Who else suspected that [Spoiler] was the killer?

[{TLM} DojoDog]

I suspected that Ichabod was the killer since episode one. His erractic behavior and unpredictable nature during conversations lead me to belive he was the killer early on. Did anyone else come to this conclusion before playing episode 2?

[kabutobond]

I didnt see it coming but in retrospect it explains a lot.

[Judge Arcadia]

I personally dont think he is the killer. To reveal him now is just too convient. Sure his behavior is creepy and erractic, but the way he talks about Snow makes him almost like he regrets what he role plays out.

[Veeh Youtube]

I too dont think he is the killer. He looked pretty messed up when he saw the snow white dopple ganger dead and he also rescued bigby from the mundy jail. I think if he was the killer he would of just put bigby off the case or tried to have covered his tracks in other ways.

He probably did have sex with fate tho and maybe did hurt her or posibly killed her but I dont think he killed the second girl, that troll woman. Not to mention that he doesnt have the power to harm a troll to begin with.

I think bigby is the killer tbh, by means of some mind control or something similar. If you notice you can find the same brand of cigs at the crime scene and at one point he doesnt remember what he did one night, i think thats in episode 1

[BeastBox]

Originally posted by Veeh:

I think bigby is the killer tbh, by means of some mind control or something similar. If you notice you can find the same brand of cigs at the crime scene and at one point he doesnt remember what he did one night, i think thats in episode 1

Bigby is asleep when Faith is killed, so that works. But we're with him the whole time when Lily is being killed, so that's out. And anything Bigby killed is likely to look like it was mauled by a wild animal, not a clean chop through the neck.

And again, no motive.

Also agreeing with everyone else here; Crane is not the murderer. The facts add up for him having a creepy fetish, and that's it.

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

As I said before, I doubt very much that the only killing and killer in the game will be the serial killer - I suspect tell tales might make it look like Crane was the killer (and maybe even killed Lily) then suddenly when he is dealt with, another murder shows up.

[Danbarrett92]

His whole fable includes the headless horseman, its obvious hes involved in some way but I dont think he is the main bad guy here. Remember there was someone saying "stop laughing at me!" on the bridge? I think he's got someone worse controlling him

[BeastBox]

Originally posted by Danbarrett92:

His whole fable includes the headless horseman

Firstly, the characters of the Fables universe seem to carry over the traits they had in their original stories, but not usually their "story" behavior (case in point: Bigby's not eating people anymore). If anyone would be going around killing women on account of his story, it would be Bluebeard, but that's likely not happening either.

Secondly, Crane's second entry in the Book of Fables heavily implies that in the Fables universe, the Headless Horseman doesn't actually exist ... it was just a prank. Actually kind of surprising how many people are trying to tie the Headless Horseman into the decapitations when a) he's not even in the game, and b) Woody's still running around with that magic axe of his ...

[Vonman]

the killer will most likely be a character not in the comic books, since this is a prequel and can't change much with the preestablished characters.

[HunterAvison]

im surprised none of you have mentioned glamour yet. who ever the killer is obviously has access to glamour that can change you into a specific person. it could be someone else who is making himself look like crane possibly.

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

Originally posted by infraredxscope:

im surprised none of you have mentioned glamour yet. who ever the killer is obviously has access to glamour that can change you into a specific person. it could be someone else who is making himself look like crane possibly.

I said it before, the killer might use glamour himself.
With that said, I suspect Crane is a creep/killer however, not the killer of Faith.

[POLISH SAUSAGE]

i think he did kill lilys sister and faith but i think theres something bigger going on here like maybe a cult or some sort of secret orginazation

[Phoenix-san]

i dont think he is the killer. Its probably fake villain. Because its too early to reveal true villain in ep 2.

[[NGNS-SWE] ⚡ Quezkatolen ⚡]

Originally posted by Phoenix-san:

i dont think he is the killer. Its probably fake villain. Because its too early to reveal true villain in ep 2.

yes and no.

I think chasing a killer in 5 episodes can also be slow.
There might be more than one killer.

[Kinuskipyyri]

I actually DON'T think Crane is the actual culprit. He's definitely a creepy dude, but not a killer. Someone clearly set him up. Crane is a bit of a jerk and a doofus, but he's not STUPID enough to leave such obvious evidence (and it doesn't seem like his... style to throw heads on the Woodlands' doorstep). So there's still twists to come. Someone's using glamour.
One thing I also wonder is... is Faith actually dead? Even post-mortem the Mirror gave the whole "these lips are sealed" stick. I mean, obviously this spell is set on all the prostitutes to say the least, but would it affect Faith even AFTER she's dead? I mean... I don't know, maybe I'm just hopeful after getting to like her. xD

[Unlucky_Cock]

In my bad theory Crane could have been blackmail and was using the serial killer idea to cover his own mess to get out of whatever problem he was in having an obession fantasy to do those things he done.