*SPOILER* Firekeeper eyes?

[ImaGuest]

I just gave the firekeeper firekeeper eyes. She gave me two options. Wish for a world without flame, or decline. Will this effect the ending in any way?

[Cthalpa]

World without flame is the betrayal ending, you basically end the cycle. If you decide you'd rather link the flame, then you can just kill her and get the eyes back, and she'll respawn when you sit at the bonfire. She's immortal, I think, at least when she has the eyes. If you kill her and decide, for some reason, that you DO want the betrayal ending, just give her the eyes again.

[V I R A L]

Yes, she gave you the choice to choose bad ending after the final boss. If you don't want the bad ending, just don't use the fire keeper summon sign after that.

[ImaGuest]

Originally posted by RB Cthalpa:

World without flame is the betrayal ending, you basically end the cycle. If you decide you'd rather link the flame, then you can just kill her and get the eyes back, and she'll respawn when you sit at the bonfire. She's immortal, I think, at least when she has the eyes. If you kill her and decide, for some reason, that you DO want the betrayal ending, just give her the eyes again. :D:

Okay, guess I'm going for the betrayal ending :D

[淵 Nayuta]

No, just use her sign beside the last bonfire for that ending, you dont need to kill her before hand to "Stop" the ending, its up to you wether or not to link the fire or summon her for it to get that ending, you can also just kill her during that ending to get the 4th ending.

[ImaGuest]

Originally posted by 鵺 Rias:

No, just use her sign beside the last bonfire for that ending, you dont need to kill her before hand to "Stop" the ending, its up to you wether or not to link the fire or summon her for it to get that ending, you can also just kill her during that ending to get the 4th ending.

Oh okay, thanks for the info.

[garjian]

I've just gotten them and done the ending they grant you.

I wonder though...
The Firelink Shrine we access from Lothric is dark, and everyone is dead.
The cave from which you enter Untended Graves exists in Cemetary of Ash.
So what is the Lothric beyond -that- cave like?
I'll bet it's a nice version, where sometimes, the Market Street bakery has 2 for 1 sales on sausage rolls.

[Terosinian]

Originally posted by Captain Daddy:

World without flame is the betrayal ending, you basically end the cycle. If you decide you'd rather link the flame, then you can just kill her and get the eyes back, and she'll respawn when you sit at the bonfire. She's immortal, I think, at least when she has the eyes. If you kill her and decide, for some reason, that you DO want the betrayal ending, just give her the eyes again. :D:

YOU LIED TO ME YOU SCUM, SHE DIDN'T RESPAWN
EDIT: She did respawn, but I had to leave the area and come back, not just sit at the bonfire.

[TheEvilNoob]

Originally posted by Terosinian:

Originally posted by Captain Daddy:

World without flame is the betrayal ending, you basically end the cycle. If you decide you'd rather link the flame, then you can just kill her and get the eyes back, and she'll respawn when you sit at the bonfire. She's immortal, I think, at least when she has the eyes. If you kill her and decide, for some reason, that you DO want the betrayal ending, just give her the eyes again. :D:

YOU LIED TO ME YOU SCUM, SHE DIDN'T RESPAWN

Reload the game then. She should respawn. She even instructs you to do it if you change your mind.

[V I R A L]

Originally posted by Terosinian:

YOU LIED TO ME YOU SCUM, SHE DIDN'T RESPAWN

Weird , go to another area then back to shrine , she'll respawn . I killed her 3 times at the firelink shrine after I gave her the eyes , she still respawn like nothing happen , still have the option to give her the eyes again lol

[Outsider_Hopper]

another question : for you all , what represent the untended grave ?

[Arjock]

you don't need to kill her, your decision while talking to her only affects her summoning sign to appear. even with that you can still just link the fire if you don't summon her.