WHY AA IS BROKEN + Proof.

[Nobody410]

https://warthunder.com/en/tournament/replay/468489311752487742

tirsha
at 1:57 -> 2:03 The hit box is totaly broken. I see this a lot and it's NOT bcs proxi fuse.
(Adats don't use proxi)


--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
https://www.noelshack.com/2019-23-3-1559731034-20190605123350-1.jpg
https://www.noelshack.com/2019-23-3-1559731034-20190605123052-1.jpg
Missile pass over me from a LONG distance

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Here the broken Hit box.
https://www.noelshack.com/2019-23-3-1559731034-20190605123428-1.jpg
https://www.noelshack.com/2019-23-3-1559731034-20190605123453-1.jpg


AA is broken bcs the hit box is broken, fix it thanks.

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1761440725

[Ragnarok]

burg4401 eredeti hozzászólása:

Barneys Had Enough Of You. eredeti hozzászólása:

You cant dodge a good SPAA pilot. They are just far and in between.

And if a helo is dodging, they aren't being shot with missiles then. Nor are they able to really fight back.

like i said, i have seen one do it....so yes, you can....just because you can't and I know i can't, others can.....i wasted lots of ammo on that heli that game.

Thats probably a gun SPAA and those are slightly harder to hit.

Try using a MIssile SPAA. its auto deletion.

[ulzgoroth]

꧁Evil-tirsha꧂ eredeti hozzászólása:

Nono it's not on replay.
It's in real time.

In real time, what you see on the screen isn't necessarily perfectly synchronized with what's on the server. If you want to know whether the missile directly hit you, the server replay is more trustworthy than your actual gameplay.

Happyguy22 eredeti hozzászólása:

Example: AIM-1 (iirc) had a direct hit system. It was one of the worse missiles of the Vietnam war iirc.

AIM-4, probably. As best I can tell there never was an AIM-1

[Happyguy22]

ulzgoroth eredeti hozzászólása:

꧁Evil-tirsha꧂ eredeti hozzászólása:

Nono it's not on replay.
It's in real time.

In real time, what you see on the screen isn't necessarily perfectly synchronized with what's on the server. If you want to know whether the missile directly hit you, the server replay is more trustworthy than your actual gameplay.

Happyguy22 eredeti hozzászólása:

Example: AIM-1 (iirc) had a direct hit system. It was one of the worse missiles of the Vietnam war iirc.

AIM-4, probably. As best I can tell there never was an AIM-1

Yeah thats it, thanks.

[Edgrponce]

Cries in m163

[ShadowSutekh]

In the future please just stick to one thread on the same subject. Especially if you're the one that's posted both.

[S. Current]

I love people trying to say AA missiles and SPAA is too hard and kill helos but like seriously ask any real life helo pilot and they will say the same thing. AA is Anti Aircraft which means it is a danger to helos which is why you fly low and behind hills and ♥♥♥♥ to try and stay off radar and peak and fire. Everyone cried that helos are too op so they added a counter is this counter a legit fly swatter of anything flying yeah if you arn't trying to be smart about flying. Most helos i see in game fly close in or up high and don't realize that makes them such a easy target, fly low in cover and peak and take out AA or stand off a fair distance with some cover and try killing tanks. I feel people of war thunder are too used to WW2 style of combat and not realizing this is modernized war super close up CAS against a conventional force is rare cause of Radar, AA missiles, and hell a magical thing called MANPADs. I agree we should get some SEAD ♥♥♥♥ but its not in right now so you gotta live with out it and adapt to the battlefield.

[Ragnarok]

Sam Current eredeti hozzászólása:

I love people trying to say AA missiles and SPAA is too hard and kill helos but like seriously ask any real life helo pilot and they will say the same thing. AA is Anti Aircraft which means it is a danger to helos which is why you fly low and behind hills and ♥♥♥♥ to try and stay off radar and peak and fire. Everyone cried that helos are too op so they added a counter is this counter a legit fly swatter of anything flying yeah if you arn't trying to be smart about flying. Most helos i see in game fly close in or up high and don't realize that makes them such a easy target, fly low in cover and peak and take out AA or stand off a fair distance with some cover and try killing tanks. I feel people of war thunder are too used to WW2 style of combat and not realizing this is modernized war super close up CAS against a conventional force is rare cause of Radar, AA missiles, and hell a magical thing called MANPADs. I agree we should get some SEAD ♥♥♥♥ but its not in right now so you gotta live with out it and adapt to the battlefield.

1. Flying Low doesnt stop missiles or guns. Not yet anyway.
2. You cant fire over objects in a helo, so you're going to have to be in danger to do anything and goood luck trying to kill tanks without actually being up high. Sorry.
3. Flying low just makes you an easy kill for Sabot and machine gun fire.
4. Helos were overpowered and its their mechanics but not Anti Air is overpowered and there is no CAS in the game at 8.0+

[dan]

epic

[^0[.SAS.]^4HunterCat]

you probably should stop spaming those treads, it just shows how much cry baby you are

[The Black Raven]

Yeah that is the result of a proximity fuse.

[R.A.T. Army *MST3K*]

꧁Evil-tirsha꧂ eredeti hozzászólása:

Op as hell choper is 600% unplayable you can do NOTHING about AA

You're the OP.

[Nobody410]

I reworked the stuff.
Just hope admin saw this.
GlHf

[SilverWolverine]

this dude thinks all missiles have to hit, does he not know flak guns use timers/fuzed shells missiles no different. not everything required be guided in for a direct hit.

[cjl1w4g2]

https://steamcommunity.com/sharedfiles/filedetails/?id=1761987649
"Adats don't use proxi"

[Nobody410]

Ho god whats a death machine.