Demon Recruiting difference from base game?

[Darsen-91]

The thing that I most hated in SMTV is the recruiting dialogue: totally nonsense and random.

In P5R you can understand the correct answer looking at the demon's type;
in SMTV it is random, only the full/new moon have predictable consequences.

I searched on google/reddit/forum, and there were no real guide to dialogue answers.

Do you know if they will change this in SMTVV?

[TSVStriFe]

The answers in SMTV aren't really random, they still go by what their type is. So for example Apparition is tiny/childlike, so he likes answers that has to do with childlike answers.

[Malkil]

Skill issue.

[solaris32]

All the SMT games are like that, where you been? I agree it's annoying.

[xEqualWhy]

The recruiting dialog being random hasn't been a thing in a long long time with the series. If you can't figure out a personality type can eventually brute force it just by paying attention.

[ZT-Sensei/Atra]

I think the only time it's random in SMT mainline is in IV and IVA(I've personally go out my way to check) in older games like SMT 1 and 2(? I forgot if 2 was the same as 1) it was based on if your int is high or not, in 3 and 5 it's based on your level and the kagutsuchi/moon phase(closer to new moon = easier to get, closer to full moon = impossible to get)

[Black Lamb, Rock Enjoyer]

IIRC, its % chance of success no? And some answers have higher %. I may be misremembering.

Edit: Yea, definitely misremembered.