Game Gets 10/10 From Gamespot

[1337Dude]

Here[www.gamespot.com]

Do you guys think it deserves a 10/10? Not often games get 10/10 from there

[Thorba]

引用自 TripSin：

引用自 -SG1-Shadowscall：

That is fine that no game gets 10/10 though. There is absolutely nothing wrong with that, no human ever reaches perfection in anything, but they still strive for it.

Nah, games like The Witcher 3 deserve 10/10's.

This game, however, does not at all.

Witcher 3 has a very nice presentation but the core game mechanics are very simple. I was beaten every enemy with exactly the same tactic on hardest difficult, just cast this shield make a few hits and then cast again....
Game wasnt bad but for my taste way to overhyped.

[KorgonZola]

引用自 -SG1-Shadowscall：

I wish game sites would stop misusing the rating scale. Pretty much every game review place does it, a 10/10 is a PERFECT game with no flaws whatsoever, no game has achieved that, it should be the holy grail of gaming. A 5/10 should be an average game that is just ok. But no, game sites act like anything that gets less than 8/10 is worthless. When they give so many games a 9/10, it cheapens what a 9/10 should actually mean.

You'll get an A in school for doing a very good job, not for doing a perfect job. Same with game rating scores. To me, DOS2 is one of the very few games in the past few years that defenitely deserves a 10/10.

[Iry]

Also the problem that many people think a 7-8 is bad. The review scene is extremely biased towards giving high scores. Even really bad games still get 5-6 out of 10 instead of 1-4s.

Heck, when I worked in a call center nothing less than a 9 was even acceptable. Anything below a 9 got people in trouble.

[Neiker]

If skyrim deserves a 95/100 this game deserves a 100/100 easy. Yeah, it has bugs, but its issues are nowhere near skyrim's specialy at launch. Hell, skyrim is still more broken than this to this day.

And lets not even talk about how the combat int his game is superior, the narative is much better, characters are better, you have much more fredom in how the story plays out, etc...

[iemander]

Gamespot scoring this game 10/10 made this game sell another 100k copies. Any whiner in this thread that has a problem with that?

[Multihog]

引用自 Neiker：

If skyrim deserves a 95/100 this game deserves a 100/100 easy. Yeah, it has bugs, but its issues are nowhere near skyrim's specialy at launch. Hell, skyrim is still more broken than this to this day.

Yeah, Skyrim is hilariously broken. NPCs glitching out every 5 seconds, literally. The pathfinding is also a joke, with NPCs running in circles and pacing back and forth, desperately trying to find a path yet failing if the player is standing on uneven ground. Combat is still a disaster, etc.

On the topic: as some people have already mentioned, what's the point of having a 10/10 rating if it's unattainable? It shouldn't mean perfect, because perfection is impossible to achieve.

[iemander]

No, all games currently out need to be scored less than 3 automatically. Because the perfect game is billion of years away right now and all games right now are at most a 3 compared to it.

[Multihog]

引用自 Shirayuki474：

引用自 Neiker：

If skyrim deserves a 95/100 this game deserves a 100/100 easy. Yeah, it has bugs, but its issues are nowhere near skyrim's specialy at launch. Hell, skyrim is still more broken than this to this day.

And lets not even talk about how the combat int his game is superior, the narative is much better, characters are better, you have much more fredom in how the story plays out, etc...

Skyrim is far more bigger game than Divinity so it is only natural to have more bugs.

It's not simply a matter of having bugs with Skyrim, though. A lot of the systems are fundamentally broken and just poorly designed.

[iemander]

Can the Skyrim whining please stop, pretty please?

The more succesfull a game is, the more whiner it gets that nag.

[THE AVERAGE]

This isn't a 10/10 game, but it's really high up there in terms of best RPGs ever. It has too many things preventing it from being 10/10, namely the uselessness of most of the combat skills in the game for anything other than straight up damage thanks to the horrible armor system. The UI, but especially the inventory is a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ mess and the log book is one of the worst I've seen in ages. Despite that, it's still a phenomenal game.

[Neiker]

引用自 THE AVERAGE DD Pawn：

This isn't a 10/10 game, but it's really high up there in terms of best RPGs ever. It has too many things preventing it from being 10/10, namely the uselessness of most of the combat skills in the game for anything other than straight up damage thanks to the horrible armor system. The UI, but especially the inventory is a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ mess and the log book is one of the worst I've seen in ages. Despite that, it's still a phenomenal game.

Armour sistem is good '-'.

[iemander]

I also don't really get the problem with the armour system. It just adds a level of strategy. You just need to match your own magic/physical skills to the enemies on the screen,

[Multihog]

引用自 iemander：

I also don't really get the problem with the armour system. It just adds a level of strategy. You just need to match your own magic/physical skills to the enemies on the screen,

It's horrible because it promotes going either full physical or full magic. Preferably full physical.

[Neiker]

引用自 Multihog：

引用自 iemander：

I also don't really get the problem with the armour system. It just adds a level of strategy. You just need to match your own magic/physical skills to the enemies on the screen,

It's horrible because it promotes going either full physical or full magic. Preferably full physical.

Just because straight swords are op on darksouls 3, dosent mean the game is utterly broken and impossible to complete while using any other weapon. Just because going as a mag ein darksouls 2 made the game easier, dosent mean the game was broken either. '-'

Its literaly the same here.

[iemander]

引用自 Multihog：

引用自 iemander：

I also don't really get the problem with the armour system. It just adds a level of strategy. You just need to match your own magic/physical skills to the enemies on the screen,

It's horrible because it promotes going either full physical or full magic. Preferably full physical.

How does that help exactly, as you'll also fight enemies with high physical resistance. You'd plow through one type of enemy and get obliterated by the other. You need to have a combination to fight again high physical and magic resistances.