(SPOILERS) Rating main DLC bosses from best to worst

[Goro]

main bosses are those who give a remembrance, all spoilers unmarked.



1. Romina, Saint of the Bud
2. Midra, Lord of the Frenzied Flame
3. Messmer, The Impaler
4. Scadutree Avatar
5. Divine Beast, Dancing Lion
6. BAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAYLE the Dread
7. Putrescent Knight
8. Metyr, Mother of Fingers
9. Rellana, Twin Moon Knight


998. Commander Gaius


999. The final boss.

[Drax]

1. Putrescent Night
2. Messmer
3. Radahn
4. Midra
5. Divine Beast
6. Bayle
7. Romina
8. Rellana
9. Metyr
10. Scadutree

999. Commander Gaius

Only boss I dislike is Gaius... I still enjoyed even the Scadutree fight.

[Mr. Nobody]

Honestly I didn't mind Commander Gaius. Kind of boring but nothing annoying to me. I'm convinced it must be something do with always using a light roll build because I had no issue dodging any of his attacks yet I see tons of complaints about his hitboxes especially his charge attack.

The Divine Beast gave me borderline motion sickness and whiplash from the camera movement so that's the worst of the main bosses for me.

[Titty]

I will not stand this Gaius slander. You may dislike him personally, but this low of a rating is just lying to oneself.

[Goro]

Originally posted by Lynfinity:

I will not stand this Gaius slander. You may dislike him personally, but this low of a rating is just lying to oneself.

true, i should have placed him lower.
jokes aside i would still put him in position 10 since i didn't really like the fight.

THE final boss however i outright hate.

[BudgieGaming]

S - Messmer, Bayle, Metyr
A - Radahn, Midra, Scadutree, Divine Dragon
B - Putrescent, Gaius, Rellana
C - Romina
D - All NPC bosses because they will forever suck for me

[Eastersimulator]

imo gaius was worse then the final boss. I can't dodge his charge and for some reason it sometimes oneshots me. But just sometimes.

[idomori]

Scadutree isn't hard to beat since it's 3x weak to flame but that doesn't mean it's a well designed boss with its stupid AOE spams. I'd put it right before gaius

I wouldnt say dancing lion is bad design but it has technical issues with the camera. You don't want to lock on to it.

[Reginald's Body is Ready]

Originally posted by BudgieGaming:

S - Messmer, Bayle, Metyr
A - Radahn, Midra, Scadutree, Divine Dragon
B - Putrescent, Gaius, Rellana
C - Romina
D - All NPC bosses because they will forever suck for me

Im really curious why people like Metyr. She is probably one of the most unfun bosses in the entire game for me. Nonstop attacks with little to no counter-attack time, Phase 2 with bs lasers and the constant flying away, and she can spawn small enemies that, while not dangerous, you need to take care of while she either jumps at you at lightning speed or just lasers you. Idk, she would be at one of the lowest ranks if I were to rank her among all bosses from Ds1, Ds2, Ds3 and this game. Romina was a joke compared to her and ive done most other dlc bosses while taking breaks from this fight because its honestly not remotely fun for me. She'd probably share the Spot with Gaius for me as the worst DLC boss. But maybe Im also just dumb and doing something wrong in the fight, knowing me that could be true too, but im really curious why you like her enough to put her in S Tier

[echo_ML]

1: Bayle the Dread
2:Messmer the Impaler
3:Rellena
4;Scadu Avatar
5:Divine Beast Lion
6:Putrescent Knight
7:Commander Gaius
8:Midra
9:Metyr


Deepest pit of hell: Radahn

Edit: Shoot, forgot Romina. She's prob between Scadu and Lion. Don't really feel that strongly about her.

[Jámez Bondo]

Gaius is a pine cone riding a boar. Without legs, no less. How dare you?

[Elymnir]

1. Bayle. Most fair fight (in my opinion at least), incredible visuals (the wings when he enters phase 2) and, of course, Igon's totally over the top performance.

2. Putrescent Knight. Also extremely fair, not too aggressive. Visually disgusting, in a good way.

3. Messmer. Quite the challenge, but still fair, and it's really fun once you start to "get the dance".

4. Scadutree avatar. Fair moves, with the exception of the magic salvo. Thorns require precise timing, but that's okay. And it's a giant sunflower, which is as funny as the weapon it gives.

5. Surprisingly, Commander Gaius. A bit too aggressive, but has clear opnings. The charge's hitbox forced me to play with the raven's AoW so that's why he's mid.

6. Romina. Nothing much to say. Good fight but not memorable.

7. Midra is an all-round good fight, but I can't dodge his nuke, even by running.

8. Metyr. Honestly the easiest fight I had. I'm absolutely delighted by the cosmic horror vibes. Plus, she's got no ♥♥♥♥♥♥♥♥ moves, everything has a good tell. She's only down here because she spawns adds, and I hate adds. To me, it's the level 0 in boss design originality (unless their serve a mechanical purpose other than "annoy the s**t out of the player").

9. Divine beast. Love the visuals, love how it moves, love the music. But the cocain'd camera plus AoE spam does him bad.

10. Final boss. Excellent first phase. Challenging but immensely rewarding once you get the trick behind every move. Then comes the phase 2 and it ruins everything, including my eyes. Bonus point for his dive bomb at 20%. I don't know how to avoid this thing. Wherever I run, he still lands right on top of me. Dodging didn't work much either. I know it's avoidable, since I saw videos of people avoiding it, but to me it's still a f**k you move.

11. Rellana. Miss, could you please stop attacking.

[zab]

1. Messmer
2. Divine beast lion dancer
3. Putrescent knight
4. Scadutree avatar
5. Midra
6. Rellana
7. Romina
8. Gaius
9. Final boss
10. Metyr
11. Bayle