Against the Storm

Against the Storm

View Stats:
Senrezu Apr 29, 2023 @ 4:41pm
Question about Service Buildings
Do they only effect the settlers that have their houses in the same fireplace area as the service building? Or is the effect global? Do the settlers actually physically wander to the service building to receive their beating or religious indoctrination?
< >
Showing 1-13 of 13 comments
el Darkness Apr 29, 2023 @ 4:51pm 
short: effect is global, your folks do not need to enter.

During each break your people go to nearest Hearth. During this break they check for their needs: housing, food (including complex food) and services. If they do not have needs fullfilled, nothing happens. If they have house, then they get up to 3 (or 6 if you built racial housing), if you have complex food, they will eat ALL complex food type they like and then their Resolve goes up, Services works in the same way.
Lil brekky Apr 29, 2023 @ 4:51pm 
Villagers satisfy all their possible needs when they visit the hearth for their break. Foods are magically consumed from the storage, and service goods magically consumed from staffed service buildings, while the consuming villager is at the hearth. Doesnt matter where that storage or service building is. So staffed and stocked Tavern in zone of Hearth A will buff visitors to Hearth A or B.

I doubt it is even necessary to have the service building inside hearth area at all to benefit.
Senrezu Apr 29, 2023 @ 4:54pm 
Thanks alot
Fire Apr 29, 2023 @ 6:51pm 
Originally posted by el Darkness:
short: effect is global, your folks do not need to enter.

During each break your people go to nearest Hearth. During this break they check for their needs: housing, food (including complex food) and services. If they do not have needs fullfilled, nothing happens. If they have house, then they get up to 3 (or 6 if you built racial housing), if you have complex food, they will eat ALL complex food type they like and then their Resolve goes up, Services works in the same way.

Actually houses bonus resolve is uptated in real time when the situation change (houses get built/destroyed/get more or less space etc.).
PhailRaptor Apr 29, 2023 @ 7:49pm 
Originally posted by Lil brekky:
I doubt it is even necessary to have the service building inside hearth area at all to benefit.

To reach Hearth T3 you will need to have a Service building completely inside the AoE the Hearth affects. But the Service Building's effect does not care whether the Service building is inside a Hearth's range or not.
Spacesuit Spiff Apr 29, 2023 @ 9:45pm 
Originally posted by el Darkness:
short: effect is global, your folks do not need to enter.

During each break your people go to nearest Hearth. During this break they check for their needs: housing, food (including complex food) and services. If they do not have needs fullfilled, nothing happens. If they have house, then they get up to 3 (or 6 if you built racial housing), if you have complex food, they will eat ALL complex food type they like and then their Resolve goes up, Services works in the same way.
Does a variety of complex food actually make them burn through food faster, or is the difference made up somewhere (ie they eat 3 foods, and then eat none on the next 2 breaks)? That would make a reward of 30 pickles or whatever much less useful if you're more concerned with food stocks than resolve.
Lil brekky Apr 29, 2023 @ 9:48pm 
They'll consume 1 of each thing they prefer, if theyre allowed and it is available. So yes - consumption control is critical if you need to be precious about reserves.
el Darkness Apr 30, 2023 @ 2:52am 
Originally posted by Fire:
Actually houses bonus resolve is uptated in real time when the situation change (houses get built/destroyed/get more or less space etc.).
Thanks for correcting me. :)
DrWolfmann Apr 30, 2023 @ 1:34pm 
Originally posted by Lil brekky:
They'll consume 1 of each thing they prefer, if theyre allowed and it is available. So yes - consumption control is critical if you need to be precious about reserves.

Hey Lil,

does this mean, for example, if some people prefer cake and cookies and both are available, they will consume two food? I always thought there will only one food consumed per rest, and then the best the settler prefers most.

TC, Stefan
el Darkness Apr 30, 2023 @ 2:02pm 
From my experience, your folks will try to eat one of EACH complex food they like. Same goes for services, Lizards would like to attend a mess and a fight during the same break. :)
LotusBlade May 1, 2023 @ 4:49am 
Few clarity thingies:
1) People who you put inside Service buildings will deliver service items from main storage to Service building's unique storage. You do not need to have all 3 slots taken, 1 is enough for delivery.

2) People consume 1 of each available Service/Food items, if they like that service. BUUUT! If there is only cookies in your storage, all people will eat cookies out of no choise in order to not starve. So yes, if someone loves pies, cookies and jerky, which are available in storage, he will eat all 3 at once to get three sources of resolve.

I am not sure what happens when they work on glade event. As far as i know, they do not go to break at all until job is done, but what happens to needs - can someone clarify? Cus player can just scam game by forcing super long glade events on purpose, preventing species to go on breaks.
koboldlord May 1, 2023 @ 5:42am 
The villagers won't have any negative effects from working on a long glade events. They'll take a break before they start unloading, though, and if you manually interrupt working the event they'll take a break before they go back on. I don't think this is practically exploitable, because most glade events have two or three slots and most of those with long timers have some bad side effect that is worse than just supplying enough extra food or services for two people.
Hollow Sep 30, 2024 @ 5:33am 
Reviving this for imporant information:
-yes, the service range is global
-for the level 3 heart upgrade you don't even need to have people in the service structure, so it can be entirely inactive and you still get your level 3 heart
-service structures lack critical information: Storage ! They can only serve needs while the items that are needed to provide the serivce are still stored inside the structure, which each villager using this service consumes once during a break. The maximum amount of items that can be stored inside a service structure is basically unlimited and only limited by the amount of workers it can have assigned multiplied by their carrying capacity for whatever service item they need to bring in. So services CAN GO DOWN despite having the structures, the people assigned and the necessary number of items IF they're drained too fast because of too many people. While the UI is otherwise good it's lacking for housing, services, haulers.
Housing: can't just assign specific people from specific workplaces to a specific house slot, so they benefit from a useful bonus
Services: if they truly want to be global they should get a storage limit that's at least as high as the number of people that could use this service, otherwise the UI should prompt that your services aren't 100% covered but only x%, depening on the total amount of items stored in relation to the population
Haulers: Not a fan of these. They're bad. With automated carts you don't even have any unit control over them. I can never get them to do what I actually want and what would be useful because of the lack of proper unit control. First of all they should only work for structures they're assigned to. Second: Each structure should be able to define what action haulers are allowed or not allowed to do: take items, bring items, for which production or of which specific type (overrides the "for which production") setting. That way they'd be far more useful and under control. Haulers also don't get a UI element at any warehouse to display the bonus effects they benefit from.

Originally posted by LotusBlade:
Few clarity thingies:I am not sure what happens when they work on glade event. As far as i know, they do not go to break at all until job is done, but what happens to needs - can someone clarify? Cus player can just scam game by forcing super long glade events on purpose, preventing species to go on breaks.
Active bonus effects for your people keep being active or fade with each break that "updates" the effects according to needs met or not met. Otherwise they could starve during a too long glade event. Villagers don't take a break before they start a glade event but that's just something that may happen, so you need to watch the indicator, which is why I always assign them first and then wait until the UI shows me they're ready and good to go before starting work on an event, with sometimes the UI failing to show any icon at all for some time, for some reason.
Last edited by Hollow; Sep 30, 2024 @ 5:44am
< >
Showing 1-13 of 13 comments
Per page: 1530 50

Date Posted: Apr 29, 2023 @ 4:41pm
Posts: 13