Best and worst Alternate Universe/Alternate timelines mega thread.

[Nekogaming1500]

So basically you are supposed to list what you feel is the best and worst alternate universes for undertale.

Rules:
#1: No arguing. You can disagree and have a civil debate on why you think one way, but you shouldn't start a flame war. I don't want a thread to prematurely die.
#2: You can only list 2 au's.
#3: You have to list why you think this way.
#4: Read rules 1-3 again until you understand what to do.

I'll start. (You can copy what I say and just change it up to your opinion.)

Best AU/AT (In my opinion) is: Horrortale!
It's a really interesting AT, not AU, that takes place after a canon ending in undertale, and expanded more. It feels like undertale, but a more broken version. Despite it's name, it isn't overly edgy and doesn't feel like an old 2014 creepypasta with bad writing.

Worst AU/AT (In my opinion.) is: Dusttale. No offense to the oc of the AT.
Pain. This au is so poor. The whole au is built on the false misconception that sans remembers resets. It's also so edgy. Like, uneedingly edgy. It doesn't feel like undertale. Genocide Undertale wasn't even close to this edge. Not to mention, sans is very out of character in this au. We know so much about sans, and we know he would never kill everyone just to revenge a human. We know from the fight that he knows he is gonna lose. He doesn't even know why he's fighting you. He knows you're so determined to win, that he will eventually die. Sans never even shows a semblence of guilt. He is more or less just Chara 2 but funny skeleton.

I look forward to everyone elses opinions!

[BIKING VIKING]

I like dustale a lot.

[Nekogaming1500]

Originally posted by littlefrillymonster:

I like dustale a lot.

And thats fine. It is only my opinion.

[★ Spaceflash ★]

My favorite AU? Storyshift, just love the idea behind these particular roleswaps while the characters keep their personality for the most part - also Azzy is alive :)
Hope this AU will have its write-up/comic along with its OST finished in the future, maybe even have it get the Inverted Fate treatment, speaking off...

Inverted Fate is my second most favorite AU. REALLY fleshed out story with a well made comic and even videos. The characters are all loveable in their own right and the story is told from an interesting perspective (that being that a monster, this case Papyrus, follows and helps Frisk throughout most of the journey). You really see and feel how much work and love is poured into the AU by its creator.

Dont know any AU I particulary dislike

[Kingangus]

My own oc where Frisk is replaced with a 3'1 clone of hitler who doesn't speak English. The whole game is just him yelling at everyone in his funny little german language. And nobody takes him seriously because of this. He can either turn a new leaf and realize "diversity is our strength". Or he can overdose on redpills and raise another army consisting completely of clones of himself.

[Grim Will-Power]

my favorite is probably inktale (i know it isnt an AU, but i love the idea of ink sans.) my least favorite... is none, i love them all

[Nekogaming1500]

Originally posted by Kingangus:

My own oc where Frisk is replaced with a 3'1 clone of hitler who doesn't speak English. The whole game is just him yelling at everyone in his funny little german language. And nobody takes him seriously because of this. He can either turn a new leaf and realize "diversity is our strength". Or he can overdose on redpills and raise another army consisting completely of clones of himself.

Wholesome 100

[𝕊𝕠𝕡𝕙𝕚𝕒]

everyone know underlust is the worst undertale au EVER

[a grilled cheese sandwich]

Originally posted by Sunstar:

everyone know underlust is the worst undertale au EVER

agreed