Non-lethal solution to Covenant quest?

[Migel]

I've gotten as far as the conversation with the doctor Chambers without killing anyone in this quest. Seeing as I don't want to kill everyone or have Amelia killed, is there an alternate, pacifist solution?

[AC Denton]

www.google.com

[Migel]

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S0K63RYrlXc

[Hedning]

The moral option is to rescue her and then kill the torturers in self defence. There is no way of rescuing her without making everyone hostile.

Edit: Although I guess if you don't have a companion you can just try to get out without shooting. Won't really end it though...

[Migel]

Imo this quest has no good ending. A: allow a synth, which has feelings and fear but is still a spy (even though with good intentions behind them - on the other hand they mustve killed stocktons real daughter to "bodysnatch" her) to be executed by a very unlikable character,

or B: Kill an entire settlement in order to free this spy.

I consider Synths to be human, just working for the wrong employer. Later story questgivers, as well as the character of nick valentaine display human behaviour and display emotions as well as free will. This would make the option to have them executed immoral.

[✠Deser✞🅵☣⚔⚔♏✠]

I just did this quest an hour ago, i killed everyone but the synth. I captured and reprogrammed her to serve me.

It was almost as fun as killing the gunners for the other synth.

[Sander]

Originally posted by VSF Migel the Sloth:

Imo this quest has no good ending. A: allow a synth, which has feelings and fear but is still a spy (even though with good intentions behind them - on the other hand they mustve killed stocktons real daughter to "bodysnatch" her) to be executed by a very unlikable character,

or B: Kill an entire settlement in order to free this spy.

I consider Synths to be human, just working for the wrong employer. Later story questgivers, as well as the character of nick valentaine display human behaviour and display emotions as well as free will. This would make the option to have them executed immoral.

Stockton knows his 'daughter' is a synth, as she is one of the rescued synths send to bunker hill by patriot. you can learn this by not taking Dan with you to the compount and then go to stockton and talk to him, where he gives you your reward. He also tells you the truth about her.

[Hedning]

She is freed by the railroad and is no longer a spy working for the railroad.

Those in the settlement know about and support the use of torture of both synth and human in order to acieve a test that can detect synths, however it is not clear if their goal is even achievable, so the likelyhood that all those humans and synths were tortured and killed in vain is pretty high.

If you had to escape from a nazi lab where they did similar things you'd have no trouble shooting yoru way out, even if their goal were to advance e.g. medical science.

[watchdog79]

@OP - Yes, there is a mod, works like a charm (read description carefuly to know what to do).

http://www.nexusmods.com/fallout4/mods/11051