War Thunder

War Thunder

View Stats:
redned Oct 12, 2023 @ 5:35pm
BR changes for Dummies
everyone likes to complain that it is not BR decompression if you do not increase the BR's.
if you were paying attention to how gaijin likes to operate then you would know that is what they plan to do.

their process works like this.
> increase the BR of high tier vehicles that perform very well.
> allow meta to shift around and adjust.
> increase BR of high performing low tier vehicles.
> allow meta to adjust.
> increase BR ceiling fill in the gaps.
> watch as the meta changes.
> repeat.

top BR used to be 10.0 just a few years ago and they have been doing this for a few years now. with every BR increase they add new top tier premiums.
what do you think they are preparing for at the end of this year?
that's right new top tier premiums, they will again increase the BR ceiling and sell everyone a new premium while they praise gaijin for finally raising the BR.

they just do it all in long drawn out process to make sure they do not ruin the meta in ways that hurt the game. if they were to increase the BR at the start of this year instead of moving all the cold war vehicles first then these WW2 heavies this update then we would have had some messed up meta's while they fix everything due to one massive shift in one go.

those BR changes shifting all the cold war vehicles were good and as predicted I knew the heavies would be effected next so it was no shock to me, I also know it won't last long for them.

the tiger I will not face IS-3's for very long. the IS-3 and many vehicles that you want moved up will be the next targets at the end of year BR increase.

just my theory as to how they do things take with grain of salt. though from my observations, this seems to be the case.
Last edited by redned; Oct 12, 2023 @ 5:39pm
< >
Showing 1-15 of 26 comments
TheAceOfSpodes Oct 12, 2023 @ 7:04pm 
Or they could just quit jerking themselves off and actually fix the BR system.
a55mu11e7 Oct 12, 2023 @ 9:25pm 
They rely too much on statistics...

Those numbers are fudged by the shifting skill level of the players. The cracked outliers are going to overshadow everything else.

I'm a Deuternope...my stats effect your gameplay.
redned Oct 12, 2023 @ 9:27pm 
Originally posted by TheAceOfSpodes:
Or they could just quit jerking themselves off and actually fix the BR system.
guess I didn't dumb it down enough. they are fixing it. it is not an over night thing.

increasing the BR even after they do this process leaves behind a messy meta for a while.
every time there has been some busted vehicle that is left in this void of no competition.
where due to all the gaps left in the BR's it can dominate in it's BR bracket until gaijin starts adding more vehicles to fill in the spaces.
redned Oct 12, 2023 @ 9:32pm 
Originally posted by a55mu11e7:
They rely too much on statistics...

Those numbers are fudged by the shifting skill level of the players. The cracked outliers are going to overshadow everything else.

I'm a Deuternope...my stats effect your gameplay.
what would you rather they use other than stats. just make ♥♥♥♥ up?

also even after they use the stats to create the initial list of BR changes they read through the forums posts to make more.
some times they remove vehicles from the list of changes other times they add vehicles.
there has been plenty of times where they take the middle ground. by increasing the BR and giving a slight buff, they may give something a buff/nerf instead and leave it instead of increasing/decreasing the BR.

these changes they make most of the time based on player feed back, it's just a lie to tell yourself they rely on stats.
Akagi Oct 12, 2023 @ 11:08pm 
I don't know, I haven't noticed any decompression in top tier jets. I only see a Mig-21 with R60s soon facing Mig-15s and Sabres
redned Oct 12, 2023 @ 11:38pm 
Originally posted by Akagi:
I don't know, I haven't noticed any decompression in top tier jets. I only see a Mig-21 with R60s soon facing Mig-15s and Sabres
because there hasn't been any yet. just set up for it later down the line.
they are moving stuff ahead of the BR increase which will create the decompression.

I thought I did a good job at spelling it out for people but I guess not.
seriously this is how they have always done it. it is what they done before increasing from 11.0-11.3 then to 11.7 for ground there is always a bunch of big changes in the BR before an increase to the limit.

you can tell the difference between BR changes adjusting due to performance and BR changes ahead of BR limit increase i.e from 11.7-12.0.
regular BR changes for balance will see more vehicles moving both up and down.
BR changes like what we are seeing now and the previous BR change are mostly in the upwards direction.

there has been no decompression yet but gaijin is setting up for it.

I feel like I have repeated myself but clearly I have to.
Last edited by redned; Oct 12, 2023 @ 11:39pm
a55mu11e7 Oct 12, 2023 @ 11:41pm 
Originally posted by redned:
what would you rather they use other than stats. just make ♥♥♥♥ up?

Obviously not...But they're kinda already doing that. i.e. the "Chinese" F16 gets AIM-7M right off the bat but USA has to work through a whole jet for it. They're both 12.0

They need proper in house play testing to measure each vehicle accurately instead of cheaping out on their biggest money maker and using statistics which are inherently wrong unless you're a "meta" normie.

Originally posted by Akagi:
I don't know, I haven't noticed any decompression in top tier jets. I only see a Mig-21 with R60s soon facing Mig-15s and Sabres

I'm struggling with this too atm... CL13 Mk6 is 9.3 in Germany.

I'm always in a match with fighters that out perform me in every way. I can't even hope to out turn missiles let alone the planes themselves.

I get almost no down tiers and even if I did, I still around half the burst mass of any other plane because i have 50's instead of cannons.

Last edited by a55mu11e7; Oct 12, 2023 @ 11:48pm
redned Oct 12, 2023 @ 11:53pm 
Originally posted by a55mu11e7:
Originally posted by redned:
what would you rather they use other than stats. just make ♥♥♥♥ up?

Obviously not...But they're kinda already doing that. i.e. the "Chinese" F16 gets AIM-7M right off the bat but USA has to work through a whole jet for it. They're both 12.0

They need proper in house play testing to measure each vehicle accurately instead of cheaping out on their biggest money maker and using statistics which are inherently wrong unless you're a "meta" normie.
wtf does order of f16 modifications have to do with the BR changes.
how they order ♥♥♥♥ in modifications has always been made up. because vehicles unlocking ♥♥♥♥ irl is not a thing.


there is over 2000 vehicles on game, there is not a team big enough to test everything every time they want to make some changes. guess what they need to test everything because otherwise they'd just be testing meta vehicles for what you like to call meta normies whatever the ♥♥♥♥ that is.

they need to test as many combinations of lineups, match ups between nations and maps how the ♥♥♥♥ do you think any team is going to figure that ♥♥♥♥ out for balance. they won't that is how.

there is only leaving it up to the players of the game to create everyone of those scenarios, taking the data then adjusting BR's.

also it is not just pure stats they take, they are still taking players input on the forums right now, I imagine we will see an updated BR list monday once they finish reading all the feedback.

the best and only way to balance is how they do it. which is: take stats, create list, gather feedback, update list, gather more feedback before making final adjustment and implementation.
it's how they always do it and how they should always do it.
Last edited by redned; Oct 12, 2023 @ 11:58pm
Black_Fox Oct 13, 2023 @ 12:23am 
Originally posted by a55mu11e7:
Originally posted by redned:
what would you rather they use other than stats. just make ♥♥♥♥ up?

Obviously not...But they're kinda already doing that. i.e. the "Chinese" F16 gets AIM-7M right off the bat but USA has to work through a whole jet for it. They're both 12.0

They need proper in house play testing to measure each vehicle accurately instead of cheaping out on their biggest money maker and using statistics which are inherently wrong unless you're a "meta" normie.

Originally posted by Akagi:
I don't know, I haven't noticed any decompression in top tier jets. I only see a Mig-21 with R60s soon facing Mig-15s and Sabres

I'm struggling with this too atm... CL13 Mk6 is 9.3 in Germany.

I'm always in a match with fighters that out perform me in every way. I can't even hope to out turn missiles let alone the planes themselves.

I get almost no down tiers and even if I did, I still around half the burst mass of any other plane because i have 50's instead of cannons.

Try the german F-84F, being a practice target for all kinds of missiles is fun according to Gaijin....
Last edited by Black_Fox; Oct 13, 2023 @ 12:24am
TheAceOfSpodes Oct 13, 2023 @ 1:13am 
At least the F-84F is consistent in BR with the US version. The CL13 is just an absolute joke at 9.3 and I'm not even a german main.

9.3 with no countermeasures and a 700mph top speed, 2 missiles, and .50 cals. Or you could do a F-104 which has double the top speed, and 20mm cannon. Or an F-100D which has 200 mph greater top speed, and 4 AIM-9Es or twice the bomb load.

Or jump to the USSR tree and find the Yak-38M packing 4 R-60s at 9.3.

8.0 -> 9.0 jets is an absolute ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ currently. In 8.0 you're facing the 9.0 jets which generally have superior speed and missiles, so you're just a sitting duck whose only hope of a kill is honing in on someone distracted by your allies.

At 9.0 you don't even have that option because you're facing off against R-60s and you have (generally speaking) no CMs or RWR. So you just die to missiles long before you even get a shot off. And on the off chance you DO get a missile off, its only a 10g so the slightest turn by the enemy and its a miss.
a55mu11e7 Oct 13, 2023 @ 1:25am 
wtf does order of f16 modifications have to do with the BR changes.
how they order ♥♥♥♥ in modifications has always been made up. because vehicles unlocking ♥♥♥♥ irl is not a thing.


It's all intrinsic to the BR...This is simply just one example. China has a superior missile earlier at a BR where the same jets SHOULD have the same equipment but they do not.


there is over 2000 vehicles on game, there is not a team big enough to test everything every time they want to make some changes. guess what they need to test everything because otherwise they'd just be testing meta vehicles for what you like to call meta normies whatever the ♥♥♥♥ that is.

Their willy nilly additions to the vehicle tree are the problem because it's like they're not planning anything out. It's bad management or it's just predatory practices of seeing what they can get away with instead of actually trying to make the game enjoyable.

Meta normies only play the "good" vehicles and it skews the statistics. For example, the PZ.IIF and T28 are both 1.7, but the T28 has had over 1500 battles in the last month while the PZ.II has only 16. In arcade, T28 has 85% win rate while PZII has 13%

Now they're not removing the shrapnel round from the 1.7 T28, but they're removing it from the LOWER tier vehicles that came out long after everybody and their dog knew about the Sh-354 round being OP in it's bracket. Big surprise the T-35 premium is keeping it's shrapnel round

Meanwhile you have 2.0 Sweden out here with APDS penetrating over 100mm of armor which allows it to punch way above it's BR. Hence "Most Effective Tactic Available normie."

They need to test as many combinations of lineups, match ups between nations and maps how the ♥♥♥♥ do you think any team is going to figure that ♥♥♥♥ out for balance. they won't that is how.

there is only leaving it up to the players of the game to create everyone of those scenarios, taking the data then adjusting BR's.


This is again, the main issue. Players don't know exactly how the game works and you'll get whiners complaining about hackers when they're just not into this game like that...they wanna get on and have fun with the vehicle they like.

These guys will be farmed by more veteran players with game knowledge who can't bridge the gap to be an excellent player.

also it is not just pure stats they take, they are still taking players input on the forums right now, I imagine we will see an updated BR list monday once they finish reading all the feedback.

the best and only way to balance is how they do it. which is: take stats, create list, gather feedback, update list, gather more feedback before making final adjustment and implementation.
it's how they always do it and how they should always do it.


The game is on Steam...The fact that they won't bring their official discussion here is a big problem and has been a huge tell for other games where they want to control the conversation.

A lot of folks aren't going to go through the trouble of taking up a second job as a forum rat to fully understand things because the game already takes up so much of their time.

It's a F2P game...they'll just move on because they feel no need to get their moneys worth.
Last edited by a55mu11e7; Oct 13, 2023 @ 1:25am
JuX Oct 13, 2023 @ 1:25am 
Only problem with this assumption, is that lesser vehicles getting moved up before the actual meta.


Gaijin seems to have it's own delusion on what is deemed to be meta. Cause it definitely isn't related to actual vehicle performance.

Helicopter change is good example of this. The changes themselves seem reasonable, but why is it only affecting the US? When russian helicopters are the meta. So it would have been logical choice to either move them up side-by-side or have russian helicopters be moved up first.
a55mu11e7 Oct 13, 2023 @ 1:34am 
Originally posted by Black_Fox:
Try the german F-84F, being a practice target for all kinds of missiles is fun according to Gaijin....

This thing really is atrocious...that plane makes me want to pop.

Originally posted by TheAceOfSpodes:
At least the F-84F is consistent in BR with the US version. The CL13 is just an absolute joke at 9.3 and I'm not even a german main.

9.3 with no countermeasures and a 700mph top speed, 2 missiles, and .50 cals. Or you could do a F-104 which has double the top speed, and 20mm cannon. Or an F-100D which has 200 mph greater top speed, and 4 AIM-9Es or twice the bomb load.

Or jump to the USSR tree and find the Yak-38M packing 4 R-60s at 9.3.

8.0 -> 9.0 jets is an absolute ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ currently. In 8.0 you're facing the 9.0 jets which generally have superior speed and missiles, so you're just a sitting duck whose only hope of a kill is honing in on someone distracted by your allies.

At 9.0 you don't even have that option because you're facing off against R-60s and you have (generally speaking) no CMs or RWR. So you just die to missiles long before you even get a shot off. And on the off chance you DO get a missile off, its only a 10g so the slightest turn by the enemy and its a miss.

Agreed, My main issue with switching now is that my german crews are already max...that crew grind kills me and makes a huge difference. If it weren't for the F5C, i wouldn't even be working on USA.

I'm stuck at the CL13 as well on Germany. Only way i make research is i put a talisman on the F84F and BLUs...pray to RNGesus that I can kill a base and ground pound a bit before anybody notices me.
redned Oct 13, 2023 @ 1:45am 
Originally posted by a55mu11e7:
you responded to my point countering you talking specifically about gaijin using stats only.
then you come at me with something that is based around grind.

how can they get the same when the US does not get 9P's at all.
redned Oct 13, 2023 @ 1:52am 
also shrapnel is just trash it's a worse HE and worse APHE. the fact you think people call that shell OP tells me you have no clue. also thunders kills stats, may as well make numbers up.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 26 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Oct 12, 2023 @ 5:35pm
Posts: 26