Rank the Amnesia games here

[Server Jester]

Ill start:
Dark Descent and Justine > Bunker > Machine for Pigs > Rebirth

[DarkMattNoir]

What political messages did you see in?

[(ADORA)ble 🌈👊]

Publicado originalmente por Pimp of Gennesaret:

1: Soma
2: All that remains

I agree. SOMA is one of the greatest games of all time, let alone one of the greatest horror games. I'll put it miles above A:DD and that's saying something because that game is a masterpiece too. But in the spirit of this topic here's my list: (bare in mind I haven't completed any of these games because they're too scary so story isn't taken into account)

1) The Dark Descent
2) A Machine for Pigs
3) The Bunker
4) Rebirth

Never played Justine.

[Pimp of Gennesaret]

Publicado originalmente por (ADORA)ble 🌈👊:

Publicado originalmente por Pimp of Gennesaret:

1: Soma
2: All that remains

I agree. SOMA is one of the greatest games of all time, let alone one of the greatest horror games. I'll put it miles above A:DD and that's saying something because that game is a masterpiece too. But in the spirit of this topic here's my list: (bare in mind I haven't completed any of these games because they're too scary so story isn't taken into account)

1) The Dark Descent
2) A Machine for Pigs
3) The Bunker
4) Rebirth

Never played Justine.

Justine honestly felt like an arcade more than anything, almost as if they've decided to incorporate an unused/test level into game's release. I don't hate it, but it certainly did not feel like amnesia

[Revalopod]

I think they're all pretty similar. TDD is probably still the best, I'd give it a 7/10, and then the rest are fairly ok in their own way, even AMFP, so they all get 6/10.

[Pimp of Gennesaret]

Publicado originalmente por Revalopod:

I think they're all pretty similar. TDD is probably still the best, I'd give it a 7/10, and then the rest are fairly ok in their own way, even AMFP, so they all get 6/10.

CR > B TD

[Angel in the Dark]

Only played 3 of them, Dark Descent > Bunker >>>> Rebirth

[Revalopod]

Publicado originalmente por Pimp of Gennesaret:

Publicado originalmente por Revalopod:

I think they're all pretty similar. TDD is probably still the best, I'd give it a 7/10, and then the rest are fairly ok in their own way, even AMFP, so they all get 6/10.

CR > B TD

I don't know what CR is.

[Pimp of Gennesaret]

Publicado originalmente por Revalopod:

Publicado originalmente por Pimp of Gennesaret:

CR > B TD

I don't know what CR is.

Clash royale, of course!

[DarkMattNoir]

Publicado originalmente por Pimp of Gennesaret:

Publicado originalmente por Revalopod:

I don't know what CR is.

Clash royale, of course!

[Pimp of Gennesaret]

Publicado originalmente por DarkMattNoir:

Publicado originalmente por Pimp of Gennesaret:

Clash royale, of course!

:cupdown:

Better than terraria too!

[Qwib-Qwib]

Bunker at the top, all the others behind at equal ranks.

I just love Bunker's emphasis on gameplay and intertwined systems, as well as its replayability. I've done 4 playthroughs so far. I might do another one later, even though I technically exhauted pretty much everything that was to do. I really think this game is the culmination of what makes Frictional Games so compelling, and I hope they'll keep that sort of direction in the future. The only thing that's missing is modifiers that impact gameplay more drastically that what we have now. Things like the new health system, the fuses mechanism or the save limitations.

That said, I'm open to most types of games, so I don't share other players' aversion for Machine for Pig and Rebirth. I like them all equally for what they're trying to do. Just not as much as Bunker. They're all flawed in various aspects that makes me like them a bit less than Bunker.

[SaSSolino]

S+: Bunker, SOMA
S: Dark Descent
A: ...
B: Rebirth, Pigs

SOMA is still my favorite Frictional Game, but Bunker is exceptional! Did not play Justine.

[Logantron]

Publicado originalmente por Comrade Rusty:

Dark Descent and Justine> Bunker >Rebirth >Machine for Pigs

Rebirth should always be last just because of the woke ♥♥♥♥.

[Pimp of Gennesaret]

Publicado originalmente por Logantron:

Publicado originalmente por Comrade Rusty:

Dark Descent and Justine> Bunker >Rebirth >Machine for Pigs

Rebirth should always be last just because of the woke ♥♥♥♥.

I know witless parroting is the second-best pastime for an average gamer, but can you please elaborate (I'm not even asking for "your" opinion, clearly that came from someone else) on how this game is "woke"? White wAmen having an affair with someone of arab/african descent isn't woke, it's what an absence of proper upbringing and a proud father does and is EXTREMELY common.

[Pulowski]

Publicado originalmente por Pimp of Gennesaret:

Publicado originalmente por Logantron:

Rebirth should always be last just because of the woke ♥♥♥♥.

I know witless parroting is the second-best pastime for an average gamer, but can you please elaborate (I'm not even asking for "your" opinion, clearly that came from someone else) on how this game is "woke"? White wAmen having an affair with someone of arab/african descent isn't woke, it's what an absence of proper upbringing and a proud father does and is EXTREMELY common.

it's time for you to find another forum to spend your life on mr pseudointellectual (type 1: anyone who agrees with my *educated* opinion is smart aka the fart-huffer archetype)

you've been stalking this thread for two years now...