Why AMX-13 is now 6.3 while the Sherman FL10 is 4.7?

[Kwoh]

Why?
Its not like it is a 0.3 br of difference
Why the AMX-13 got 6.3 with a 10k repair cost for a light tank and the Sherman sits at 4.7 having the same gun? The AMX-13 mobility difference gives it a 0.3 br change at max. not a 1.3 BR in difference.

Same nation, same turret, same armor (AMX having less armor but the Sherman armor is not that great to compare) almost same mobility, same autoloader, but one being 1.3 BR higher and 10k to repair.

The american sherman M4A3 76W is a 5.3 tank having a inferior gun and without autoloader, and at 5.3 it's a great tank! So what absurd makes the FL10 sherman have 4.7? If it makes sense to anybody so why the AMX-13 being pretty much the same tank but at 6.3 and 10k repair? All of this don't make any sense.

[fruitbowl]

the fl10 gets uptiered 8/10 times anyway dude.

[Kwoh]

Originally posted by cool guy:

the fl10 gets uptiered 8/10 times anyway dude.

uptiered at 5.7, while the AMX13 gets 7.3

[kamikazi21358]

As someone who has the M4A1 (FL10), I can vouch it is overpowered.

[halolo39]

gaijin logic has run it course again, a few inherited design characteristics IRL made it good by the game get BR increased, most french post war tanks suffered from this. not helping matters are the obsurd repair cost, BR increase till it isnt effective anymore and gajin's refusal to make changes across the board I.E BR decompression to make it work. Hell the tiger doesnt deserve to be at 5.3 yet the AMX13 doing it's role perfectly gets dumped on.

[Kwoh]

Originally posted by halolo39:

gaijin logic has run it course again, a few inherited design characteristics IRL made it good by the game get BR increased, most french post war tanks suffered from this. not helping matters are the obsurd repair cost, BR increase till it isnt effective anymore and gajin's refusal to make changes across the board I.E BR decompression to make it work. Hell the tiger doesnt deserve to be at 5.3 yet the AMX13 doing it's role perfectly gets dumped on.

I didnt believe when I saw the AMX-13 got uptiered again, it was already a pain at 6.0 mainly because it the repair cost and had no more the support of the AMX M4, which should be a 6.0 tank minimum.

I made a thread where I compared every other nation spawnpoint costs and the french was the higher one with 60k plus to fix a lineup. And still they increased the cost and the BR

[halolo39]

Originally posted by k w o h:

I didnt believe when I saw the AMX-13 got uptiered again, it was already a pain at 6.0 mainly because it the repair cost and had no more the support of the AMX M4, which should be a 6.0 tank minimum.

I made a thread where I compared every other nation spawnpoint costs and the french was the higher one with 60k plus to fix a lineup. And still they increased the cost and the BR

i wouldnt mind a 6.3 AMX13 if its the 105mm version, but ffs we only have is the 75 and 90mm versions, doing its intended role of scouting and flanking just makes us lose SL for doing to correct way of playing.