is it better to kill the mechanist or not

[xDreadbloodx]

in the title which is better

[Yhwach]

Spare: booty call, more quests
Kill: armor,, weapons, no more quests

[xDreadbloodx]

actually thats the reason to kill her if u do ada will give u the quest instead meaning u dont have to go all the way there just to get the quest

[Xyzzy]

Cruz gives Radiant repeat Rogue Robot quests.

[Count Smashula]

Doesn't matter, only difference is that she remains in the lair and gives you quests. if you kill her, Ada gives you the quests. Ultimately, it's better to kill her since you can keep Ada with you and do things more quickly.

[DEVOLVE MINHA CACHAÇA!]

Publicado originalmente por Omni King Zen-Oh:

Spare: booty call, more quests
Kill: armor,, weapons, no more quests

Not entirely true.

If you manage to convince Isabel she's wrong on her deeds, she will give you the Mechanist outfit as well as the helmet, no need to kill here to obtain it.

[Sander]

Killing her only gives one extra reward, which is a unique lazer pistol called the protectrons gaze. Besides that all the rewards are the same.

Sparing her gives you the mechanist armour, cruz as a merchant and all the robot parts.

Killing gives you the machanist armour, the protectron gaze and all the robot parts.

The choice falls to you, will you allow a person who made a mistake that backfired to live with the guild, or will you play judge, jury and executioner.

[Park_Ranger]

I let her live, and just pop back now and again for a rogue robot quest.

[MageThis]

Send her to Sanctuary to bunk with Mama Murphy. They can share Mama's meds and forget together.

[JOW]

The mechanist's lair is the hub for my robotic settlement supply system. There is no need to kill everything, just conquer and rule.

[Let's Roleplay]

I'm intrigued by this: "Spare: booty call"
I don't think you can sleep with her.

[Anvos]

She's hardly the first person in Fallout to underestimate how robobrains turn into psychopaths and if you killed everybody in Fallout who was an idiot there would maybe less than a hundred people left in all of Fallout USA. Let alone she's a skilled individual so letting her live is something good for the future of the Commonwealth, now that she's learned not to take a robot's word on doing their mission correctly.

[Xenon The Noble]

Publicado originalmente por You Ha Bach:

Spare: booty call, more quests
Kill: armor,, weapons, no more quests

Kill the mechanist and you get the quests from Ada instead of the mechanist. You get her armor either way. So armor and quests don't change either way.
Booty call? Maybe with a mod.
So really, it's just personal preference. Personally I get pissed off that she won't listen to SS until SS has the gun to her head, then suddenly she wants to be reasonable and not murder you (and she doesn't want to because she can't!)
And what kind of engineer writes a program for devices that could be deadly and doesn't even bother to check it to see if it works?! As an engineer IRL, this offends me greatly. Stupid woman just throws it over the fence and assumes that she's so great it all works the way she wanted. It never works the way you want. Everything that can go wrong, is going to go wrong. That's manslaughter (killing commonwealth people out of gross neglegance) and attempted murder (for try very hard to kill SS right up until he wins the battle). So, blammo!

[Anvos]

Keep in mind there aren't that many public schools and colleges in the wasteland so many people are self taught in their field if they have an interest in science or engineering.

[Xenon The Noble]

Publicado originalmente por Pookie101:

Publicado originalmente por Anvos:

Keep in mind there aren't that many public schools and colleges in the wasteland so many people are self taught in their field if they have an interest in science or engineering.

I'm honestly surprised she wasn't asked to join the Institute

Do you think the Institute wants someone who intends to make help bots but makes kill bots instead, and then tried to murder you if you say there's a problem? They're smarter than that and synths are far better bots in the first place! And yet the Institute still arms synths with pop-guns!

[☠MarcoCuteFemboy☠]

no because she's hot