Goose Goose Duck

Goose Goose Duck

View Stats:
Kaidalen Oct 8, 2021 @ 4:52pm
This looks oddly familiar
Deja Vu? Alternate reality? is the Simulation broken? I swear I have seen a game like this before
< >
Showing 1-15 of 19 comments
AlphaGodith Oct 9, 2021 @ 1:13pm 
i am honestly baffled that this level of copying of a trademarked game is being allowed
herbert  [developer] Oct 9, 2021 @ 1:45pm 
We're doing a ton of things differently, ranging from being free to having proximity chat and roles and different game modes. I know a lot of people reflexively want to call it a ripoff, but you might like it if you give it a chance. I'm obviously biased, but I think we are better in literally every single possible way
Last edited by herbert; Oct 9, 2021 @ 2:19pm
Nachtmahr Oct 9, 2021 @ 2:41pm 
It's funny how people judge this game because of the way it is, yet people also praise and buy all of the souls-likes, metroidvania 2D pixel retro platformer, and roguelite derivatives, despite them also only being "rip-offs", even with the same basic U.I.s that come with unity and UE4 assets and modules
Last edited by Nachtmahr; Oct 9, 2021 @ 2:41pm
Stevie Wonder Oct 10, 2021 @ 4:05am 
Originally posted by AlphaGodith:
i am honestly baffled that this level of copying of a trademarked game is being allowed
You cant trade mark game play mechanics lol.

comparing this to Amongus its like Comparing COD to BF. and saying COD or BF is trademarking stealing from BF/COD because they also shoot and go pew pew

lol
Sikari Oct 10, 2021 @ 6:54am 
Originally posted by herbert:
We're doing a ton of things differently, ranging from being free to having proximity chat and roles and different game modes. I know a lot of people reflexively want to call it a ripoff, but you might like it if you give it a chance. I'm obviously biased, but I think we are better in literally every single possible way
I agree. What's being done here reminds me a lot of (old) Blizzard. Most of Blizzard's games weren't ground breaking, but they took formulas and made them accessible and designed the way players wanted them to be. That's how Goose Goose Duck feels. There is still quite a bit of QoL and roles I'd like to see added, but they're not that similar at all.

You also have more reason to finish a game with the way cosmetics work in this game, and that's a huge plus.
bruh game genres exist you know
iTax Oct 10, 2021 @ 11:38pm 
Going by this logic, anything that was ever made can never be replicated and/or improved upon. Baseball game made in the 80s for the Atari? MLB The Show is ripping it off! Everquest existed before World of Warcraft? There should have been no reason for WoW to ever come along!
Shakzor Oct 11, 2021 @ 4:14am 
Social Deduction games were not invented by Among Us.
Stuff like Werewolves, Mafia, Town of Salem and whatnot existed long before.
This game is actually doing a lot of stuff differently and only really "copied" the structure of the innocents being able to win without HAVING to find the criminals and even that, i'm not sure if other games did it before Among Us, but adds to a game like this and let's the innocents actively work towards a win condition, rather than having to wait till someone gets murdered to actually start playing and let's them actually play if they got murdered aswell.

But man... kids really need to stop with this "it's the same genre, therefore copied *insert popular game here*". It's like saying Megami Tensei/Persona copied Dragon Quest because both are turn based.
Last edited by Shakzor; Oct 11, 2021 @ 4:15am
PileOPhish  [developer] Oct 11, 2021 @ 7:02am 
I've been in and around gaming for a long time and I can swear I've never seen a fan-base so dedicated to a single product that they claim anything remotely close is a rip-off and attack it for existing. I didn't realise we would be threatening people's identity by advancing a genre that they obviously like.

I get it, people love Among Us. So do we! That's why we did what we did because we wanted to bring it to the next level without having to wait for an update. We wanted to do things our way. Our way is different. Some people and and will be forever happy running around as a jelly-bean-like characters yelling "sus" while trying to find out if they are a crew-mate or impostor. We're not taking Among Us away from anyone. They already paid for it, they can still play it whenever they want. That's fine, but why they yap and bite at anything that comes remotely close to social deduction as a threat to their identity is beyond me.

I've been gaming longer than most of the people on Steam have been alive. Playing games IS part of my identity. Gaming was never about IP or brand loyalty... at least for me. It was about waiting to see what the developers built on. How we went from Tetris to Dr. Mario. to Match 3 games tells a story of evolution and it's something we should be excited about. I never once felt my identity as a gamer threatened by "newer" games. I still call Diablo II one of my all time favourites, but Path of Exile knocked the entire genre out of the park. Was it unique? Barely, but I didn't avoid it because at the heart of things I love games and I am confident enough in my own identity to just be able to enjoy something I like without fear of losing who I am.

When developers iterate and build upon a genre I get excited, not scared or defensive. The difference I suppose between playing games and making games is that you become severely detached when you make something. You can never truly enjoy playing it the way your player base does. You have to push yourself to imagine what they are thinking and feeling. One thing I never considered is that we would anger people just by existing. On the flip-side, the fact that so many people have come to the discussion boards and dropped us negative reviews after playing 0.1 hours with the comment "amogus" and we still have over 90% support from the community says we're doing something right.

We will continue to improve on the genre and grow with our loyal fan base. One day a better version of Goose Goose Duck will come out and people will play that one.
Last edited by PileOPhish; Oct 11, 2021 @ 7:05am
Cheesepizza2 Oct 12, 2021 @ 7:37pm 
team fortress two is a ripoff of among us because red spy sus!

ss13 is a ripoff of among us because clown sus!

werewolf is a ripoff of among us because sorcerer sus!

town of salem is a ripoff of among us because mafia sus!

(i'm honestly suprised people still play that piece of ♥♥♥♥ amoger game, much less claim it's the original in ANYTHING)
Paradox Oct 12, 2021 @ 9:17pm 
Among us
Imagine thinking this genre only belongs to one singular game.

Games from the very beginning of have been adaptations and inspiration done by OG game developers probably before I was even born and grew into the empire it is today. The gaming community hasn't grown due to people sitting on one particular genre and going "K guys. No one else can absolutely copy our formula in any sense of the word even if it's inspired and not the exact same."
- Ðemünhel - (Banned) Oct 15, 2021 @ 10:27am 
The first really popular fighting game was Street Fighter 2 on arcade before it hit super nintendo. Imagine if it took feedback every time a similar game was released ... (there are dozens of it since).
Last edited by - Ðemünhel -; Oct 20, 2021 @ 6:34pm
zmanbuilder Oct 15, 2021 @ 7:32pm 
i just want to say the old saying "Imitation is the highest form of flattery"
DOPEaMineFix Oct 28, 2021 @ 8:55am 
Among Us is now going to be copying GGD. Lol. They announced a new "shapeshifter" role coming. Watch them add proximity chat before next Summer lol.
< >
Showing 1-15 of 19 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Oct 8, 2021 @ 4:52pm
Posts: 19