Objective Souls game Tier List

[REVOLVER OCELOT]

With the latest announcement of the GaaS slop that's been announced due to this game's disappointing popularity, I decided to take it upon myself to make the first objective ranking of Souls games to help people decide on their purchases.

It is as follows:

1: Dark Souls

2: Sekiro

3: Bloodborne

4: Demon's Souls

5: Dark Souls 3

6: Elden Rong

7: Dark Souls 2

Hopefully this post can inspire some intellectual discourse and help people steer away from the worst games in the series.

[zero]

any list with sekiro on it fails to understand what makes a souls like a souls like

[JustGeorge]

Fromsoft, where even their weakest games are still better than what other companies give us

[Senki]

Originally posted by JustGeorge:

Fromsoft, where even their weakest games are still better than what other companies give us

only if you're a fanboy that doesn't actually play many games

[REVOLVER OCELOT]

Originally posted by Fahrenheit:

Hopefully you get banned for spamming the forum with the same post every other day

I'm not gonna lie, I put a lot of effort into my posts to enjoy and share critical intellectual discussion with other likeminded fans of the series, so I don't super appreciate the accusation. But I don't want this to go too off-topic so I'll leave it there.

[REVOLVER OCELOT]

Originally posted by zero:

any list with sekiro on it fails to understand what makes a souls like a souls like

Sekiro was an incredibly interesting branch off the souls path, and is wonderful imo.

[zero]

Originally posted by REVOLVER OCELOT:

Originally posted by zero:

any list with sekiro on it fails to understand what makes a souls like a souls like

Sekiro was an incredibly interesting branch off the souls path, and is wonderful imo.

the lack of character, build, and utility variety, along with fundamentally losing nothing on death makes it not a souls-like as far you can call it one.

its an rpg, sure, might even be a good one, but as a souls-game it fails to deliver the souls-like experience in any measure, to have it high(or even on) any souls-like list just shows a lack of understanding of what makes a souls-like good.

between that and putting DS1: clunkville which required community patches to even work on pc that high up shows a whole other realm of issues as well.

[Senki]

Originally posted by zero:

along with fundamentally losing nothing on death

you do lose things on death, you actually lose a whole lot more than in any souls game on death because it isn't recoverable

I used to think it's not a soulslike but honestly it's hard not to see it at least as a failed abortion of one with how much design it borrows from souls games.

[REVOLVER OCELOT]

Originally posted by zero:

Originally posted by REVOLVER OCELOT:

Sekiro was an incredibly interesting branch off the souls path, and is wonderful imo.

the lack of character, build, and utility variety, along with fundamentally losing nothing on death makes it not a souls-like as far you can call it one.

its an rpg, sure, might even be a good one, but as a souls-game it fails to deliver the souls-like experience in any measure, to have it high(or even on) any souls-like list just shows a lack of understanding of what makes a souls-like good.

between that and putting DS1: clunkville which required community patches to even work on pc that high up shows a whole other realm of issues as well.

It's the most pared down, sure, but the exploration, bonfire system, punishing combat and being forced to learn the game's systems are all there.

Calling DS1 "clunkville" is crazy, my man. It's got the best world out of all the From games, and was the perfect balance of character build variety without being giga-huge and bloated like ER.

[zero]

Originally posted by REVOLVER OCELOT:

Originally posted by zero:

the lack of character, build, and utility variety, along with fundamentally losing nothing on death makes it not a souls-like as far you can call it one.

its an rpg, sure, might even be a good one, but as a souls-game it fails to deliver the souls-like experience in any measure, to have it high(or even on) any souls-like list just shows a lack of understanding of what makes a souls-like good.

between that and putting DS1: clunkville which required community patches to even work on pc that high up shows a whole other realm of issues as well.

It's the most pared down, sure, but the exploration, bonfire system, punishing combat and being forced to learn the game's systems are all there.

Calling DS1 "clunkville" is crazy, my man. It's got the best world out of all the From games, and was the perfect balance of character build variety without being giga-huge and bloated like ER.

the bonfire system is just check points, might as well call final fantasy games souls-like by that metric

any game can be hard "punishing" as you call it, but if all your doing is playing a desginated character with no build variety and not losing anything upon death aside from characters getting "sick"(which does nothing) then you're just playing an rpg, not a souls-like.

and you might wanna take off the rose tinted glasses, dark souls 1 is clunk for sure, there is a reason everyone remembers backstab circling in that game, for good reason.

[Norm Macdonald's Ghost]

Originally posted by REVOLVER OCELOT:

Originally posted by Fahrenheit:

Hopefully you get banned for spamming the forum with the same post every other day

I'm not gonna lie, I put a lot of effort into my posts to enjoy and share critical intellectual discussion with other likeminded fans of the series, so I don't super appreciate the accusation. But I don't want this to go too off-topic so I'll leave it there.

Trash panda is a ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ connoisseur.

[lost horizon]

sekiro is not soulslike its a tenchu game. see wrath of heaven ps2

[Sabaithal]

Originally posted by REVOLVER OCELOT:

Hey Snek! In kapitolist Murica is it true the banks rob you?!

Oh god no plz no more insane questions cat person!

[Nxce]

Yet another guy claiming his subjective opinion is objective...

[Sirius]

"Objective"
Proceeds to straight lists an opinion.

Classic Ocelot.

[Burdpal]

I would not smoke a blunt with you.