Frenzies Flame Ending Question

[Archdeacon Monseigneur]

So i am aware that accepting the three finger's "blessing" will lock you into the age of chaos ending, and that it can be reverted should the player wish to.

here's my question; if i finish the game with the age of chaos ending, will that "haunt" me into my next playthrough?
like what are the pros and cons here?
if i revert the three finger's blessing using the needle, will i lose the Frenzied Flame Seal?
will Melania ever talk to me again in following playthroughs, if i inherit the frenzied flame in my former playthrough?

really wish the game would give more detail on this stuff, because as it is, i am left to guessing, and being left to guessing has screwed me out of numerous questlines already.

[Lord Bob]

Originally posted by JaggSauce:

So i am aware that accepting the three finger's "blessing" will lock you into the age of chaos ending, and that it can be reverted should the player wish to.

here's my question; if i finish the game with the age of chaos ending, will that "haunt" me into my next playthrough?
like what are the pros and cons here?
if i revert the three finger's blessing using the needle, will i lose the Frenzied Flame Seal?
will Melania ever talk to me again in following playthroughs, if i inherit the frenzied flame in my former playthrough?

really wish the game would give more detail on this stuff, because as it is, i am left to guessing, and being left to guessing has screwed me out of numerous questlines already.

No ending has any consequences on ng+ unfortunately.

If you revert it you will keep the frenzied flame seal.

No, Melina just disappears for good in your current playthrough, and acts like nothing happened when you go to ng+.

[Lord Bob]

I was hoping for the same actually. My first ending was Rannisand I hoped it would transfer into ng+,putting the lands between into an endless cycle of night for example.
It was really disappointing to say the least to find out that no ending has any influence on the second journey whatsoever.
It sounds kind of obvious but endings really are just there to end the game in some way and that's about it.

[Codester]

Nope, ng+ functions like every other ng+ in the world.
The sad truth is most people will never beat the game. So creating extra content for after 100+ hours in a single player focused game would just be silly business practice.

[Archdeacon Monseigneur]

thanks for the replies.
so if i understand correctly, there is absolutely no consequences to finishing this questline except for the impact on your current playthrough, and NOT finishing it screws you out of the frenzied flame seal, so finishing it should be a priority, right?

do i get a different item if i don't complete it and keep Melania around? or melina or whatever her name is... the chick that gives you the horse.

[Lord Bob]

Originally posted by JaggSauce:

thanks for the replies.
so if i understand correctly, there is absolutely no consequences to finishing this questline except for the impact on your current playthrough, and NOT finishing it screws you out of the frenzied flame seal, so finishing it should be a priority, right?

do i get a different item if i don't complete it and keep Melania around? or melina or whatever her name is... the chick that gives you the horse.

Exactly, only for your current playthrough and not finishing it screws you out of getting the frenzied flame seal.

No, you just don't get any item at all. Melina "leaves" one way or another, either by calling you cringe for receiving the blessing of the Three Fingers orby kindling herself to burn the Erdtree if you have never met the Three Fingers

[Ghostorias]

Frenzied Flame ending is my favourite ending but like most people i ended up doing Ranni's on my First playthrough and i'm on NG+7 now i don't think i've missed an ending

Edit: i've not done Goldmasks ending but honestly i don't think i'll complete NG+7 soon i like doing the PvP at level 125