Broken Kaiser Path Germany

[epichoffman]

So the focus that allows you to protect poland in return for former German territories does not work properly. It does not give cores on Gydinia or however you spell it. You end up being weaker then the pre update and it makes no sense. It obviously meant for you to have that province cored and should be fixed. Also any suggestions on how to go the Holy Roman Empire Path? Each time I have tried to find a way to get her hindenburg keeps being destroyed.

[lakupupu]

yes, use a mod to fix it however its such a small province that not having it cored as germany is an unimaginably small loss

[Immortalis]

The focus works as intended and as it has always worked.

The issue being that back when Poland received its own focus tree the state was split and Gdynia was separated from Danzig. You get cores on Danzig because that's the state that existed when the German focus tree was made.

It has already been reported time and time again but the devs have not patched it out yet. Either it is so inconsequential that is at the bottom of the fix list or there is some unknown justification for it.

Still, I'd hardly consider a missing core on Gydinia as a "broken path"

[Plain, Simple, Garak]

Originally posted by epichoffman:

So the focus that allows you to protect poland in return for former German territories does not work properly. It does not give cores on Gydinia or however you spell it. You end up being weaker then the pre update and it makes no sense. It obviously meant for you to have that province cored and should be fixed. Also any suggestions on how to go the Holy Roman Empire Path? Each time I have tried to find a way to get her hindenburg keeps being destroyed.

Paradox didn't update the state IDs for the event when they reworked Poland
As a result its only partially working
Don't expect a fix either, unlike Stellaris, the HoI team doesn't try to keep older content up to date

[epichoffman]

Well the definition of broken , means that something needs to be fixed. So the path is indeed broken, at the very least the content should be fixed.

[Immortalis]

Originally posted by epichoffman:

Well the definition of broken , means that something needs to be fixed. So the path is indeed broken, at the very least the content should be fixed.

The definition of a broken path is you being unable to continue along that path.

What you have is a minor oversight at best which has absolutely no impact on the game given how irrelevant Gdynia is as a state (neither tons of manpower nor a crucial industrial center). And the fact that you do not gain core on that state could just as well be justified with the idea that a lot of Poles immigrated there, so much so that the state has no resemblance whatsoever to the "old german empire territory".

[epichoffman]

Originally posted by Immortalis:

Originally posted by epichoffman:

Well the definition of broken , means that something needs to be fixed. So the path is indeed broken, at the very least the content should be fixed.

The definition of a broken path is you being unable to continue along that path.

What you have is a minor oversight at best which has absolutely no impact on the game given how irrelevant Gdynia is as a state (neither tons of manpower nor a crucial industrial center). And the fact that you do not gain core on that state could just as well be justified with the idea that a lot of Poles immigrated there, so much so that the state has no resemblance whatsoever to the "old german empire territory".

Is it working as intended ? Yes or no. If it's not then it is indeed broken. Anyway gdyinia was old ww1 border territory, so it was "Old German Territory" . When the poles got danzig and Gdyina it was one of the most unpopular border changes post world war one and arguably a factor in starting world war two, because the land for koinsberg was seperated.

[Immortalis]

Originally posted by epichoffman:

Is it working as intended ? Yes or no. If it's not then it is indeed broken. Anyway gdyinia was old ww1 border territory, so it was "Old German Territory" . When the poles got danzig and Gdyina it was one of the most unpopular border changes post world war one and arguably a factor in starting world war two, because the land for koinsberg was seperated.

And should the answer be yes and Gdynia not being cored answer to a choice made by the devs then it would indeed be not broken. I don't know the answer, as you don't know the answer. What we do know is that this "issue" has been present from day 1 of NSB, the devs are aware of it and as of yet it has received no "fix" whatsoever. To each to decide why it is so.

That being said, I very well know the conmsequences of WW1 but what I said is that my reasoning for what's happening is that after the land was transferred to Poland, Danzig remained an eminently German city whereas Gdynia was subjected to massive immigration of Poles. Something that is reasonable when you consider that as Poland you can basically cut off Danzig by creating a better and fully polish port town right in Gdynia. Now, is that historical? I honestly don't care because it gives me a valid reason as to why I'm not coring Gdynia.

[epichoffman]

Originally posted by Immortalis:

Originally posted by epichoffman:

Is it working as intended ? Yes or no. If it's not then it is indeed broken. Anyway gdyinia was old ww1 border territory, so it was "Old German Territory" . When the poles got danzig and Gdyina it was one of the most unpopular border changes post world war one and arguably a factor in starting world war two, because the land for koinsberg was seperated.

And should the answer be yes and Gdynia not being cored answer to a choice made by the devs then it would indeed be not broken. I don't know the answer, as you don't know the answer. What we do know is that this "issue" has been present from day 1 of NSB, the devs are aware of it and as of yet it has received no "fix" whatsoever. To each to decide why it is so.

That being said, I very well know the conmsequences of WW1 but what I said is that my reasoning for what's happening is that after the land was transferred to Poland, Danzig remained an eminently German city whereas Gdynia was subjected to massive immigration of Poles. Something that is reasonable when you consider that as Poland you can basically cut off Danzig by creating a better and fully polish port town right in Gdynia. Now, is that historical? I honestly don't care because it gives me a valid reason as to why I'm not coring Gdynia.

I dont care if you dont care, it was a bad issue. Ethier way the point is moot now and it works again. Good day.