Can you save Sazza without the evil stuff?

[bulldog0890]

so apparently saving her leads to some evil choices. but can you just sorta go along with it and stop?

[Elazul]

Why would you want to? She's an evil goblin. Killing her is an act of good or you'll be to blame for any further harm she causes.

[bulldog0890]

Originally posted by Elazul:

Why would you want to? She's an evil goblin. Killing her is an act of good or you'll be to blame for any further harm she causes.

shooting a dude in a cage with a crossbow seems bad

[Humble]

Originally posted by bulldog0890:

Originally posted by Elazul:

Why would you want to? She's an evil goblin. Killing her is an act of good or you'll be to blame for any further harm she causes.

shooting a dude in a cage with a crossbow seems bad

dude? I thought it's female goblin in the jail. I guess it's would be call cage, but you are correct, it's wrong to kill someone who trapped in jail. It's should fair public trial since she already in locked up in jail.

[bulldog0890]

Originally posted by Humble:

Originally posted by bulldog0890:

shooting a dude in a cage with a crossbow seems bad

dude? I thought it's female goblin in the jail. I guess it's would be call cage, but you are correct, it's wrong to kill someone who trapped in jail. It's should fair public trial since she already in locked up in jail.

well whatever, freeing them seems like the "better" choice. i just don't wanna ride it all the way to the dark side

[Texas BourBun Alice (She/Her)]

Originally posted by bulldog0890:

Originally posted by Elazul:

Why would you want to? She's an evil goblin. Killing her is an act of good or you'll be to blame for any further harm she causes.

shooting a dude in a cage with a crossbow seems bad

She wants to murder everyone else there.

[Settings]

Saving her isn't evil. Siding with the Goblins is.

[Texas BourBun Alice (She/Her)]

Originally posted by bulldog0890:

Originally posted by Humble:

dude? I thought it's female goblin in the jail. I guess it's would be call cage, but you are correct, it's wrong to kill someone who trapped in jail. It's should fair public trial since she already in locked up in jail.

well whatever, freeing them seems like the "better" choice. i just don't wanna ride it all the way to the dark side

"freeing the serial killer being held prisoner and actively making threats seems like the 'better' choice"
dude

[solaris32]

Originally posted by bulldog0890:

Originally posted by Elazul:

Why would you want to? She's an evil goblin. Killing her is an act of good or you'll be to blame for any further harm she causes.

shooting a dude in a cage with a crossbow seems bad

It is. That's why you stop the killing, then leave her in the cell.

[Jaggid Edje]

I don't see how she will possibly get what could be called a "fair trial" given the circumstances.

I don't disagree that outright killing her while she's locked in a cage is undeniably not a very good thing to do. But it's not like any trial is going to be at all "fair" either. Her execution is a foregone outcome, either way.

I am playing a paladin on my 2nd playthrough, and I actually struggled with what to do when it came to her. I mean, I obviously didn't let them just shoot her in the cage. Helping her escape obviously also comes with a lot of not-so-good ramifications, so I didn't do that. But leaving her there, she's not going to get a fair trial.

She should have been killed instead of captured on the battlefield, would have been much more neat and tidy from a morality standpoint.

Would have been nice to have a prisoner exchange offer, btw. Exchange her for the druid, for example. That would have been the cleanest solution to the whole situation for someone who wants to see good outcomes.

[Quineloe]

Originally posted by bulldog0890:

Originally posted by Elazul:

Why would you want to? She's an evil goblin. Killing her is an act of good or you'll be to blame for any further harm she causes.

shooting a dude in a cage with a crossbow seems bad

just correcting the mistake of catching the vermin alive in the first place.

[Quineloe]

Originally posted by Jaggid Edje:

I don't see how she will possibly get what could be called a "fair trial" given the circumstances.

I don't disagree that outright killing her while she's locked in a cage is undeniably not a very good thing to do. But it's not like any trial is going to be at all "fair" either. Her execution is a foregone outcome, either way.

I am playing a paladin on my 2nd playthrough, and I actually struggled with what to do when it came to her. I mean, I obviously didn't let them just shoot her in the cage. Helping her escape obviously also comes with a lot of not-so-good ramifications, so I didn't do that. But leaving her there, she's not going to get a fair trial.

She should have been killed instead of captured on the battlefield, would have been much more neat and tidy from a morality standpoint.

ah yes, lawful convenient.

[Jaggid Edje]

Originally posted by Quineloe:

ah yes, lawful convenient.

Like I said (in my edit), I'd have loved if Larian had put in an option to pursue a prisoner exchange. Her for the druid, or even her for Volo. Would have been a nice way to resolve the dilemma.

[Quineloe]

There is no way Minthara would trade either of those for a stupid gobbo

[Jaggid Edje]

Originally posted by Quineloe:

There is no way Minthara would trade either of those for a stupid gobbo

I agree, but it would have been nice to at least have the option to try. :)

[Mr.Hmm]

I left her in the cell and made sure to magically lock the cell so she could never get away, fast-forward after erasing the goblins she died in the cell, I dunno who did it but good riddance.