Remove cannon barrel breaking in one hit

[Botboy3]

Make it two hits, atleast in AB.

[StingerRPG]

You know how stupid that sounds, right? What even prompted you to make this? What, can't take a 152 HE to the barrel?

[Botboy3]

Diposting pertama kali oleh StingerRPG:

You know how stupid that sounds, right? What even prompted you to make this? What, can't take a 152 HE to the barrel?

Oh yeah I forgot that every tank fires 152mm HE shells my bad.
In reality for Gameplay reasons it should take more than one hit, just like tank tracks. Tank tracks, atleast the devs said, that it should take two hits.

[StingerRPG]

Diposting pertama kali oleh Botboy3:

Diposting pertama kali oleh StingerRPG:

You know how stupid that sounds, right? What even prompted you to make this? What, can't take a 152 HE to the barrel?

Oh yeah I forgot that every tank fires 152mm HE shells my bad.
In reality for Gameplay reasons it should take more than one hit, just like tank tracks. Tank tracks, atleast the devs said, that it should take two hits.

I do not expect my fragile barrel to eat a shell even though there's probably going to be a gaping hole in the middle.

[Botboy3]

Diposting pertama kali oleh StingerRPG:

Diposting pertama kali oleh Botboy3:

Oh yeah I forgot that every tank fires 152mm HE shells my bad.
In reality for Gameplay reasons it should take more than one hit, just like tank tracks. Tank tracks, atleast the devs said, that it should take two hits.

I do not expect my fragile barrel to eat a shell even though there's probably going to be a gaping hole in the middle.

Barrels are more durable when getting shot than tracks imo. If anything tracks should be one hit-able and barrels two hittable.

[Xoho]

Diposting pertama kali oleh Botboy3:

Diposting pertama kali oleh StingerRPG:

I do not expect my fragile barrel to eat a shell even though there's probably going to be a gaping hole in the middle.

Barrels are more durable when getting shot than tracks imo. If anything tracks should be one hit-able and barrels two hittable.

All it takes is 1 little dent in your barrel to completely disable it. A single hit is accurate.

[Botboy3]

Diposting pertama kali oleh Xoho:

Diposting pertama kali oleh Botboy3:

Barrels are more durable when getting shot than tracks imo. If anything tracks should be one hit-able and barrels two hittable.

All it takes is 1 little dent in your barrel to completely disable it. A single hit is accurate.

And the same can be said for tracks. But for gameplay reasons they made it two hits in most cases. This is why, for gameplay purposes, they should also make the barrel two hits two break.

[Kartul]

Diposting pertama kali oleh Botboy3:

And the same can be said for tracks. But for gameplay reasons they made it two hits in most cases. This is why, for gameplay purposes, they should also make the barrel two hits two break.

Why don't we make other things 2 hits to disable too. For gameplay purposes.

[Botboy3]

Diposting pertama kali oleh Товарищ Potatovitch:

Diposting pertama kali oleh Botboy3:

And the same can be said for tracks. But for gameplay reasons they made it two hits in most cases. This is why, for gameplay purposes, they should also make the barrel two hits two break.

Why don't we make other things 2 hits to disable too. For gameplay purposes.

Major modules are different, but getting shot in the barrel and not being able to do anything its basically a free kill. In a 1v1, where skill should determine the winner, all you have to do is shoot the opponents barrel. It takes no skill and it just makes 1v1s super boring and harder to play tanks with long repairs on their guns.

[Kartul]

Diposting pertama kali oleh Botboy3:

Major modules are different, but getting shot in the barrel and not being able to do anything its basically a free kill. In a 1v1, where skill should determine the winner, all you have to do is shoot the opponents barrel. It takes no skill and it just makes 1v1s super boring and harder to play tanks with long repairs on their guns.

Well okay, you're free to rush someone if a part of their gun is damaged to the point of needing repair but it still takes skill (and a bit of luck) to destroy someone's gun barrel because it's not the easiest thing to hit, really. Especially if you're both wiggling and moving around trying to make the other miss a shot.

[Botboy3]

Diposting pertama kali oleh Товарищ Potatovitch:

Diposting pertama kali oleh Botboy3:

Major modules are different, but getting shot in the barrel and not being able to do anything its basically a free kill. In a 1v1, where skill should determine the winner, all you have to do is shoot the opponents barrel. It takes no skill and it just makes 1v1s super boring and harder to play tanks with long repairs on their guns.

Well okay, you're free to rush someone if a part of their gun is damaged to the point of needing repair but it still takes skill (and a bit of luck) to destroy someone's gun barrel because it's not the easiest thing to hit, really. Especially if you're both wiggling and moving around trying to make the other miss a shot.

I mean it is kinda skillless. I machine gunned a RU-251s barrel with my IS-4 after he shot mine. So it just turned into a who could repair their tank faster.

[VELOCIFRENK]

Arcade is already a joke

[Proteus]

Being able to disable a barrel via MG fire surely sounds like too much.

I don't mind if a barrel gets disabled by a direct AP hit, but at least it should be able to withstand MG fire or a few shrapnells by a HE explosion

[C4Cole]

i think it should give a accuracy debuff and when its completely red it should decrease the muzzle velocity by half

[DapperSpino]

muh gameplay balance

[Botboy3]

Diposting pertama kali oleh Proteus:

Being able to disable a barrel via MG fire surely sounds like too much.

I don't mind if a barrel gets disabled by a direct AP hit, but at least it should be able to withstand MG fire or a few shrapnells by a HE explosion

I understand large 100mm+ AP and HE shots, but it is kinda ridiculous when tanks with small calibers can just shoot my barrel and make me a moving bunker with a machine gun.