Soul Grinders got in!

[Wh♂♂par]

Can't wait!

Also, little that was not revealed so far in the roster reveal, but the Soul Grinder made up for it! (For me)

[Mactalon]

Publicado originalmente por victorlopezdelosmozogomez:

This unit is from 40k. isn't it?

It's from 8th edition Fantasy, what was that nonsense you were saying before about having played the game before?

[𝒦.ℒ.ℬ.]

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

Publicado originalmente por 𝓚ℒ𝔅.:

perfectly fitting unit the soul grinder? o:

Being a 40K unit, it's anything but perfectly fitting.

it fits beautifully, hence why CA added it bud. :]

woop woop cant wait to see it man, u hype?

[Dean Winchester]

Publicado originalmente por Mactalon:

Publicado originalmente por victorlopezdelosmozogomez:

This unit is from 40k. isn't it?

It's from 8th edition Fantasy, what was that nonsense you were saying before about having played the game before?

Nope. It's based on a unit from 40k, it was ported to WHFB in 8th edition. Lots of people hated its addition.

Publicado originalmente por 𝓚ℒ𝔅.:

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

Being a 40K unit, it's anything but perfectly fitting.

it fits

Most certainly not. It's a robotic mech from 40K.

[SpaceGoatMage]

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

Publicado originalmente por Mactalon:

It's from 8th edition Fantasy, what was that nonsense you were saying before about having played the game before?

Nope. It's based on a unit from 40k, it was ported to WHFB in 8th edition. Lots of people hated its addition.

Ok, thens its an 8th edition model that can be used in 40k just like all the other daemons.

[Mactalon]

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

Nope. It's based on a unit from 40k, it was ported to WHFB in 8th edition. Lots of people hated its addition.

So yes, it's from 8th Ed Fantasy, hence why it's in this game.

Lots of people loved its addition. Such is life.

[EnStorEn]

Soul Grinder was 40k first, then ported to Fantasy. And most in the TT community think its fugly, not that secondaries on this board would know that...

[Dean Winchester]

Publicado originalmente por Mactalon:

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

Nope. It's based on a unit from 40k, it was ported to WHFB in 8th edition. Lots of people hated its addition.

So yes, it's from 8th Ed Fantasy, hence why it's in this game.

Lots of people loved its addition. Such is life.

Being from 8th edition doesn't somehow mean it fits the setting. And about half of the people didn't love it. It was a controversial addition.

[Mactalon]

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

Publicado originalmente por Mactalon:

So yes, it's from 8th Ed Fantasy, hence why it's in this game.

Lots of people loved its addition. Such is life.

Being from 8th edition doesn't somehow mean it fits the setting. And about half of the people didn't love it. It was a controversial addition.

Lol saw it played in dozens of games, was at games days and comps, and part of the community during that time, nobody ever seemed to mind or care. More people seemed to just enjoy it or not care than anything else.
People complained Thorgrim and Archaon and other characters were OP, Skaven didn't get an 8th Ed book, the Ogres were too ridiculous and other things but the Soul Grinder more or less just existed and people didn't care. I'm sure there were some but never really came up at any event.

[Dean Winchester]

Publicado originalmente por Mactalon:

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

Being from 8th edition doesn't somehow mean it fits the setting. And about half of the people didn't love it. It was a controversial addition.

Lol saw it played in dozens of games, was at games days and comps, and part of the community during that time, nobody ever seemed to mind or care. More people seemed to just enjoy it or not care than anything else.
People complained Thorgrim and Archaon and other characters were OP, Skaven didn't get an 8th Ed book, the Ogres were too ridiculous and other things but the Soul Grinder more or less just existed and people didn't care. I'm sure there were some but never really came up at any event.

None of your anecdotal "evidence" changes anything, nor does it change the fact that it was a highly controversial unit. It's controversial even on the TW forums and reddit.

[Mactalon]

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

Publicado originalmente por Mactalon:

Lol saw it played in dozens of games, was at games days and comps, and part of the community during that time, nobody ever seemed to mind or care. More people seemed to just enjoy it or not care than anything else.
People complained Thorgrim and Archaon and other characters were OP, Skaven didn't get an 8th Ed book, the Ogres were too ridiculous and other things but the Soul Grinder more or less just existed and people didn't care. I'm sure there were some but never really came up at any event.

None of your anecdotal "evidence" changes anything, nor does it change the fact that it was a highly controversial unit. It's controversial even on the TW forums and reddit.

None of your non-anything-evidence changes anything either, but we had different experiences of it back when it came out apparently. I just don't take you at your word since I was active at the time and heard nothing about it being controversial and you've proffered nothing to suggest it was.

Heard plenty of other complaints, Warhammer having one of the most vocally whiny consumer bases about every little thing and all, but that one never came up which you'd think it would have given how "controversial" it was, based on nothing.

[Dean Winchester]

Publicado originalmente por Mactalon:

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

None of your anecdotal "evidence" changes anything, nor does it change the fact that it was a highly controversial unit. It's controversial even on the TW forums and reddit.

None of your non-anything-evidence changes anything either, but we had different experiences of it back when it came out apparently. I just don't take you at your word since I was active at the time and heard nothing about it being controversial and you've proffered nothing to suggest it was.

Heard plenty of other complaints, Warhammer having one of the most vocally whiny consumer bases about every little thing and all, but that one never came up which you'd think it would have given how "controversial" it was, based on nothing.

It's a fact that the unit was controversial. You can find numerous posts on it, on the TW forums, and reddit posts even today. You can find people here that don't like it myself included. It's a fact that it's a controversial unit and has been for almost a decade. Just because you haven't seen them doesn't mean it didn't happen. That's an issue of ignorance on your end.

[Funky Monk]

Wish we had slaughterbrutes

[Velber]

Publicado originalmente por ϺEƳEƦ:

Absolutely love the look of this unit. It is so terrifying and nasty looking!! Just to clarify though, does the soul grinder have a range weapon? and if so what is it?

seems like it had a rifle like gun for its left arm, so it may shoot small projectiles

[Mactalon]

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

Publicado originalmente por Mactalon:

None of your non-anything-evidence changes anything either, but we had different experiences of it back when it came out apparently. I just don't take you at your word since I was active at the time and heard nothing about it being controversial and you've proffered nothing to suggest it was.

Heard plenty of other complaints, Warhammer having one of the most vocally whiny consumer bases about every little thing and all, but that one never came up which you'd think it would have given how "controversial" it was, based on nothing.

It's a fact that the unit was controversial. You can find numerous posts on it, on the TW forums, and reddit posts even today. You can find people here that don't like it myself included. It's a fact that it's a controversial unit and has been for almost a decade. Just because you haven't seen them doesn't mean it didn't happen. That's an issue of ignorance on your end.

Or more likely it was a storm in a teacup.

[Dean Winchester]

Publicado originalmente por Mactalon:

Publicado originalmente por SteadilyPhysical:

It's a fact that the unit was controversial. You can find numerous posts on it, on the TW forums, and reddit posts even today. You can find people here that don't like it myself included. It's a fact that it's a controversial unit and has been for almost a decade. Just because you haven't seen them doesn't mean it didn't happen. That's an issue of ignorance on your end.

Or more likely it was a storm in a teacup.

Most certainly not. Check the TW forums, reddit, other sources. The soulgrinder is a contentious unit and has always been. This is simply an issue of ignorance on your end.