Is it possible to beat Nightmare?

[redeyerain]

Earlier me and my friend with vwry good randoms tried it. The medic was a god, the engi was wrecking everyone, the heavy and soldier were amazing. I was using loose cannon and using the knockback and double donks to stop giants. we went halfway before getting overwhelmed by tanks and spies. is it possible?

[Deathrowboat]

Yes.

[SP458]

Nightmare is actually used due to the Halloween theme of the mission. In practice it's closer to advanced.

The Tanks + Spies subwave is quite hard if the roles aren't correctly distributed. The first Tank is alone. Damage it as much as you can before the Spies appear; they start spawning with the second Tank.
Soldiers, Sticky Demos and Pyros should stay on the ground and attack the Spies (they come in large mobs, so you can kill most of them in one hit) while they're attacking the Tank. Bop all the Spies you currently see, then come back to the Tank and listen to their loud decloaking noise before turning your back (or wait 5 s). Medics should use their shield to help killing the Spies and damaging the Tanks; if they don't have the Kritz, they must buy crit canteens + canteen specialist (and they should even with the Kritz for extra crits). All other classes should climb the Tanks (buy mov. speed + jump height, and jump from the central building) and keep some crit canteens in case the Tank is about to drop the bomb. Beggar's Bazooka + Buff Banner, Bushwacka + Cleaner's Carbine and Phlog are great options to destroy the Tanks quickly, as well as fully upgraded Scatterguns.

[MannsOverMeta]

You guys sucked.
All you need is enough tank DPS and crowd killing capabilities to win. You could take care of tanks with 2 dedicated tank killers (maybe even one if everything goes perfectly). Sniper can solo all the Giants (other classes can also do it, I’ve done it as Beggar’s Soldier and Phlog Pyro, but not as fast or as easily) as well as many of the trash bots.
Tank + Spy wave is difficult because it features 4 high health tanks and lots of Spies, which can intimidate a lot of players. Really, it’s just a test of tank DPS and the ability not to die to Spies. Again, at least 2 dedicated tank killers can take it down, and the spies can be countered by standing on top of the tank or having one/two guys focused on killing them.
If you’re prepared, the wave is very easy. Only thing that could give you trouble are the crit swarms at the third half because of all the knockback and damage they do, even with max resists. Even then, it’s still not too difficult if you actually know what you’re doing.

[Hell-met]

legends say no one has done it yet

[fingers]

I disagree with you saying you were with very good randoms.

[Dark Frank]

Legend checking in. It's true. I've tried many times and couldn't do it. Been masturbating ever since.

[Rumpus]

Almost did it with a team of four and my best friend. The bar was a few centimetres away but we got overwhelmed by tanks. I swear it's possible.

[Rylanor the Unyielding]

Oh yes it's possible, I've won it before, you do need a good coordinated team though and it is rare to win with randos unless the randos are excellent in their roles and know what to do.
With the tanks you really want a phlog pyro and a krits medic to deal with the tanks, and a soldier to deal with the crowd control. The other members should focus on stopping the bomb and taking out those pesky spies.

[Vlad the Impala]

Originally posted by Call Me Mercenary:

Oh yes it's possible, I've won it before, you do need a good coordinated team though and it is rare to win with randos unless the randos are excellent in their roles and know what to do.
With the tanks you really want a phlog pyro and a krits medic to deal with the tanks, and a soldier to deal with the crowd control. The other members should focus on stopping the bomb and taking out those pesky spies.

Lies.

[Rylanor the Unyielding]

Originally posted by Staplerfahrer Klaus:

Originally posted by Call Me Mercenary:

Oh yes it's possible, I've won it before, you do need a good coordinated team though and it is rare to win with randos unless the randos are excellent in their roles and know what to do.
With the tanks you really want a phlog pyro and a krits medic to deal with the tanks, and a soldier to deal with the crowd control. The other members should focus on stopping the bomb and taking out those pesky spies.

Lies.

What about beating it? Well, it's no joke. I really have won it. You need a good team though, and you need a strategy, you can't just go in guns blazing or you'll lose. Also, it's important to cry DEUS VULT after every kill for it's a holy war.

[Vlad the Impala]

Originally posted by Call Me Mercenary:

Originally posted by Staplerfahrer Klaus:

Lies.

What about beating it? Well, it's no joke. I really have won it. You need a good team though, and you need a strategy, you can't just go in guns blazing or you'll lose. Also, it's important to cry DEUS VULT after every kill for it's a holy war.

How can 6 men beat 911 robots?

[Rylanor the Unyielding]

Originally posted by Staplerfahrer Klaus:

Originally posted by Call Me Mercenary:

What about beating it? Well, it's no joke. I really have won it. You need a good team though, and you need a strategy, you can't just go in guns blazing or you'll lose. Also, it's important to cry DEUS VULT after every kill for it's a holy war.

How can 6 men beat 911 robots?

It really is possible, you're just lacking in imagination lol.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yx6JbI0PB1Y

[Vlad the Impala]

Originally posted by Call Me Mercenary:

Originally posted by Staplerfahrer Klaus:

How can 6 men beat 911 robots?

It really is possible, you're just lacking in imagination lol.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yx6JbI0PB1Y

It's clearly fake, see:

Originally posted by Hell-met:

legends say no one has done it yet

[Rylanor the Unyielding]

Originally posted by Staplerfahrer Klaus:

Originally posted by Call Me Mercenary:

It really is possible, you're just lacking in imagination lol.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Yx6JbI0PB1Y

It's clearly fake, see:

Originally posted by Hell-met:

legends say no one has done it yet

Haven't you heard? Disney made Legends non-canon sorry.
But believe it or not the proof is out there it's been beaten and it's actually pretty easy to beat too.

[Vlad the Impala]

Originally posted by Call Me Mercenary:

Originally posted by Staplerfahrer Klaus:

It's clearly fake, see:

Haven't you heard? Disney made Legends non-canon sorry.
But believe it or not the proof is out there it's been beaten and it's actually pretty easy to beat too.

You cannot beat 900 dudes on your own, how can you beat 900 dudes made of steel?