Kill Kenneth Haight?

[PAPI SHREK]

Is it true he is worthless after getting him back to the top of the castle and receiving the dagger? No other way to get the Golden Seed?

[Meewec]

i think he's needed to get an ancient dragon stone. you shouldn't need the golden seed by the end of the game.

[upset]

Honestly, it doesn't really matter, there's Golden Seeds everywhere once you reach the Altus.

And on principle, most NPCs are kinda worthless, in the sense that none of your choices really impact anything other than you either get an item, or can't get one. That's what NG is for.

[Lord Bob]

The Golden Seed might seem tempting in the early game, but be assured that you'll find more of them than you'll ever need. Doing his questline is the only way to get two Erdsteel Daggers in one playthrough outside of trading.

[Greywander]

There's more than enough Golden Seeds in the game to max out your flasks. I'm not sure if he's required to get the Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone, I think probably not, but I don't really see a reason to kill him and I find him to be a likable character. I know YMMV on that point, but bro goes through a whole character arc from being apprehensive about getting help from a tarnished to putting another tarnished on the throne of Stormveil instead of himself. He's one of the few characters in the game that actually seems to be genuinely good.

[Z5]

Originally posted by Greywander:

There's more than enough Golden Seeds in the game to max out your flasks. I'm not sure if he's required to get the Ancient Dragon Smithing Stone, I think probably not, but I don't really see a reason to kill him and I find him to be a likable character. I know YMMV on that point, but bro goes through a whole character arc from being apprehensive about getting help from a tarnished to putting another tarnished on the throne of Stormveil instead of himself. He's one of the few characters in the game that actually seems to be genuinely good.

U need him for the stone and it's 2 stones because u can buy other one from other NPC

[Dizzy Ladybug]

it's true, Kenneth isn't needed for any ancient stones. you just need to keep Gostoc alive and complete Nepheli's quest. Nepheli will give you the ancient stone in the Stormveil throneroom and you can buy the other from Gastoc after

[SoundsOfNight]

Dude...no!!! Completing his 3 NPC quest gives you TWO Dragon stones.

[SoundsOfNight]

Originally posted by dizzy ladybug:

it's true, Kenneth isn't needed for any ancient stones. you just need to keep Gostoc alive and complete Nepheli's quest. Nepheli will give you the ancient stone in the Stormveil throneroom and you can buy the other from Gastoc after

Interesting, I never woulda thought that. But the ladybug speaks!

[Phasma]

:o