War Thunder

War Thunder

View Stats:
This topic has been locked
bunny Oct 30, 2024 @ 8:28am
you add israel and not Ukraine
explain the logic without removing the thread, Ukraine has more interesting and unique tanks than Israel. It makes no sense.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 68 comments
Enkeli Oct 30, 2024 @ 8:36am 
They allready have soviet? THats ukraine bud
Canadian Guitar Oct 30, 2024 @ 8:37am 
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:
explain the logic without removing the thread, Ukraine has more interesting and unique tanks than Israel. It makes no sense.
Which unique tanks do they have versus Israel?
Israel had enough vehicles to have five ranks, from 4 to 8 (although I think they could start from rank III for both air and ground, as they even had Cromwells in possession, which are okay for rank III, just like the Sakeen which is rank IV currently, and missing Beaufighters, Mosquitos and other airplanes).
Remind me please when Ukraine was formed as an independent state? Can it start from rank IV at least without copying everything USSR/Russia TT has? If it starts from rank VI or rather VII (thus having just 2 rank, 7 and 8), it just isn't worth it. See, no politics, just in-game logic.
bunny Oct 30, 2024 @ 8:54am 
Originally posted by Canadian Guitar:
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:
explain the logic without removing the thread, Ukraine has more interesting and unique tanks than Israel. It makes no sense.
Which unique tanks do they have versus Israel?
BTR-3E-90, 2P148-BRDM-2, BMD-2, BMP-1TS, T-72B1, T-72M1, T-64BVK, T-80BV, T-64BM2 Bulat, T-84U Oplot, BTR-94, BRDM-2 Amulet, 9P148 Konkurs, T-64BV(Zaslin APS), 269 Nona-S, MT-LB-AT, BTR-RD, BMPT-62, BTR-4, BTR-3E1, 2K33M3 Osa-AKM, T-64B1M, Strazh BMPT, T-72AMT, T-64BV Mod. 17

I haven't included all the NATO and other eastern European tanks they have acquired and modified.
Last edited by bunny; Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:00am
Dadadudu Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:06am 
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:
Originally posted by Canadian Guitar:
Which unique tanks do they have versus Israel?
BTR-3E-90, 2P148-BRDM-2, BMD-2, BMP-1TS, T-72B1, T-72M1, T-64BVK, T-80BV, T-64BM2 Bulat, T-84U Oplot, BTR-94, BRDM-2 Amulet, 9P148 Konkurs, T-64BV(Zaslin APS), 269 Nona-S, MT-LB-AT, BTR-RD, BMPT-62, BTR-4, BTR-3E1, 2K33M3 Osa-AKM, T-64B1M, Strazh BMPT, T-72AMT, T-64BV Mod. 17

I haven't included all the NATO and other eastern European tanks they have acquired and modified.
Can be put as a Subtree into USSR or have the more unique variations of those USSR Vehicles as a Premium for it
Russian game.
Enkeli Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:07am 
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:
Originally posted by Canadian Guitar:
Which unique tanks do they have versus Israel?
BTR-3E-90, 2P148-BRDM-2, BMD-2, BMP-1TS, T-72B1, T-72M1, T-64BVK, T-80BV, T-64BM2 Bulat, T-84U Oplot, BTR-94, BRDM-2 Amulet, 9P148 Konkurs, T-64BV(Zaslin APS), 269 Nona-S, MT-LB-AT, BTR-RD, BMPT-62, BTR-4, BTR-3E1, 2K33M3 Osa-AKM, T-64B1M, Strazh BMPT, T-72AMT, T-64BV Mod. 17

I haven't included all the NATO and other eastern European tanks they have acquired and modified.
So it would just be soviet tanks?
bunny Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:09am 
Originally posted by Dadadudu:
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:
BTR-3E-90, 2P148-BRDM-2, BMD-2, BMP-1TS, T-72B1, T-72M1, T-64BVK, T-80BV, T-64BM2 Bulat, T-84U Oplot, BTR-94, BRDM-2 Amulet, 9P148 Konkurs, T-64BV(Zaslin APS), 269 Nona-S, MT-LB-AT, BTR-RD, BMPT-62, BTR-4, BTR-3E1, 2K33M3 Osa-AKM, T-64B1M, Strazh BMPT, T-72AMT, T-64BV Mod. 17

I haven't included all the NATO and other eastern European tanks they have acquired and modified.
Can be put as a Subtree into USSR or have the more unique variations of those USSR Vehicles as a Premium for it


Majority of those tanks where built/modified after they gained independence USSR. If anything you create a Central and Eastern European tech tree that combines all independent smaller countries to avoid conflict of the player-base.
Last edited by bunny; Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:14am
bunny Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:11am 
Originally posted by Enkeli:
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:
BTR-3E-90, 2P148-BRDM-2, BMD-2, BMP-1TS, T-72B1, T-72M1, T-64BVK, T-80BV, T-64BM2 Bulat, T-84U Oplot, BTR-94, BRDM-2 Amulet, 9P148 Konkurs, T-64BV(Zaslin APS), 269 Nona-S, MT-LB-AT, BTR-RD, BMPT-62, BTR-4, BTR-3E1, 2K33M3 Osa-AKM, T-64B1M, Strazh BMPT, T-72AMT, T-64BV Mod. 17

I haven't included all the NATO and other eastern European tanks they have acquired and modified.
So it would just be soviet tanks?
How are they soviet if most got built/modified by Ukraine after Independence
Last edited by bunny; Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:12am
Dadadudu Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:14am 
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:
Originally posted by Dadadudu:
Can be put as a Subtree into USSR or have the more unique variations of those USSR Vehicles as a Premium for it


Majority of those tanks where built after they gained independence USSR. If anything you create a Central and Eastern European tech tree that combines all independent smaller countries.
Central Europe would include Germany. Eastern Europe is just Russia, Belarus and Ukraine...which we already have as the USSR Tree.

And at that Point if they make a Central European, Eastern European etc. Tree they might as well create an East Asian Tree, Western European Tree, Five Eyes Tree and so on and just smash Nations together based on their Geography (aside from Five Eyes)
Last edited by Dadadudu; Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:17am
bunny Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:17am 
Originally posted by Dadadudu:
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:


Majority of those tanks where built after they gained independence USSR. If anything you create a Central and Eastern European tech tree that combines all independent smaller countries.
Central Europe would include Germany. Eastern Europe is just Russia, Belarus and Ukraine...which we already have as the USSR Tree.
Central Europe: Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Slovenia obviously you wouldn't include Germany because it already has a tree.. "east asian tree" doesn't even make sense lmao.
Last edited by bunny; Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:18am
arni.gamexeon Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:17am 
Originally posted by Enkeli:
They allready have soviet? THats ukraine bud

2 country its different, dude....

ukraine its should be the leader of european eastern with all new tech tree in this game.....
Dadadudu Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:20am 
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:
Originally posted by Dadadudu:
Central Europe would include Germany. Eastern Europe is just Russia, Belarus and Ukraine...which we already have as the USSR Tree.
Central Europe: Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Slovenia obviously you wouldn't include Germany because it already has a tree..
All just Copy+Paste Tree.

In case of China they at least get their own unique Vehicles at the Top with tons of more domestic Stuff open to be added, Ukraine or an Central EU Tree would just be entirely Copy+Paste, those Countries make much more sense as a Subtree or have their more unique Vehicles as Premiums for greater Nations.
bunny Oct 30, 2024 @ 9:21am 
Originally posted by Dadadudu:
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:
Central Europe: Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Slovenia obviously you wouldn't include Germany because it already has a tree..
All just Copy+Paste Tree.

You didn't even take the time to individually look into Ukrainian produced tanks. These are unique if not better.
Originally posted by bunny bunny bunny:
Originally posted by Enkeli:
So it would just be soviet tanks?
How are they soviet if most got built/modified by Ukraine after Independence

By that logic, there's no place for Su-25BM (Belarusian modification, but belongs to Kazakhstan Air Force), M53/59 or T-72M2 Moderna in the Soviet TT, but here they are. As well as the Finnish subtree in Sweden (and a couple of Norwegian ones), the Hungarian subtree in Italy, the Benelux in France...which is already better than if they were added as standalone micro-nations with just a bit of unique vics and tons of clones and semi-clones. Ukrainian vehicles you listed are all semi-clones...
< >
Showing 1-15 of 68 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Oct 30, 2024 @ 8:28am
Posts: 68