War Thunder

War Thunder

查看统计:
Nikola 5 2016 年 8 月 17 日 上午 10:03
British patrol boat has depth charges, submaries confirmed
title says every thing
< >
正在显示第 1 - 15 条,共 41 条留言
Bogey 2016 年 8 月 17 日 上午 10:19 
On the WarThunder page it doesn't say anything about the Fairmile D having depth charges. It had depth charges in real life, but apparently not in WarThunder. Maybe you have some additional sources?
Datname 2016 年 8 月 17 日 上午 10:21 
引用自 Bogey
On the WarThunder page it doesn't say anything about the Fairmile D having depth charges. It had depth charges in real life, but apparently not in WarThunder. Maybe you have some additional sources?
well on stream i think they showed and even talked about them
Bogey 2016 年 8 月 17 日 上午 10:25 
Yes, it will have depth charges. I missed that part, my bad. There will not be any submarines though, apparently the depth charges are meant to be used against pursuing boats ...
The One True Git 2016 年 8 月 17 日 上午 10:28 
引用自 Bogey
Yes, it will have depth charges. I missed that part, my bad. There will not be any submarines though, apparently the depth charges are meant to be used against pursuing boats ...
Sucks about subs, but the use of depth charges in that manner is interesting.
Datname 2016 年 8 月 17 日 上午 10:35 
引用自 Bogey
Yes, it will have depth charges. I missed that part, my bad. There will not be any submarines though, apparently the depth charges are meant to be used against pursuing boats ...
Sucks about subs, but the use of depth charges in that manner is interesting.
defently will bring some spice in chases at 70kmh
Coolmint 2016 年 8 月 17 日 下午 2:17 
引用自 your lord and savior 2.0
title says every thing
Gaijin have said they don't want slow battles. Subs were slow underwater,(U-Boat especially) the U-boat could only go about 18kph under it was about 7kph at max I believe, much slower then what they want.
最后由 Coolmint 编辑于; 2016 年 8 月 17 日 下午 2:17
kiro the avenger! 2016 年 8 月 17 日 下午 2:31 
subs wont happen
theyre completely unsuited to ship-ship warefare, let alone boat-boat warefare
and even less the break-neck speed of gameplay gajin thinks we all require
then theres how much more theyd have to model in maps to accomodate them

cool that you get depth charges though, i guess. just dont be dumb enough to ram them up the arse and youre good
Katokevin 2016 年 8 月 17 日 下午 3:02 
引用自 kiro the avenger!
subs wont happen
theyre completely unsuited to ship-ship warefare, let alone boat-boat warefare
and even less the break-neck speed of gameplay gajin thinks we all require
then theres how much more theyd have to model in maps to accomodate them

cool that you get depth charges though, i guess. just dont be dumb enough to ram them up the arse and youre good
I can see AI subs though. If they ever do a co-op mode, maybe you may have to have somebody with depth charges and find and kill an enemy sub or force it to surface. Just tossing ideas out there. I would at least find that fun (along with defending a convoy).
TypicalBipedalMammal 2016 年 8 月 17 日 下午 3:43 
引用自 kiro the avenger!
subs wont happen
theyre completely unsuited to ship-ship warefare, let alone boat-boat warefare
and even less the break-neck speed of gameplay gajin thinks we all require
then theres how much more theyd have to model in maps to accomodate them

cool that you get depth charges though, i guess. just dont be dumb enough to ram them up the arse and youre good
I can see AI subs though. If they ever do a co-op mode, maybe you may have to have somebody with depth charges and find and kill an enemy sub or force it to surface. Just tossing ideas out there. I would at least find that fun (along with defending a convoy).

That is my theory on why there are depth charges in War Thunder. Judging by how long it took for the presenter to give a "explanation" for their use I am certain that Subs will likely be AI objectives.
Foxtrot39 2016 年 8 月 17 日 下午 6:18 
引用自 Bogey
On the WarThunder page it doesn't say anything about the Fairmile D having depth charges. It had depth charges in real life, but apparently not in WarThunder. Maybe you have some additional sources?

"This version of the boat carried no torpedoes, but had a pair of Mk VII depth charges."

End of the second paragraph on the devblog page

Depth charge :

AKA anti submarine mine, those explosive devices are set to blow up at a set depth, usualy droped in numerous number they use the fact that water unlike air is not compressible to crush submarine hulls, leading to critical hull breaches

Therefore those are completly useless against any other target than submarine, since depth charge are never made to float

To use it against another ship would require do a kamikaze attack as it need to be detonated ON the target to do anything
最后由 Foxtrot39 编辑于; 2016 年 8 月 17 日 下午 6:24
kiro the avenger! 2016 年 8 月 18 日 上午 12:03 
引用自 Foxtrot39
引用自 Bogey
On the WarThunder page it doesn't say anything about the Fairmile D having depth charges. It had depth charges in real life, but apparently not in WarThunder. Maybe you have some additional sources?

"This version of the boat carried no torpedoes, but had a pair of Mk VII depth charges."

End of the second paragraph on the devblog page

Depth charge :

AKA anti submarine mine, those explosive devices are set to blow up at a set depth, usualy droped in numerous number they use the fact that water unlike air is not compressible to crush submarine hulls, leading to critical hull breaches

Therefore those are completly useless against any other target than submarine, since depth charge are never made to float

To use it against another ship would require do a kamikaze attack as it need to be detonated ON the target to do anything
they could be Hedgehog charges, they only exploded on contact with a large metal object (IE ships hull)
which was better because you'd know if you missed or not, and missing wouldnt create a lot of noise, making it harder for the sonarman to track the sub
Eftwyrd (已封禁) 2016 年 8 月 18 日 上午 12:42 
引用自 Foxtrot39
引用自 Bogey
On the WarThunder page it doesn't say anything about the Fairmile D having depth charges. It had depth charges in real life, but apparently not in WarThunder. Maybe you have some additional sources?

"This version of the boat carried no torpedoes, but had a pair of Mk VII depth charges."

End of the second paragraph on the devblog page

Depth charge :

AKA anti submarine mine, those explosive devices are set to blow up at a set depth, usualy droped in numerous number they use the fact that water unlike air is not compressible to crush submarine hulls, leading to critical hull breaches

Therefore those are completly useless against any other target than submarine, since depth charge are never made to float

To use it against another ship would require do a kamikaze attack as it need to be detonated ON the target to do anything

depth charges were occasionally used by small boats as a desperation move againt pursuers as set to go off at as shallow a depth as possible they could do serious damage to a surface ship (as you mention water not being compressable, explosions are amplified in water and depth charges dont require direct hits), forcing your pursuer to swerve or risk the hit below the waterline
最后由 Eftwyrd 编辑于; 2016 年 8 月 18 日 上午 12:49
Foxtrot39 2016 年 8 月 18 日 上午 10:12 
Well from the dev answering comment of the shooting range part 8 :

"Were not planning to add subs at the very beginning"

Subs aren't left out like arty are, like larger ship, we will see them down the line someday, until gaijin change their mind about it
最后由 Foxtrot39 编辑于; 2016 年 8 月 18 日 上午 10:12
kiro the avenger! 2016 年 8 月 18 日 上午 10:14 
引用自 Foxtrot39
Well from the dev answering comment of the shooting range part 8 :

"Were not planning to add subs at the very beginning"

Subs aren't left out like arty are, like larger ship, we will see them down the line someday, until gaijin change their mind about it
Gajin almost never flat out denies anything
especially because they know the ♥♥♥♥ storm would be a hell of a lot worse if they just said 'yeah subs wont work'
theyve already had a decent back lash just from saying 'capital ships most likely wont work'
Red 2016 年 8 月 18 日 下午 2:46 
引用自 kiro the avenger!
subs wont happen
theyre completely unsuited to ship-ship warefare, let alone boat-boat warefare
and even less the break-neck speed of gameplay gajin thinks we all require
then theres how much more theyd have to model in maps to accomodate them

cool that you get depth charges though, i guess. just dont be dumb enough to ram them up the arse and youre good

You should play a game called Battlestations: Pacific. It features subs, as well as ships, boats, fighters and bombers. The gameplay mechanics and controls are quite similar to WT from what i remember, also WWII era. But baring in mind it's kinda old now however, so the sim aspect isn't as realistic.

Anyway, Subs were a lot of fun and well balanced into the game.

I don't know about real life but the subs in that game weren't the biggest drag on game speed. PT boats and Destroyers were the only things faster. Cruisers, Carriers, Battleships usually couldn't out speed a sub, even if only by a few knots.
That was also baring in mind the sub is submerged, when surfaced it would gain a good 5 knots on its top speed.


< >
正在显示第 1 - 15 条,共 41 条留言
每页显示数: 1530 50

发帖日期: 2016 年 8 月 17 日 上午 10:03
回复数: 76