Renna

[Mollymawk]

NG+: does still Renna start at the church and give me wolf ash? I can't get her to show up.

[echo_ML]

I don't think so. You should already have the wolf ashes and the spirit-calling bell.

If you don't and have gotten later in the game, you can find them with the Twin Maiden husks at roundtable.

[Lord Bob]

Did you make Melina show up at the Gatefront site of grace or Agheel Lake North site of grace first?

She won't show up if you haven't talked to Melina first, and she will have moved on for good if you went past a certain point (I believe it was fighting Godrick or leaving Limgrave, not sure right now)

[Mollymawk]

Yes, I talked to Melenia about torrent. Then went for Renna. I've been back several times and still no show.

This is my first NG+ but I've restarted a new character dozens of times. I am good at getting the horse, whetstone and wolf ashes very quickly and efficiently.

[Mollymawk]

wolf ashes are at round table so I guess the quest just moved on on its own.

[echo_ML]

Originally posted by Mollymawk:

This is my first NG+ but I've restarted a new character dozens of times. I am good at getting the horse, whetstone and wolf ashes very quickly and efficiently.

I'm confused. All of those items transfer to NG+. You don't need to get them again.

[Artek [General]]

Originally posted by echo_ML:

Originally posted by Mollymawk:

This is my first NG+ but I've restarted a new character dozens of times. I am good at getting the horse, whetstone and wolf ashes very quickly and efficiently.

I'm confused. All of those items transfer to NG+. You don't need to get them again.

I think he says that he started a new fresh character a couple of times.

[Lord Bob]

Originally posted by Mollymawk:

Yes, I talked to Melenia about torrent. Then went for Renna. I've been back several times and still no show.

This is my first NG+ but I've restarted a new character dozens of times. I am good at getting the horse, whetstone and wolf ashes very quickly and efficiently.

You also need to make sure it's night time, and reload the area by warping to Church of Elleh after making sure it's night, just in case.

edit:
If you rest at one of either sites of grace I mentioned earlier and make Melina show up for the first time, time will progress to night automatically. After accepting her accord and getting Torrent, riding to Church of Elleh right away should make Renna show up, at least when you rest the Church of Elleh site of grace.

[Greywander]

IIRC, Renna only shows up:
- After you've received Torrent's whistle from Melina
- During the night, at the Church of Elleh
- Before Melina invites you to the Roundtable Hold

Either you didn't return to the Church of Elleh at night, or you triggered Melina to invite you to the Roundtable Hold. It's possible she doesn't show up in NG+, but I don't know that for sure.

If you somehow missed meeting Renna, you can still buy the Wolf ashes at the Roundtable Hold.

The cutscene where Melina gives you Torrent's whistle sets the time to night, so you can immediately warp back to the Church of Elleh and meet Renna. That's usually what I do. I could see if it's your first time playing that you might miss it, but once you know there isn't really any reason to delay talking to Renna.

[roba]

You have to teleport there, walking does not work. Just fast-travel / teleport to the site of grace and she will be there. I was trying to come there in night, rest there, wait there - nothing. Once you teleport, there she is.