen key. DEV was granted access to create a keys or gived them keys directly. This is an agreement between the two of them and not between the developer and me.

The keys were legally transferred and legally sold. That something didn't work out between the two is their internal matter. We still don't know WHO he transferred those keys to and WHY he received any payment. Maybe for the keys from Fanatical he received and from the sales on other sites he didn't get any more?

I gave my key and the developer did not respond in any way.

So this is a scam. Sold a keys and revoke them later.



YOU did not understand.

THE original owner of this game, did not SELL ANYKEYS whatsoever to outside of steam every single key that was outside of steam was illegal.

The previous publisher has just generated dozen and dozen of keys saved them and never gave them back even after they finally lost the right to the game.

After they lost the right to the game they keep selling steam keys to key reseller even though thoes keys where illegal the owner of the game has never gotten the money for it.


SO IF YOU have problems with the key contact fanatical because they got the keys from a scammer and not the other way arround.
HAKIMODO Mar 22, 2023 @ 9:41am 
You clearly don't understand.

The developer provided someone (a distributor?) with an account of his game and allowed the generation and sale of keys. The fact that he did not see to the business is only his fault.

Blaming the problems on buyers of legitimate keys is unethical. The only person at fault here is the developer. He is the one who provided access to the account and ensured that the distributor could sell the keys. Their mutual animosities should not interest anyone. That's what the courts are for, and that's where he should assert his rights.

The cancellation of legally purchased keys is a scam and it is cheating buyers by the developer.
Last edited by HAKIMODO; Mar 22, 2023 @ 9:41am
Tiberia Mar 22, 2023 @ 12:32pm 
Originally posted by HAKIMODO:
You clearly don't understand.

The developer provided someone (a distributor?) with an account of his game and allowed the generation and sale of keys. The fact that he did not see to the business is only his fault.

Blaming the problems on buyers of legitimate keys is unethical. The only person at fault here is the developer. He is the one who provided access to the account and ensured that the distributor could sell the keys. Their mutual animosities should not interest anyone. That's what the courts are for, and that's where he should assert his rights.

The cancellation of legally purchased keys is a scam and it is cheating buyers by the developer.


Ahh I see the problem. Nono the distributor was not ALLOWED to create new keys. He did it without legal rights. And that is where this is coming from.
HAKIMODO Mar 22, 2023 @ 4:05pm 
If he is not allowed - so why he created them?
Tiberia Mar 22, 2023 @ 4:17pm 
Originally posted by HAKIMODO:
If he is not allowed - so why he created them?


Hm ok last time I am trying to explain in simple terms.

The one how created the game got screwd over by a company

The creator never allowed to sell steam keys outside of steam

he sued and won

the moment he won and the game was supposed to be handed over the old publisher created a ton of keys and keept them without saying the have them.

the creator gets back the game and can finally earn money with his own game.

The old publisher sells of the keys they illegaly created to key reseller such as fanatic or gamesplanet.com etc etc

the creator having found out blocks the keys so the websites need to stop selling.


if you got a key from that website fanatic or whever write a support tell them what happend and get your money back !
< >
Showing 1-15 of 18 comments
Per page: 1530 50