anyone else think Magnolia's songs hide more then just her origin? (spoilers)

[S0ul]

She says when you ask her where she is really from that its all in her songs. Not only do her songs sing about going "under ground" and "help her save her from falling apart." that all points to synth and institute.

But to an extent it also feels like her songs tell us what bethesda has planned for the future.

"can't go forward can't go back."
So...by that, can't go forward (with the institute ending) can't go back, not to far back like minutemen or perhaps like the pre-war this is the new civilization after all. But what i also tells me with "not being able to move forward." is that the brotherhood will be the continuing chapter? the canon ending?

That's just my two cents worth based on some in depth look at her and her songs that I wanted to share. I feel she is a singing easter egg.

[Shahadem]

She could have been a vault dweller. Or the wording could be symbolic. Where she is "from" are the experiences she's endured over the years that made her the person she is.

[S0ul]

Originally posted by Shahadem:

She could have been a vault dweller. Or the wording could be symbolic. Where she is "from" are the experiences she's endured over the years that made her the person she is.

Yeah but when you specifically ask where she is from, she is evasive and says to pay close attention to the songs. Later (and this was months ago) I found out on the wiki that she is a synth, suddenly the underground thing makes sense, and falling apart, she's practically singing about being a synth in secret.

Then I wondered if the rest of her songs had meaning to the player or the canon ending. notice that she seems to mention pretty much every faction in the song train train.

Train train > Railroad
Can't go forward > Brotherhood destroying institute prevents this
Can't go back > The minute men fell apart with their effort and they are trying again but depending history will likely repeat itself.

Unless they establish a real order (which may require help from like the brotherhood) She also mentions in her song about "training to be a person at war." The protagonist as a male, is a soldier at war returning while the wife is a lawyer, and all the scenes bethesda uses including the New DLC features the male so I think its safe to say he is for sure the one who is intended to survive. No offense or pokes to those who enjoy playing women I'm just pointing out things I found.

[SaveTheZombies]

Yea, I got the feeling that there's more to Magnolia's story. I hope she and her band are in a DLC...maybe we can get the band back together...maybe a mission from Gad; would be fitting since 'Blue' (maybe he's from a vault) Lou Marini is the horn player.

[troy_cummings]

Originally posted by Admiral Durgon:

Originally posted by Shahadem:

She could have been a vault dweller. Or the wording could be symbolic. Where she is "from" are the experiences she's endured over the years that made her the person she is.

Yeah but when you specifically ask where she is from, she is evasive and says to pay close attention to the songs. Later (and this was months ago) I found out on the wiki that she is a synth, suddenly the underground thing makes sense, and falling apart, she's practically singing about being a synth in secret.

Then I wondered if the rest of her songs had meaning to the player or the canon ending. notice that she seems to mention pretty much every faction in the song train train.

Train train > Railroad
Can't go forward > Brotherhood destroying institute prevents this
Can't go back > The minute men fell apart with their effort and they are trying again but depending history will likely repeat itself.

Unless they establish a real order (which may require help from like the brotherhood) She also mentions in her song about "training to be a person at war." The protagonist as a male, is a soldier at war returning while the wife is a lawyer, and all the scenes bethesda uses including the New DLC features the male so I think its safe to say he is for sure the one who is intended to survive. No offense or pokes to those who enjoy playing women I'm just pointing out things I found.

I've never thought about that, but it makes a lot of sense.

[S0ul]

^ thanks for agreeing with my thought. I was hoping I wasn't the only one lol.