Is there any point to the "max planning" bonuses in land doctrine if I don't use frontline/offensive line tools?

[Josh]

As the question says, I micro manage every battle and never use battle plans.

Does that make the max planning or planning speed bonuses in land doctrines (like grand battleplan) effectively useless?

[runifoc]

The planning bonus gives the assigned units a % increase to attack and defense even when the battleplan is never activated.

[Josh]

Ok, sweet

[Ваня]

Planning bonus will only tick up from 0% to max when units are at the starting point for a battle plan. If there's no front line and accompanying advance line, then the planning bonus won't tick up.

As runifoc says, it doesn't need to be activated, but it does need to exist.

[Josh]

İlk olarak Ваня tarafından gönderildi:

Planning bonus will only tick up from 0% to max when units are at the starting point for a battle plan. If there's no front line and accompanying advance line, then the planning bonus won't tick up.

As runifoc says, it doesn't need to be activated, but it does need to exist.

So, what if I make a frontline and assign my troops to it.

Then I delete the frontline and micro manage..

What happens?

[Ваня]

The planning bonus will slowly tick down to 0%.

It ticks up and stays up when they're at the start point.

It ticks down when they move, fight, or in this case if the plan is deleted. But you still can make use of it for some time.

[Josh]

Ok cool, thanks

[Ваня]

Always happy to help

[Tama]

In your case, maybe other trees would suit you better.
For example, superior firepower. It mainly has passive bonuses, that will be useful for your playstyle.